An analysis of "hybrid" scholarly journals: new spaces for developing distinctive ways of knowing?

Stierer, B. 2008. An analysis of "hybrid" scholarly journals: new spaces for developing distinctive ways of knowing? Society for Research into Higher Education Annual Conference 2008. Liverpool 09 - 11 Dec 2008

TitleAn analysis of "hybrid" scholarly journals: new spaces for developing distinctive ways of knowing?
AuthorsStierer, B.
TypeConference paper
Abstract

There now exist, in the UK and elsewhere, a large number of peer-reviewed journals concerned with teaching, learning, curriculum and assessment in specific higher education disciplines. Examples include: Arts and Humanities in Higher Education, International Journal for Pharmaceutical Education, and International Journal of Construction Education and Research. This paper presents an analysis of about 20 of these journals, including email interviews with a sample of authors and editors. The analysis is prompted by the tensions inherent in the growing phenomenon of HE lecturers engaging in pedagogic research as a part of their academic practice. On the one hand, the value of pedagogic research derives precisely from the discipline-specific perspectives of the practitioners conducting it. On the other hand, HE lecturers based in ‘the disciplines’, who wish to develop confidence and expertise in the typical ‘ways of knowing’ for pedagogic research, may face a daunting journey. The significance of journals which straddle this borderland lies in their potential to provide a prestigious outlet for research and scholarship sometimes viewed as amateurish and parochial, as well as a forum for communities of subject specialists to discuss and debate educational issues in their disciplines. However the journals may also offer new spaces for developing distinctive ‘ways of knowing’: theoretical framings, epistemological analyses and methodological approaches which display elements of both ‘educational’ and ‘disciplinary’ traditions, with interesting implications for the changing nature of academic practice and academic identities. Questions to be asked as part of this analysis include:

• What kinds of educational issues get written about?

• What kinds of discourses, theoretical frames and methodologies are used?

• How do academics who publish in such journals describe this work in relation to their academic practice and academic identity?

• What light is shed in relation to the tension between research and teaching?

Year2008
ConferenceSociety for Research into Higher Education Annual Conference 2008
Publication dates
Completed2008

Related outputs

Changing academic identities in changing academic workplaces: learning from academics’ everyday professional writing practices
Lea, M.R. and Stierer, B. 2011. Changing academic identities in changing academic workplaces: learning from academics’ everyday professional writing practices. Teaching in Higher Education. 16 (6), pp. 605-616.

(Guest Editors) Special Issue: leaving the academy
Clegg, S., Hunt, C., Parker, J., Rowland, S., Skelton, A. and Stierer, B. 2011. (Guest Editors) Special Issue: leaving the academy. Teaching in Higher Education. 16 (5), pp. 469-470.

Changing academic identities in changing academic workplaces: what we can learn from academics' everyday professional writing practices
Stierer, B. and Lea, M.R. 2009. Changing academic identities in changing academic workplaces: what we can learn from academics' everyday professional writing practices. Beyond Teaching and Research: inclusive understandings of academic practice. University of Oxford 13 - 15 Dec 2009

Lecturers' everyday writing as professional practice in the university as workplace: new insights into academic identities
Lea, M.R. and Stierer, B. 2009. Lecturers' everyday writing as professional practice in the university as workplace: new insights into academic identities. Studies in Higher Education. 34 (4), pp. 417-428.

(Guest Editors) Special issues on the theme 'Purposes, knowledge and identities'
Clegg, S., Hunt, C., Parker, J., Rowland, S., Skelton, A. and Stierer, B. 2009. (Guest Editors) Special issues on the theme 'Purposes, knowledge and identities'. Teaching in Higher Education. 14 (5), pp. 467-585.

Writing as professional practice in the university as workplace: new insights into academic identity
Stierer, B. and Lea, M.R. 2008. Writing as professional practice in the university as workplace: new insights into academic identity. Higher Education Close Up 4. University of Cape Town, South Africa 26 - 28 June 2008

Learning to write about teaching: understanding the writing demands of lecturer development programmes in higher education
Stierer, B. 2008. Learning to write about teaching: understanding the writing demands of lecturer development programmes in higher education. in: Murray, R. (ed.) The scholarship of teaching and learning in higher education Maidenhead Society for Research into Higher Educaton & Open University Press. pp. 34-45

HE lecturers researching HE issues: issues and dilemmas for academic developers
Stierer, B. 2008. HE lecturers researching HE issues: issues and dilemmas for academic developers. Educational Developments. 9 (1), pp. 22-24.

Special Double Issue: Diversity and commonality in higher education
Stierer, B., Clegg, S., Hunt, C., Parker, J., Rowland, S. and Skelton, A. 2007. Special Double Issue: Diversity and commonality in higher education. Teaching in Higher Education. 12 (5&6), pp. 555-797.

University lecturers learning to "write education": issues of academic literacy and professionalisation
Stierer, B. 2006. University lecturers learning to "write education": issues of academic literacy and professionalisation. Annual Research Symposium of the Literacies in Higher Education Research Group, University of Westminster. London, UK 30 Jun 2006

Reflective writing in higher education: a case study
Stierer, B. 2005. Reflective writing in higher education: a case study. Academic Literacies Symposium, University of London Institute of Education. London, UK Jul 2005

Are there distinctive methodologies for pedagogic research in higher education?
Stierer, B. and Antoniou, M. 2004. Are there distinctive methodologies for pedagogic research in higher education? Teaching in Higher Education. 9 (3), pp. 275-285.

HE teachers researching their own practice: the possibilities for hybrid methodologies in practitioner research
Stierer, B. and Antoniou, M. 2003. HE teachers researching their own practice: the possibilities for hybrid methodologies in practitioner research. Annual Conference of the British Educational Research Association. Edinburgh, UK 11-13 Sept 2003

Teaching university/research university: the debate
Stierer, B. 2003. Teaching university/research university: the debate. Annual Teaching and Learning Conference of the Council for Hospitality Management Education. Eastbourne, UK Nov 2003

Managing the impression of authenticity: students' construction of an authorial persona in reflective writing
Stierer, B. 2001. Managing the impression of authenticity: students' construction of an authorial persona in reflective writing. in: Graal, M. (ed.) Changing contexts for teaching and learning, proceedings of the 8th Annual Writing Development in Higher Education Conference Leicester, UK Teaching and Learning Unit, University of Leicester.

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/91856/an-analysis-of-hybrid-scholarly-journals-new-spaces-for-developing-distinctive-ways-of-knowing


Share this
Tweet
Email