Fraud on the European Union emissions trading scheme: effects, vulnerabilities and regulatory reform

Nield, K. and Pereira, R. 2011. Fraud on the European Union emissions trading scheme: effects, vulnerabilities and regulatory reform. European Energy and Environmental Law Review. 20 (6), pp. 255-289.

TitleFraud on the European Union emissions trading scheme: effects, vulnerabilities and regulatory reform
AuthorsNield, K. and Pereira, R.
Abstract

As the European Union Emissions Trading Scheme (EU ETS) has grown in size and value, it has become an increasingly attractive playground for fraudsters. The past two years have seen value-added-tax (VAT) fraud and emissions allowance thefts emerge as major threats to the EU ETS market. This study explores the effects that these forms of fraud have had on parts of the EU carbon market; uncovers vulnerabilities in the regulation of the registries (the ``banks'' of accounts in which emissions allowances are kept and from which they are traded) and the oversight of the EU ETS market; and analyses the adequacy and wider implications of the regulatory reforms recently proposed by the European Commission. A series of semi-structured interviews conducted for this study exposes a significant amount of discomfort amongst stakeholders regarding the proposed reforms to the regulation of the registries system, which is felt could still leave the system vulnerable to fraud and its effects. The potential extension of the EU financial markets oversight regulations has also led to fear that the future regulatory framework may be disproportionately burdensome for some market participants, potentially compromising the cost-efficiency of this emissions abatement tool. Moreover, the paper highlights the difficulties involved in the investigation and prosecution of fraud in the carbon markets and assesses the extent to which recent developments in EU criminal law, in particular since the ratification of the Lisbon Treaty in 2009, hold the potential to overcome some of the existing barriers to the effective criminal law cooperation between the Member States.

JournalEuropean Energy and Environmental Law Review
Journal citation20 (6), pp. 255-289
ISSN1879-3886
YearDec 2011
PublisherKluwer International
Publication dates
PublishedDec 2011

Related outputs

Financial crimes in the European carbon markets
Nield, K. and Pereira, R. 2016. Financial crimes in the European carbon markets. in: Weishaar, S. (ed.) Research Handbook on Emissions Trading Cheltenham Edward Elgar. pp. 195-231

Pollution from seabed activities
Pereira, R. 2016. Pollution from seabed activities. in: Attard, D., Fitzmaurice, M., Martinez, N. and Hamza, R. (ed.) IMLI manual on international maritime law: volume III: Marine environmental law and international maritime Ssecurity law Oxford Oxford University Press.

Environmental criminal liability and enforcement in European and international law
Pereira, R. 2015. Environmental criminal liability and enforcement in European and international law. Brill.

Government-Sponsored Population Policies and Indigenous Peoples: Challenges for International Human Rights Law
Pereira, R. 2015. Government-Sponsored Population Policies and Indigenous Peoples: Challenges for International Human Rights Law. Netherlands Quarterly of Human Rights. 33 (4), pp. 437-483.

The Cartagena protocol on living modified organisms: the regulation of trade in transgenic organisms under international and European environmental law
Pereira, R. 2014. The Cartagena protocol on living modified organisms: the regulation of trade in transgenic organisms under international and European environmental law. in: Benedict, M.Q. (ed.) Transgenic insects: techniques and applications CABI.

Permanent sovereignty over natural resources in the 21st century: natural resource governance and the right to self-determination of indigenous peoples under international law
Pereira, R. and Gough, O. 2013. Permanent sovereignty over natural resources in the 21st century: natural resource governance and the right to self-determination of indigenous peoples under international law. Melbourne Journal of International Law. 14 (2), pp. 451-495.

The case for regulating nanotechnologies: international, European and national perspectives
Ngarize, S., Makuch, K. and Pereira, R. 2013. The case for regulating nanotechnologies: international, European and national perspectives. Review of European Community and International Environmental Law. 22 (2), pp. 131-145.

A legal framework for clean technology transfer and finance
Wright, H. and Pereira, R. 2012. A legal framework for clean technology transfer and finance. in: Makuch, K. and Pereira, R. (ed.) Environmental and energy law Wiley. pp. 75-91

International and EU climate change law
Pereira, R. and Jourdain, C. 2012. International and EU climate change law. in: Makuch, K. and Pereira, R. (ed.) Environmental and energy law Wiley. pp. 141-171

The regionalization of criminal law: the example of European criminal law
Pereira, R. 2012. The regionalization of criminal law: the example of European criminal law. in: van den Herik, L. and Stahn, C. (ed.) The diversification and fragmentation of international criminal law Brill.

The exploration and exploitation of energy resources in international law
Pereira, R. 2012. The exploration and exploitation of energy resources in international law. in: Makuch, K. and Pereira, R. (ed.) Environmental and energy law Wiley. pp. 199-224

Environmental regulation, business competitiveness and corporate responsibility
Pereira, R. 2012. Environmental regulation, business competitiveness and corporate responsibility. in: Makuch, K. and Pereira, R. (ed.) Environmental and energy law Wiley. pp. 61-74

Compliance and enforcement in international, European and national environmental law
Pereira, R. 2012. Compliance and enforcement in international, European and national environmental law. in: Makuch, K. and Pereira, R. (ed.) Environmental and energy law Wiley. pp. 559-574

The regulation of nanotechnologies
Ngarize, S., Makuch, K. and Pereira, R. 2012. The regulation of nanotechnologies. in: Makuch, K. and Pereira, R. (ed.) Environmental and energy law Wiley. pp. 437-462

UK climate change law and policy
Makuch, K., Makuch, Z., Pereira, R. and Jourdain, C. 2012. UK climate change law and policy. in: Makuch, K. and Pereira, R. (ed.) Environmental and energy law Wiley. pp. 172-192

The clean development mechanism: legal and contractual framework in CDM renewable energy projects
Aidelojie, K., Tze-Teo, C., Makuch, Z. and Pereira, R. 2012. The clean development mechanism: legal and contractual framework in CDM renewable energy projects. in: Makuch, K. and Pereira, R. (ed.) Environmental and energy law Wiley. pp. 288-310

The legal basis for harmonisation of environmental criminal law in the EU: past and future challenges
Pereira, R. 2011. The legal basis for harmonisation of environmental criminal law in the EU: past and future challenges. in: Andenas, M. and Andersen, C.B. (ed.) Theory and practice of harmonisation Edward Elgar. pp. 403-424

The right to reproductive self-determination of indigenous peoples under human rights law
Pereira, R. 2009. The right to reproductive self-determination of indigenous peoples under human rights law. in: Berking, S. and Zolkos, M. (ed.) Between life and death: governing population in an era of human rights Peter Lang.

On the legality of the ship-source pollution 2005/35/EC directive: the Intertanko case and selected others
Pereira, R. 2008. On the legality of the ship-source pollution 2005/35/EC directive: the Intertanko case and selected others. European Energy and Environmental Law Review. 17 (6), pp. 372-383.

Environmental criminal law in the first pillar: a positive development for environmental protection in the European Union?
Pereira, R. 2007. Environmental criminal law in the first pillar: a positive development for environmental protection in the European Union? European Energy and Environmental Law Review. 16 (10), pp. 254-268.

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/8zq1q/fraud-on-the-european-union-emissions-trading-scheme-effects-vulnerabilities-and-regulatory-reform


Share this
Tweet
Email