The political economy of co-ordination challenges in the National Health Service: a postpositivist evaluation of diabetes policy and governance

Mills, T. 2016. The political economy of co-ordination challenges in the National Health Service: a postpositivist evaluation of diabetes policy and governance. PhD thesis University of Westminster Politics and International Relations

TitleThe political economy of co-ordination challenges in the National Health Service: a postpositivist evaluation of diabetes policy and governance
TypePhD thesis
AuthorsMills, T.
Abstract

The present PhD thesis develops and applies an evaluative methodology suited to the evaluation of policy and governance in complex policy areas. While extensive literatures exist on the topic of policy evaluation, governance evaluation has received less attention. At the level of governance, policymakers confront choices between different policy tools and governance arrangements in their attempts to solve policy problems, including variants of hierarchy, networks and markets. There is a need for theoretically-informed empirical research to inform decision-making at this level.

To that end, the PhD develops an approach to evaluation by combining postpositivist policy analysis with heterodox political economy. Postpositivist policy analysis recognises that policy problems are often contested, that choices between policy options can involve significant trade-offs and that knowledge of policy options is itself dispersed and fragmented. Similarly, heterodox economics combines a concept of incommensurable values with an appreciation of the strengths and weaknesses of different institutional arrangements to realise them. A central concept of the field is coordination, which orientates policy analysis to the interactions of stakeholders in policy processes. The challenge of governance is to select the appropriate policy tools and arrangements which facilitate coordination. Via a postpositivist exploration of stakeholder ‘frames’, it is possible to ascertain whether coordination is occurring and to identify problems if it is not. Evaluative claims of governance can be made where arrangements can be shown to frustrate the realisation of shared values and objectives.

The research makes a contribution to knowledge in a number of ways a) a distinctive evaluative approach that could be applied to other areas of health and public policy b) greater appreciation of the strengths and weaknesses of different forms of evidence in public policy and in particular health policy and c) concrete policy proposals for the governance and organisation of diabetes services, with implications for the NHS more broadly.

Year2016
File

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/9ywzy/the-political-economy-of-co-ordination-challenges-in-the-national-health-service-a-postpositivist-evaluation-of-diabetes-policy-and-governance


Share this
Tweet
Email

Usage statistics

51 total views
185 total downloads
3 views this month
7 downloads this month
These values are for the period from September 2nd 2018, when this repository was created

Export as