Public Interests, Private Disputes: Investment Arbitration and the Public Good

Glinavos, I. 2016. Public Interests, Private Disputes: Investment Arbitration and the Public Good. Manchester Journal of International Economic Law. 13 (1), pp. 50-62.

TitlePublic Interests, Private Disputes: Investment Arbitration and the Public Good
AuthorsGlinavos, I.
Abstract

This paper seeks to investigate the bases for resistance to arbitration in general -and investor arbitration in particular- focusing on the way in which arbitral tribunals deal with notions of public interest and the public good. The paper hypothesises that while courts have within their terms of reference the capacity to consider notions of public interest, arbitral tribunals do not. It is this core difference in the scope of decision making between the two bodies that could render privately organised dispute resolution unsuitable for disputes that have public aspects, like investor-state disputes. The paper discusses the meaning of public interest and the public good as found in the literature. It then proceeds to consider how tribunals in the investment field have dealt with these concepts. This leads to a conclusion urging not abandonment of arbitration as a component of dispute resolution, but caution. It is argued that unchecked growth in private dispute resolution can threaten perceptions of legitimacy and democratic accountability. The paper adopts a socio-legal methodology in considering the effect of legal mechanisms on social and political phenomena. It is also informed by a law and economics methodology in addressing impacts of dispute resolution mechanisms on economic efficiency. The contribution of the paper rests on theorising motivations for resistance to private dispute resolution, a topical issue in light of the TTIP debate.

KeywordsInvestment Arbitration, Commercial Arbitration, Arbitration, TTIP, ISDS, ICSID
JournalManchester Journal of International Economic Law
Journal citation13 (1), pp. 50-62
ISSN1742-3945
Year2016
PublisherElectronicpublications.org Ltd
Web address (URL)https://www.electronicpublications.org/stuff.php?id=580
Publication dates
PublishedApr 2016

Related outputs

To ISDS or not to ISDS: A question of legitimacy in dispute resolution
Glinavos, I. 2019. To ISDS or not to ISDS: A question of legitimacy in dispute resolution. in: A brand new world: the evolution and future of arbitration London Chartered Institute of Arbitrators (CIArb).

Brexit, the City and options for ISDS
Glinavos, I. 2018. Brexit, the City and options for ISDS. ICSID Review. 33 (2), pp. 380-405. doi:10.1093/icsidreview/siy003

Huffington Post: No-Deal Brexit and Fear
Glinavos, I. 2017. Huffington Post: No-Deal Brexit and Fear.

Newsweek: The City of London is preparing for a hard Brexit
Glinavos, I. 2017. Newsweek: The City of London is preparing for a hard Brexit. Newsweek.

Forbes: Brexit Negotiations: A Greek Tragedy
Glinavos, I. 2017. Forbes: Brexit Negotiations: A Greek Tragedy. Forbes.

The Conversation: Why TTIP will live on – but not for the EU
Glinavos, I. 2016. The Conversation: Why TTIP will live on – but not for the EU. The Conversation.

Solar eclipse: investment treaty arbitration and Spain’s photovoltaic troubles
Glinavos, I. 2016. Solar eclipse: investment treaty arbitration and Spain’s photovoltaic troubles. in: Gurdgiev, C., Leonard, L. and Gonzalez-Perez, M.A. (ed.) Lessons from the Great Recession: at the crossroads of sustainability and recovery Bingley, Yorkshire, UK Emerald. pp. 251-271

The Conversation: Why leaving the euro is back on the agenda in the Greek election
Glinavos, I. 2015. The Conversation: Why leaving the euro is back on the agenda in the Greek election. The Conversation.

A crisis beyond law, or a crisis of law? Reflections on the European economic crisis
Glinavos, I. 2014. A crisis beyond law, or a crisis of law? Reflections on the European economic crisis. European Journal of Law Reform. 2014 (4), pp. 679-691.

Haircut undone? The Greek drama and prospects for investment arbitration
Glinavos, I. 2014. Haircut undone? The Greek drama and prospects for investment arbitration. Journal of International Dispute Settlement. 5 (3), pp. 475-497. doi:10.1093/jnlids/idu008

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/9937z/public-interests-private-disputes-investment-arbitration-and-the-public-good


Restricted files

Publisher's version
Under embargo indefinitely

Share this
Tweet
Email