The limits to good governance and the state of exception: a case study of North Sea fisheries

Griffin, L. 2010. The limits to good governance and the state of exception: a case study of North Sea fisheries. Geoforum. 41 (2), pp. 282-292.

TitleThe limits to good governance and the state of exception: a case study of North Sea fisheries
AuthorsGriffin, L.
Abstract

This paper explores a series of maxims, widely known in policy and academic circles as the ‘principles of good governance’, which state that policymaking in the European Union (EU) should be participatory, conducted as close to citizens as practicable, transparent, accountable, effective and coherent. These maxims were introduced into EU fisheries management as part of a radical reform of the Common Fisheries Policy (CFP) in 2002. This reform was instituted in response to criticisms of a prevailing management regime alleged to be inefficient, undemocratic, and potentially responsible for an environmental crisis: the exhaustion of key fish stocks. The research for this work has found that there are limits to the actual achievement of good governance in EU fisheries. In practice governance innovations are very often contradictory and rife with tensions. I reason that such problems result not merely from policy implementation failures; they constitute a more endemic feature of the CFP reforms. We can begin to understand these limits to good governance principles by looking to Agamben’s permanent state of exception thesis. Agamben’s theory helps to show how these contradictions and tensions occur under new governance regimes, because the relationship between democratic norms (like good governance) and political power is no longer clear. I argue that this blurring has been exploited by groups seeking influence in these new regimes. They do this through citing a supposed need for emergency measures to mitigate crisis. Although this research broadly supports the state of exception thesis, my analysis leads me to question some aspects of its application in contemporary governance spaces.

JournalGeoforum
Journal citation41 (2), pp. 282-292
ISSN0016-7185
YearMar 2010
PublisherElsevier
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)doi:10.1016/j.geoforum.2009.10.007
Publication dates
PublishedMar 2010

Related outputs

Good governance, scale and power: a case study of North Sea fisheries
Griffin, L. 2013. Good governance, scale and power: a case study of North Sea fisheries. Abingdon Routledge.

Where is power in governance?
Griffin, L. 2010. Where is power in governance? Perspectives on Political Science. 10 (2), pp. 208-220.

Fishing for the public interest: making and representing publics in North Sea fisheries governance reform
Griffin, L. 2010. Fishing for the public interest: making and representing publics in North Sea fisheries governance reform. in: Mahoney, N., Newman, J. and Barnett, C. (ed.) Rethinking the public: innovations in research, theory and politics Bristol Policy Press. pp. 107-126

Editorial: Governance innovation for sustainability:exploring the tensions and dilemmas
Griffin, L. 2010. Editorial: Governance innovation for sustainability:exploring the tensions and dilemmas. Environmental Policy & Governance. 20 (6), pp. 365-369.

What are the consequences of the 'spatial turn' for how we understand politics today? A proposed research agenda
Pugh, J. and Griffin, L. 2009. What are the consequences of the 'spatial turn' for how we understand politics today? A proposed research agenda. Progress in Human Geography. 33 (5), pp. 579-586.

Scales of knowledge: North Sea fisheries governance, the local fisherman & the European scientist
Griffin, L. 2009. Scales of knowledge: North Sea fisheries governance, the local fisherman & the European scientist. Environmental Politics. 18 (4), pp. 557-575.

Food security and fisheries governance
Griffin, L. 2009. Food security and fisheries governance. in: Fagan, H. and Munck, R. (ed.) Globalisation and Security Praeger Press.

The North Sea fisheries crisis and good governance
Griffin, L. 2008. The North Sea fisheries crisis and good governance. Geography Compass. 2 (2), pp. 452-475.

All aboard: power, participation and governance in the North Sea regional advisory council
Griffin, L. 2007. All aboard: power, participation and governance in the North Sea regional advisory council. International Journal of Green Economics. 1 (3/4), pp. 478-493.

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/90334/the-limits-to-good-governance-and-the-state-of-exception-a-case-study-of-north-sea-fisheries


Share this
Tweet
Email