Compromised critique: a meta-critical analysis of American studies after 9/11

Bond, L. 2011. Compromised critique: a meta-critical analysis of American studies after 9/11. Journal of American Studies. 45 (4), pp. 733-756.

TitleCompromised critique: a meta-critical analysis of American studies after 9/11
AuthorsBond, L.
Abstract

This paper contends that 9/11 remains subject to a crisis in criticism, resulting from the failure of certain strains within American studies to sufficiently separate their modes of critique from the ideological means of 9/11's manipulation. An overreliance upon themes of trauma, and a failure to observe the means by which these discourses have been compromised by their mobilization in political rhetoric, has led to the development of an interpretative void unable to produce a much-needed counternarrative. Whilst the explicit politicization of 11 September has been widely criticized, far less remarked upon is the extent to which the tropes in which 9/11 is represented have been standardized across popular, political, critical and artistic narratives. Failure to challenge the basic terms of this movement has engendered a compromised interpretative field, in which frames of reference slip too easily between the public and the personal, simultaneously militarizing mourning and sentimentalizing politics. This compromises counterhegemonic narratives, neutering the force of their thrust by presenting them as echoing, and even reinforcing, the discourses of the public–political realm. I will contend that this crisis of representation has arisen, at least in part, from the ubiquity of traumatic narratives, which have been transferred across discursive realms, disguising crucial authorial and critical differences, and seeming to validate the perspective of the state by testifying to an apparent unity of interpretation and response.

JournalJournal of American Studies
Journal citation45 (4), pp. 733-756
ISSN0021-8758
YearNov 2011
PublisherCambridge University Press
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)doi:10.1017/S0021875811000934
Publication dates
PublishedNov 2011

Related outputs

Introduction: Planetary memory in contemporary American fiction
Bond, L., de Bruyn, B. and Rapson, J. 2017. Introduction: Planetary memory in contemporary American fiction. Textual Practice. 31 (5), pp. 853-866.

‘In the eyeblink of a planet you were born, died, and your bones disintegrated’: scales of mourning and velocities of memory in Philipp Meyer’s American Rust
Bond, L. 2017. ‘In the eyeblink of a planet you were born, died, and your bones disintegrated’: scales of mourning and velocities of memory in Philipp Meyer’s American Rust. Textual Practice. 31 (5), pp. 995-1016.

Introduction: memory on the move
Bond, L., Craps, S. and Vermeulen, P. 2016. Introduction: memory on the move. in: Bond, L., Craps, S. and Vermeulen, P. (ed.) Memory Unbound: Tracing the Dynamics of Memory Studies New York and Berlin Berghahn Books. pp. 1-26

Frames of memory after 9/11: culture, criticism, politics, and law
Bond, L. 2015. Frames of memory after 9/11: culture, criticism, politics, and law. London Palgrave Macmillan.

Introduction
Bond, L. and Rapson, J. 2014. Introduction. in: Bond, L. and Rapson, J. (ed.) The transcultural turn: interrogating memory between and beyond borders Berlin, Germany De Gruyter. pp. 1-26

Types of transculturality: narrative frameworks and the commemoration of 9/11
Bond, L. 2014. Types of transculturality: narrative frameworks and the commemoration of 9/11. in: Bond, L. and Rapson, J. (ed.) The transcultural turn: interrogating memory between and beyond borders Berlin, Germany De Gruyter. pp. 61-80

From the stricken community to the solitary night mind: the politics of time, space, and otherness in American fiction after 9/11
Bond, L. 2014. From the stricken community to the solitary night mind: the politics of time, space, and otherness in American fiction after 9/11. in: Levene, M. (ed.) Political fiction Amenia, New York, USA Salem Press. pp. 21-41

Intersections or misdirections? Problematising crossroads of memory in the commemoration of 9/11
Bond, L. 2012. Intersections or misdirections? Problematising crossroads of memory in the commemoration of 9/11. Culture, Theory and Critique. 53 (2), pp. 111-128.

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/8zq3w/compromised-critique-a-meta-critical-analysis-of-american-studies-after-9-11


Share this
Tweet
Email