Moneo, Libeskind and a question of influence

Peckham, A. 2008. Moneo, Libeskind and a question of influence. Journal of Architecture. 13 (1), pp. 23-51.

TitleMoneo, Libeskind and a question of influence
AuthorsPeckham, A.
Abstract

This paper focuses on two museum buildings designed in the 1980s: Rafael Moneo's Museum of Roman Art in Merida (1980-86) and Daniel Libeskind's Jewish Museum in Berlin (1988-99, 2001). The first consolidated the initial phase of Moneo's career, while the second, over-interpreted in subsequent criticism, ignited Libeskind's reputation as a theorist who could build. Approaching the design of both museums with Aldo Rossi's influence in mind, the particular focus is the relationship between concepts of order and contingency associated with the theme of temporality recurrent in his architecture. This retrospective examination was initially conceived in response to Robin Evans's review of Libeskind's Chamberworks, where he remarked on the efficacy of Rossi's short preface. Relationships discovered in comparative examination of these two polemically divergent buildings credit Rossi with a more nuanced influence on late twentieth-century architecture than is generally attributed to his work (currently at the margins of architectural discourse).

JournalJournal of Architecture
Journal citation13 (1), pp. 23-51
ISSN1360-2365
YearFeb 2008
PublisherTaylor & Francis
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)doi:10.1080/13602360701865209
Publication dates
PublishedFeb 2008

Related outputs

The Afterlife of the Architecture Journal
Peckham, A. 2019. The Afterlife of the Architecture Journal. in: Schmiedeknecht, T. and Peckham, A. (ed.) Modernism and the Professional Architecture Journal: Reporting, editing and reconstructing in postwar Europe  Routledge.

Introduction
Schmiedeknecht, T. and Peckham, A. 2019. Introduction. in: Schmiedeknecht, T. and Peckham, A. (ed.) Modernism and the Professional Architecture Journal: Reporting, editing and reconstructing in postwar Europe  Abingdon, Oxon Routledge.

Review: Franklin, Geraint, Howell Killick Partridge & Amis, Swindon: Historic England (2017)
Peckham, A. 2018. Review: Franklin, Geraint, Howell Killick Partridge & Amis, Swindon: Historic England (2017). Ancient Monuments Society: Transactions. 62.

Architecture and its Imprint: Building, Concepts, Publication
Peckham, A. 2018. Architecture and its Imprint: Building, Concepts, Publication. London Routledge.

Beyond formalism: the quiescent art of formal analysis in architecture
Peckham, A. 2016. Beyond formalism: the quiescent art of formal analysis in architecture. Journal of Architecture. 21 (5), pp. 679-689.

Transcribing The Journal of Architecture: research, production and publication 2004–2013
Lewi, H. and Peckham, A. 2016. Transcribing The Journal of Architecture: research, production and publication 2004–2013. The Journal of Architecture. 21 (4), pp. 479-489.

Roundtable Discussion
Peckham, A. and Schmiedeknecht, T. 2014. Roundtable Discussion. Book Launch for The Rationalist Reader. Feb 2014

Rationalist Architecture Today
Peckham, A. and Schmiedeknecht, T. 2014. Rationalist Architecture Today. DOCOMOMO (UK).

Letters: When buildings don’t speak
Peckham, A. 2014. Letters: When buildings don’t speak. arq: Architectural Research Quarterly. 18 (3), pp. 198-201.

Cataloguing architecture: the library of the architect
Peckham, A. 2013. Cataloguing architecture: the library of the architect. in: Mays, S. (ed.) Libraries, literatures, and archives Routledge. pp. 202-223

Questions of authenticity: brickwork and ‘found space’
McCormack, S. and Peckham, A. 2011. Questions of authenticity: brickwork and ‘found space’. Architectural Research Quarterly. 15 (2), pp. 105-118.

Foreword
Peckham, A. 2011. Foreword. in: Madge, J. (ed.) Sabbioneta: cryptic city Bibliotheque McLean. pp. 3-4

Reviews: Ordinary Works: Jonathan Woolf Architects Exhibition. Jonathan Woolf: Architects. Tony Fretton: Architects
Peckham, A. 2010. Reviews: Ordinary Works: Jonathan Woolf Architects Exhibition. Jonathan Woolf: Architects. Tony Fretton: Architects. Architectural Research Quarterly. 14 (4), pp. 375-379.

Grey area
Peckham, A. 2010. Grey area. Block. 1, pp. 40-41.

Book review: Modernity and reinvention: the architecture of James Gowan by Ellis Woodman
Peckham, A. 2009. Book review: Modernity and reinvention: the architecture of James Gowan by Ellis Woodman. Architectural Research Quarterly. 13 (3-4), pp. 328-331.

Building review Norwich Forum 1998-2001: millennial prospect, coincident detachment
Peckham, A. 2007. Building review Norwich Forum 1998-2001: millennial prospect, coincident detachment. Journal of Architecture. 12 (2), pp. 209-227.

Rossi in retrospect: fame and familiarity
Peckham, A. 2005. Rossi in retrospect: fame and familiarity. in: Davies, P. and Schmiedeknecht, T. (ed.) An architect's guide to fame Oxford, UK Elsevier. pp. 83-102

Book review: Why architects draw, Ed Robbins
Peckham, A. 1994. Book review: Why architects draw, Ed Robbins. Architectural Review. 195 (1172), p. 105.

Profile Vittorio Gregotti: the urban dimension
Peckham, A. 1990. Profile Vittorio Gregotti: the urban dimension. Architecture Today. 12, pp. 58-65.

Review: PCL symposium architecture and sculpture
Peckham, A. 1989. Review: PCL symposium architecture and sculpture. Architects' Journal. 189 (11), p. 79.

Stirling and Wilford’s Latina library
Peckham, A. 1985. Stirling and Wilford’s Latina library. A3 Times. 6, p. 16.

Architecture and continuity: a critique
Peckham, A. 1984. Architecture and continuity: a critique. Issue (PCL). 4, pp. 49-56.

O.M. Ungers: notes towards an ideology of form
Peckham, A. 1982. O.M. Ungers: notes towards an ideology of form. Issue (PCL). 3, pp. 39-50.

This is the modern world: a critique of the Sainsbury Centre
Peckham, A. 1979. This is the modern world: a critique of the Sainsbury Centre. Architectural Design (Profile 19). 49 (2), pp. 1-26.

Review: Rational architecture 1978
Peckham, A. 1979. Review: Rational architecture 1978. International Architect. 1 (1), pp. 64-65.

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/91360/moneo-libeskind-and-a-question-of-influence


Share this
Tweet
Email