Judicial Interpretation of Commercial Contracts in English and French Law: A Comparative Perspective

Pedamon, C. 2021. Judicial Interpretation of Commercial Contracts in English and French Law: A Comparative Perspective . European Business Law Review. 36 (6), p. 1093 – 1124.

TitleJudicial Interpretation of Commercial Contracts in English and French Law: A Comparative Perspective
TypeJournal article
AuthorsPedamon, C.
Abstract

In this paper, I consider whether the recent French reform of contract law has changed the principles of judicial interpretation of commercial contracts, and how they compare with the principles in English law. Is the traditional dichotomy between the French subjective approach and the English objective one has been altered now that the objective principle of interpretation has been codified in the reformed Code civil? Other aspects of judicial interpretation must be considered in this comparative exercise, such as the nature of the interpretative question, the purpose of interpretation and its scope. Similarities emerge that show a rapprochement, but this cannot hide persistent differences as interpretation is anchored in their respective legal orders. However, with the complexification and fragmentation of commercial contracts, it is expected that the distinctiveness in the interpretative approach will diminish as English and French courts follow an objective text-based approach to interpretation. The French reform encourages this as it enhances lower courts’ ability to seek the objective meaning of the contract. An emerging coalescence around an objective textual interpretation would be welcomed by commercial parties as it enhances certainty across borders.

KeywordsJudicial interpretation
implication
subjective approach to interpretation
objective approach to interpretation
contextualism
common judicial hermeneutics
English law
French law
French reform of contract law
JournalEuropean Business Law Review
Journal citation36 (6), p. 1093 – 1124
ISSN0959-6941
Year2021
PublisherKluwer Law
Accepted author manuscript
File Access Level
Open (open metadata and files)
Publisher's version
File Access Level
Open (open metadata and files)
Web address (URL)https://kluwerlawonline.com/journalarticle/European+Business+Law+Review/32.4/EULR2021040
Publication dates
Published01 Sep 2021

Related outputs

The ILA White Paper on Business and Human Rights
Humberto Cantú Rivera and Catherine Pedamon 2022. The ILA White Paper on Business and Human Rights. International Law Association (Paris).

Publications for the PhD by Published Work "Overcoming Divergence in English and French Contract Law: A Common Taxonomy of Commercial Contracts"
Pedamon, C. 2022. Publications for the PhD by Published Work "Overcoming Divergence in English and French Contract Law: A Common Taxonomy of Commercial Contracts". University of Westminster.

Overcoming Divergence in English and French Contract Law: A Common Taxonomy of Commercial Contracts
Pedamon, Catherine 2022. Overcoming Divergence in English and French Contract Law: A Common Taxonomy of Commercial Contracts. PhD thesis University of Westminster School of Law https://doi.org/10.34737/w13z3

Contractual Performance in Covid-19 Times: Does Anglo-French Legal History Repeat Itself?
Pedamon, C. and Vassileva, R. 2021. Contractual Performance in Covid-19 Times: Does Anglo-French Legal History Repeat Itself? European Review of Private Law. 29 (1), pp. 3-38.

The paradoxes of the theory of imprévision in the new French law of contract: a judicial deterrent?
Pedamon, C. 2019. The paradoxes of the theory of imprévision in the new French law of contract: a judicial deterrent? Amicus Curiae. (112), pp. 10-17.

The “Duty to Cooperate” in English and French Contract Law: One Channel, Two Distinct Views
Pedamon, C. and Vassileva, R. 2019. The “Duty to Cooperate” in English and French Contract Law: One Channel, Two Distinct Views. Journal of Comparative Law . 14 (1), pp. 1-25 No 1 (2019).

The New French Contract Law and Its Impact on Commercial Law: Good Faith, Unfair Contract Terms and Hardship
Pedamon, C. 2018. The New French Contract Law and Its Impact on Commercial Law: Good Faith, Unfair Contract Terms and Hardship. in: Heidemann, M. and Lee, J. (ed.) The Future of the Commercial Contract in Scholarship and Law Reform: European and Comparative Perspectives Springer.

Theory of Fraud in French Law - Fraus omnia corrumpit - old law, new opportunities?
Pedamon, C. 2015. Theory of Fraud in French Law - Fraus omnia corrumpit - old law, new opportunities? in: Research Handbook on International Financial Crimes Cheltenham Edward Elgar. pp. 338-355

Hardship in transnational commercial contracts: a critique of legal, judicial and contractual remedies
Pedamon, C. and Chuah, J. 2013. Hardship in transnational commercial contracts: a critique of legal, judicial and contractual remedies. Paris Legal Publishers.

How is Convergence Best Achieved in International Project Finance?
Pedamon, C. 2010. How is Convergence Best Achieved in International Project Finance? Fordham International Law Journal. 24 1272.

Corporate social responsibility: a new approach to promoting integrity and  responsibility
Pedamon, C. 2010. Corporate social responsibility: a new approach to promoting integrity and  responsibility. Company Lawyer. 31 (6), pp. 172-180.

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/v0265/judicial-interpretation-of-commercial-contracts-in-english-and-french-law-a-comparative-perspective


Explore this journal article

The New French Contract Law and Its Impact on Commercial Law: Good Faith, Unfair Contract Terms and Hardship
Pedamon, C. 2018. The New French Contract Law and Its Impact on Commercial Law: Good Faith, Unfair Contract Terms and Hardship. in: Heidemann, M. and Lee, J. (ed.) The Future of the Commercial Contract in Scholarship and Law Reform: European and Comparative Perspectives Springer.

The “Duty to Cooperate” in English and French Contract Law: One Channel, Two Distinct Views
Pedamon, C. and Vassileva, R. 2019. The “Duty to Cooperate” in English and French Contract Law: One Channel, Two Distinct Views. Journal of Comparative Law . 14 (1), pp. 1-25 No 1 (2019).

The paradoxes of the theory of imprévision in the new French law of contract: a judicial deterrent?
Pedamon, C. 2019. The paradoxes of the theory of imprévision in the new French law of contract: a judicial deterrent? Amicus Curiae. (112), pp. 10-17.

Contractual Performance in Covid-19 Times: Does Anglo-French Legal History Repeat Itself?
Pedamon, C. and Vassileva, R. 2021. Contractual Performance in Covid-19 Times: Does Anglo-French Legal History Repeat Itself? European Review of Private Law. 29 (1), pp. 3-38.

Hardship in transnational commercial contracts: a critique of legal, judicial and contractual remedies
Pedamon, C. and Chuah, J. 2013. Hardship in transnational commercial contracts: a critique of legal, judicial and contractual remedies. Paris Legal Publishers.

Overcoming Divergence in English and French Contract Law: A Common Taxonomy of Commercial Contracts
Pedamon, Catherine 2022. Overcoming Divergence in English and French Contract Law: A Common Taxonomy of Commercial Contracts. PhD thesis University of Westminster School of Law https://doi.org/10.34737/w13z3

Share this

Usage statistics

708 total views
1055 total downloads
These values cover views and downloads from WestminsterResearch and are for the period from September 2nd 2018, when this repository was created.