Will there Be fallout from Clementi? The global repercussions for the legal profession after the UK Legal Services Act 2007

Flood, J. 2008. Will there Be fallout from Clementi? The global repercussions for the legal profession after the UK Legal Services Act 2007. Jean Monnet/Robert Schuman Paper Series Vol. 8 No. 6.

TitleWill there Be fallout from Clementi? The global repercussions for the legal profession after the UK Legal Services Act 2007
AuthorsFlood, J.
TypeDiscussion paper
Abstract

The paper presents the historical arguments that led to the Clementi review of the legal profession and its culmination in the Legal Services Act 2007. There were two strands: one based on consumerism (too many complaints about lawyers' services); the other based on a sustained investigation by the competition authorities into professions' restrictive practices (anti-competitive unless proved in the public interest). These led to the abandonment of traditional forms of organization for lawyers' practices (alternative business structures) and the imposition of a new regulatory structure for the profession (oversight and frontline regulators). In the second part of the paper I examine the trends in lawyers' practices as currently pursued and as envisaged by the Act as aligned with our conceptions of professionalism. Using two hypotheticals: Tesco Law, and Goldman Sachs Skadden, I chart a move from professionalism to deskilling and proletarianization in the legal profession, not unlike that which existed in the 19th century. This dystopian view, which is essentially a top down conception of the legal industry, is contrasted with a more optimistic view based on the changes in the idealization of careers and life as represented by Generation Y. This is augmented by the changing nature of work, ie, post-Fordist, within organizations which in a number of ways escapes control and measurement because the distinctions between production and consumption, work and leisure allied with distributed network forms of production blur the boundaries that we have taken for granted. In contrast to the socio-economic approaches, I argue that we must examine conceptions of career, inclusion and exclusion, vocation, and community in order to understand how the professions will adapt to the postmodern condition.

KeywordsClementi, legal profession, lawyer
YearApr 2008
PublisherJean Monnet/Robert Schuman Paper Series Vol. 8 No. 6
Publication dates
PublishedApr 2008
Web address (URL)http://www6.miami.edu/EUCenter/publications/FloodLong08ClementiEdi.pdf

Related outputs

What do lawyers do? An ethnography of a large law firm
Flood, J. 2013. What do lawyers do? An ethnography of a large law firm. New Orleans Quid Pro.

Entrepreneurship, managerialism and professionalism in action: the case of the legal profession in England and Wales
Muzio, D. and Flood, J. 2012. Entrepreneurship, managerialism and professionalism in action: the case of the legal profession in England and Wales. in: Reihlen, M. and Werr, A. (ed.) Handbook of research on entrepreneurship in professional services Edward Elgar. pp. 369-386

Becoming a cosmopolitan lawyer
Flood, J. and Lederer, P.D. 2012. Becoming a cosmopolitan lawyer. Fordham Law Review. 80 (6), pp. 2523-2539.

Transnational lawyering: clients, ethics and regulation
Flood, J. 2012. Transnational lawyering: clients, ethics and regulation. in: Mather, L. and Levin, L. (ed.) Lawyers in practice: ethical decision making in context University of Chicago Press. pp. 176-196

The re-landscaping of the legal profession: large law firms and professional re-regulation
Flood, J. 2011. The re-landscaping of the legal profession: large law firms and professional re-regulation. Current Sociology. 59 (4), pp. 507-529.

Legal education in the global context: challenges from globalization, technology and changes in government regulation
Flood, J. 2011. Legal education in the global context: challenges from globalization, technology and changes in government regulation. Legal Services Board.

Straight there, no detours: direct access to barristers
Flood, J. and Whyte, A. 2009. Straight there, no detours: direct access to barristers. International Journal of the Legal Profession. 16 (2&3), pp. 131-152.

Structuring transactions: the case of real estate finance
Flood, J. 2009. Structuring transactions: the case of real estate finance. in: Gessner, V. (ed.) Contractual certainty in international trade : empirical studies and theoretical debates on institutional support for global economic exchanges Oxford ; Portland Hart. pp. 157-171

Clementi, crisis and careers
Flood, J. 2009. Clementi, crisis and careers. Reconceptualising the Professions: Professions and professionalism in the 21st century: meanings, challenges and prospects. Lancaster University 06 Jan 2009

Straight there no detours: direct access to barristers
Flood, J. and Whyte, A. 2008. Straight there no detours: direct access to barristers. Westminster Law School, University of Westminster.

Lawyers, law firms, and the stabilization of transnational business
Flood, J. and Sosa, F. 2008. Lawyers, law firms, and the stabilization of transnational business. Northwestern Journal of International Law & Business. 28 (3), pp. 489-526.

Lawyers, law firms and the stabilization of transnational business
Flood, J. and Sosa, F. 2008. Lawyers, law firms and the stabilization of transnational business. Northwestern Journal of International Law & Business. 28 (3), pp. 489-525.

