Science and environmental law: collaboration across the double helix

McEldowney, J. and McEldowney, S. 2011. Science and environmental law: collaboration across the double helix. Environmental Law Review. 13 (3), pp. 169-198.

TitleScience and environmental law: collaboration across the double helix
AuthorsMcEldowney, J. and McEldowney, S.
Abstract

Science engages both substantially and methodologically with environmental law more than with any other law subject. Collaboration between environmental lawyers and scientists is essential in the development of sustainable solutions to environmental problems. Law and science are distinct disciplines with their own autonomy and methodology. Science claims objective facts as reality, while law seeks to reconcile different understandings or disputes about facts. Legal truth and scientific truth may seem to be at odds with each other. In the policy field scientific expertise can be in conflict with political or media perspectives; nevertheless effective legislation has to be based on sound science. Judicial opinion is often reliant on science but may struggle to accommodate it within legal doctrines. In this paper we put the intersection of law and science under scrutiny in an effort to address what is seen as one of the ‘structural sources’ of environmental law scholarship used in defining environmental problems. Our approach is interdisciplinary as the integration of science with law provides a normative influence over environmental law and has greatest potential to shape the future of environmental law scholarship. Interdisciplinarity requires recognition of differing methodologies but also the facility to collaborate across the disciplinary divide. This is illustrated by examples such as the influence of risk assessment and the precautionary principle; EU legislation such as REACH, the Water Framework Directive (WFD); and the demands of regulating new developments such as GMOs. We argue for a greater mutual dialogue and understanding between law and science that supports a reflexive learning approach that crosses disciplines and is based on the principles of evaluation and justification. Both inductive and deductive forms of reasoning contribute to the dialogue and science is regarded not as an autonomous and external input into law and environmental policy making, but as intrinsic to the regulatory process. In contemporary society science is embedded in the legal and administrative culture in which it is a partner more than in the past. Science helps establish the facts and data as well as the techniques of evaluation, which are essential for sustainable environmental regulation. We argue that the existing epistemological/methodological framework must shift to accommodate a different perspective that is sufficiently reflexive to promote effective learning specifically linked to solutions that correspond to identifiable environmental problems. Reflexive learning processes should engage with the changing and diverse approaches to regulatory styles of governance and the diffuse and complex nature of environmental problems.

JournalEnvironmental Law Review
Journal citation13 (3), pp. 169-198
ISSN1461-4529
YearAug 2011
PublisherVathek Publishing
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)doi:10.1350/enlr.2011.13.3.128
Publication dates
PublishedAug 2011

Related outputs

Contemporary issues in environmental law and policy
McEldowney, J. and McEldowney, S. 2020. Contemporary issues in environmental law and policy. Cheltenham Edward Elgar.

Sustainable Chemical Regulation in a Global Environment
McEldowney, S. 2017. Sustainable Chemical Regulation in a Global Environment. in: Tan, C. and Faundez, J. (ed.) Natural Resources and Sustainable Development: International Economic Law Perspectives. Cheltenham Edward Elgar. pp. 257-276

Buttressing volatile desktop grids with cloud resources within a reconfigurable environment service for workflow orchestration
Winter, S., Reynolds, C.J., Kiss, T., Terstyanszky, G., Greenwell, P., McEldowney, S., Acs, S. and Kacsuk, P. 2014. Buttressing volatile desktop grids with cloud resources within a reconfigurable environment service for workflow orchestration. Journal of Cloud Computing: Advances, Systems and Applications. 3 (1), p. 1.

Meeting demand: water strategy, policy and legislation
McEldowney, S. 2014. Meeting demand: water strategy, policy and legislation. in: Booth, C.A. and Charlesworth, S.M. (ed.) Water resources in the built environment: management issues and solutions Chichester Wiley. pp. 11-22

Large-scale virtual screening experiments on Windows Azure-based cloud resources
Kiss, T., Borsody, P., Terstyanszky, G., Winter, S., Greenwell, P., McEldowney, S. and Heindl, H. 2014. Large-scale virtual screening experiments on Windows Azure-based cloud resources. Concurrency and Computation: Practice and Experience. 26 (10), pp. 1760-1770.

Molecular docking: a potential tool to aid ecotoxicity testing in environmental risk assessment of pharmaceuticals
Walker, S. and McEldowney, S. 2013. Molecular docking: a potential tool to aid ecotoxicity testing in environmental risk assessment of pharmaceuticals. Chemosphere. 93 (10), pp. 2568-2577.

Application repository and science gateway for running molecular docking and dynamics simulations
Terstyanszky, G., Kiss, T., Kukla, T., Lichtenberger, Z., Winter, S., Greenwell, P., McEldowney, S. and Heindl, H. 2012. Application repository and science gateway for running molecular docking and dynamics simulations. in: Gesing, S., Glatard, T., Kruger, J., Delgado Olabarriaga, S., Solomonides, T., Silverstein, J.C., Montagnat, J., Gaignard, A. and Krefting, D. (ed.) Healthgrid applications and technologies meet science gateways for life sciences IOS Press.