Will there be fallout from Clementi? The global repercussions for the legal profession after the Legal Services Act 2007
Flood, J. 2008. Will there be fallout from Clementi? The global repercussions for the legal profession after the Legal Services Act 2007. Workshop on Law Practice in the European Union and the United States. School of Law, University of Miami 04 Apr 2008

Role of lawyers
Flood, J. 2008. Role of lawyers. Hague Institute for the Internationalisation of Law (HiiL) Second Meeting. May 2008

Globalization and lawyers
Flood, J. 2008. Globalization and lawyers. Society of Legal Scholars Annual Conference 2008: The Impact of Legal Scholarship. London School of Economics 15 - 18 Sep 2008

Globalisation and large law firms
Flood, J. 2008. Globalisation and large law firms. in: Cane, P. and Conaghan, J. (ed.) The new Oxford companion to law Oxford Oxford University Press. pp. 501-502

Future directions in the UK legal profession: life after the Legal Services Act 2007
Flood, J. 2008. Future directions in the UK legal profession: life after the Legal Services Act 2007. Symposium of the Future of the Global Law Firm. Georgetown University Law Center, Washington DC 17 - 18 Apr 2008

Becoming global lawyer
Flood, J. 2008. Becoming global lawyer. 38th World Congress of the International Institute of Sociology: Sociology Looks at the Twenty-first Century: From Local Universalism to Global Contextualism. Budapest 26 - 30 Jun 2008

The fall and rise of barristers' clerks
Flood, J. 2007. The fall and rise of barristers' clerks. Counsel.

Partnership and professionalism in global law firms: resurgent professionalism?
Flood, J. 2007. Partnership and professionalism in global law firms: resurgent professionalism? in: Ackroyd, S., Muzio, G.D. and Chanlet, J.F. (ed.) Redirections in the study of expert labour Basingstoke, UK Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 52-74

Participant observation
Flood, J. 2007. Participant observation. in: Clark, D.S. (ed.) Encyclopedia of law and society: American and global perspectives Thousand Island, CA Sage.

Lawyers as sanctifiers: the role of elite law firms in international business transactions
Flood, J. 2007. Lawyers as sanctifiers: the role of elite law firms in international business transactions. Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies. 14 (1), pp. 35-66.

Lawyers as sanctifiers of value creation
Flood, J. 2007. Lawyers as sanctifiers of value creation. Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies. 14, pp. 35-66.

Law firms
Flood, J. 2007. Law firms. in: Clark, D.S. (ed.) Encyclopedia of law and society: American and global perspectives Thousand Island, CA Sage.

Case assignment in English courts
Banakar, R., Flood, J., Webb, J. and Whyte, A. 2007. Case assignment in English courts. in: Langbroek, P.M. and Fabri, M. (ed.) The right judge for each case: a study of case assignment and impartiality in six European judiciaries Antwerp ; Oxford Intersentia.

What's wrong with legal aid?: Lessons from outside the UK
Flood, J. and Whyte, A. 2006. What's wrong with legal aid?: Lessons from outside the UK. Civil Justice Quarterly. 25, pp. 80-98.

Book review: The Collegial Phenomenon: The Social Mechanisms of Cooperation Among Peers in a Corporate Law Partnership by Emmanuel Lazega, New York: Oxford University Press, 2001, Hbk, 346 + xi pp, ISBN 0-19-924272-0
Flood, J. 2006. Book review: The Collegial Phenomenon: The Social Mechanisms of Cooperation Among Peers in a Corporate Law Partnership by Emmanuel Lazega, New York: Oxford University Press, 2001, Hbk, 346 + xi pp, ISBN 0-19-924272-0. Legal Ethics. 8 (2), pp. 291-294.

Postmodern professions? The fragmentation of legal education and the legal profession
Boon, A., Flood, J. and Webb, J. 2005. Postmodern professions? The fragmentation of legal education and the legal profession. Journal of Law and Society. 32 (3), pp. 473-492.

Report on international approaches to the defence of indigent persons in criminal cases: a report for Lord Carter's review of legal aid procurement
Flood, J., Whyte, A. and Bacquet, S. 2005. Report on international approaches to the defence of indigent persons in criminal cases: a report for Lord Carter's review of legal aid procurement. London, UK Department for Constitutional Affairs.

Internal case assignment in England
Flood, J., Banakar, R., Webb, J. and Whyte, A. 2005. Internal case assignment in England. in: Fabri, M. and Langbroek, P.M. (ed.) Internal case assignment. A report on a comparative study into the rules and practices of case distribution in courts in five countries Utrecht, Netherlands University of Utrecht. pp. 63-134

Socio-legal ethnography
Flood, J. 2005. Socio-legal ethnography. in: Banakar, R. and Travers, M. (ed.) Theory and method in socio-legal research Oxford, UK Hart. pp. 33-48

Rating, dating, and the (in)formal regulation and formal ordering of financial transactions: securitisations and credit rating agencies
Flood, J. 2005. Rating, dating, and the (in)formal regulation and formal ordering of financial transactions: securitisations and credit rating agencies. in: Likosky, M.B. (ed.) Privatising development: transnational law, infrastructure, and human rights Leiden, Netherlands Martinus Nijhoff. pp. 147-171

Report on costs of legal aid in other countries
Flood, J. and Whyte, A. 2004. Report on costs of legal aid in other countries. UK University of Westminster.

Capital markets, globalisation and global elites
Flood, J. 2002. Capital markets, globalisation and global elites. in: Likosky, M.B. (ed.) Transnational legal processes: globalisation and power disparaties London, UK Butterworths. pp. 114-134

The vultures fly East: the creation and globalisation of the distressed debt market
Flood, J. 2001. The vultures fly East: the creation and globalisation of the distressed debt market. in: Nelken, D. and Feest, J. (ed.) Adapting legal cultures Oxford, UK Hart. pp. 257-278

Capital markets: those who can and cannot do the purest global law
Flood, J. 2001. Capital markets: those who can and cannot do the purest global law. in: Appelbaum, R.P., Felstiner, W.L.F. and Gessner, V. (ed.) Rules and networks: the legal culture of global business transactions Oxford, UK Hart. pp. 248-272

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/912w9/will-there-be-fallout-from-clementi-the-global-repercussions-for-the-legal-profession-after-the-uk-legal-services-act-2007


Share this
Tweet
Email