Bioinformatics: a potential tool for ecotoxicity testing of pharmaceuticals
Walker, S. and McEldowney, S. 2010. Bioinformatics: a potential tool for ecotoxicity testing of pharmaceuticals. Society of environmental toxicology and chemistry UK annual meeting 2010: ‘environmental pollution in a changing world’. 13-14th Sept 2010

River sediment sampling and analysis for selected heavy metals: establishing a practical protocol
Mokwe-Ozonzeadi, N.U., McEldowney, S., Foster, I. and Valsami-Jones, E. 2010. River sediment sampling and analysis for selected heavy metals: establishing a practical protocol. Society of environmental toxicology and chemistry UK annual meeting 2010: ‘environmental pollution in a changing world’. 13-14th Sept 2010

Science and environmental regulation in a period of financial constraint
McEldowney, S. and Owen, R. 2010. Science and environmental regulation in a period of financial constraint. Law, Science and Policy. 3, pp. 209-255.

L’eau: reguler une ressource naturelle dans un climat economique changeant
McEldowney, J. and McEldowney, S. 2010. L’eau: reguler une ressource naturelle dans un climat economique changeant. in: Les enjeux de la gestion locale de l’eau, droit et gestion des collectives territoriales Paris Groupe Moniteur. pp. 259-274

Environmental law
McEldowney, J. and McEldowney, S. 2010. Environmental law. Harlow Longman.

Sound science and environmental monitoring: a case study of pharmaceuticals in aquatic environments
Walker, S. and McEldowney, S. 2009. Sound science and environmental monitoring: a case study of pharmaceuticals in aquatic environments. William Smith meeting: environmental pollution and human health. London

Pharmaceuticals in water and regulatory concerns
Walker, S. and McEldowney, S. 2009. Pharmaceuticals in water and regulatory concerns. Society of environmental toxiocology and chemisty annual meeting: environment and human health. London

An experimental investigation of the effect of Bacillus megaterium on apatite dissolution
Hutchens, E., Valsami-Jones, E., Harouiya, N., Chairat, C., Oelkers, E.H. and McEldowney, S. 2006. An experimental investigation of the effect of Bacillus megaterium on apatite dissolution. Geomicrobiology Journal. 23 (3-4), pp. 177-182.

Viewpoint: science education and the public interest
McEldowney, S. 2005. Viewpoint: science education and the public interest. Law, Science and Policy. 2, pp. 251-268.

Science education and the public interest
McEldowney, S. 2005. Science education and the public interest. Law, Science and Policy. 2, pp. 251-268.

Viewpoint: science and the future
McEldowney, S. 2004. Viewpoint: science and the future. Law, Science and Policy. 2, pp. 101-113.

EU chemicals policy - a foundation for environmental protection or a missed opportunity?
McEldowney, S. 2004. EU chemicals policy - a foundation for environmental protection or a missed opportunity? in: Etty, T.F.M., Somsen, H., Kramer, L., Lee, M. and Scott, J. (ed.) Yearbook of European environmental law Oxford, UK Oxford University Press.

The role of heterotrophic bacteria in feldspar dissolution: an experimental approach
Hutchens, E., Valsami-Jones, E., McEldowney, S., Gaze, W. and McLean, J. 2003. The role of heterotrophic bacteria in feldspar dissolution: an experimental approach. Mineralogical Magazine. 67 (6), pp. 1157-1170.

The influence of heterotrophic bacteria and fungi on K-feldspar dissolution
Hutchens, E., Valsami-Jones, E. and McEldowney, S. 2003. The influence of heterotrophic bacteria and fungi on K-feldspar dissolution. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta. 67 (18, Supp. 1), p. A163.

The precautionary principle: the British perspective
McEldowney, S. 2001. The precautionary principle: the British perspective. in: Guardiola, B. and El Feki, S. (ed.) La prevention et la protection dans la societe du risque: le principe de precaution Elsevier.

A case study in environmental risk and its assessment in the BSE epidemic: lessons for the future
McEldowney, S. 2001. A case study in environmental risk and its assessment in the BSE epidemic: lessons for the future. in: Anglo-Japanese Academy Proceedings of the Conference on National, Regional and Global Transition: a common agenda for Anglo-Japanese relations in the twenty-first century, 07-08 Sep 2001, Tokyo, Japan Tokyo, Japan ICCLP Publication. pp. 305-312

Environmental law and regulation
McEldowney, J. and McEldowney, S. 2001. Environmental law and regulation. London, UK Blackstone.

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/8zqyw/science-and-environmental-law-collaboration-across-the-double-helix


Share this
Tweet
Email