On working and being: The legal metaphysics of labour and the constitutional errors of Social Europe

Mason, L. 2019. On working and being: The legal metaphysics of labour and the constitutional errors of Social Europe. in: Toracca, T and Condello, A (ed.) Law, Labour and the Humanities: Contemporary European Perspectives London Routledge.

Chapter titleOn working and being: The legal metaphysics of labour and the constitutional errors of Social Europe
AuthorsMason, L.
EditorsToracca, T and Condello, A
Abstract

This Chapter outlines the legal contradictions in the European ‘project’ with regard to work. In particular, it points to grave tensions between, on the one hand, the ‘existential’ social aspirations of the European Union, which place work at their centre, and, on the other hand, the ‘metaphysical’ realities of a legal framework which has singularly failed to constitute the very working relationships upon which the much vaunted ‘Social Europe’ is predicated. By constructing this ontological account of the role of law in constituting all social and economic identity and exchange, this Chapter argues that the legal and constitutional theory which formed the basis of the ‘economic’ phase of European integration has not been followed during the ‘social’ phase of integration which has followed. In this manner, the ‘social’ within Europe has been relegated to an inferior status, precisely due to the failure to construct the working relationships which this social vision is based upon. While the idea that the ‘social’ gives way to the ‘economic’ is one which emerges from much writing on the European Union and international economic integration more generally, this Chapter breaks with that vast, cacophonous body of literature to argue that it is precisely the efforts to rectify this ‘social deficit’ which cement this failure. The emergent ‘social’ acquis of European Union law at constitutional level has often come to adopt the ‘existential’ trappings of constitutional language, by expressing the identity of its polity through its values and social aims. However, in so doing, it has failed to capture the ontological essence of constitutionalism, whereby social or economic actors are literally constituted by the law. It is this ontological role of the law which allows us to talk of the European Union as a genuinely constitutional project, at least in the economic sphere. As the social values of the Union largely rest on an economic framework premised on stable working relationships, the failure of the constitutional settlement to ensure such relationships has the effect of negating the ontological status of the work in the European social model.
In this manner, this Chapter questions the coherence of the European employment and social policies through their failure to deliberately constitute stable employment relationships, while nonetheless being premised upon their existence. This failure is not simply a legal one however, but also one of ideology: much labour law thinking, including that which is critical of the relegation of social policy within the European project, shares this naïve vision of economic relationships and work. On the one hand, labour law emerged within an economico-historical, materialist heritage, rejecting the importance of law in the arranging of industrial affairs. On the other hand, more recent labour law scholarship and policy development have often fallen into a form of jurisprudential naivety, in which it has been thought sufficient to engage in a form of juridical ‘virtue signalling’ through the use of the rhetoric of social values and human rights. Such scholarship is based on, respectively, legitimate and laudable concerns regarding social power and the pervasiveness of constitutional principles. However, this Chapter argues that without the necessary legal constitution of the economic relationships, in particular working relationships, upon which these values and rights are predicated, such goals will remain illusory, and social power will prove difficult to shape. While the passing of ambitious legislation such as the European Pillar of Social Rights, declared in late 2017, in many ways typifies and indeed magnifies these errors yet again, it might offer an opportunity for judicial and policy-focused reflection that forces greater focus on constituting working relationships within the shared European economic and social space.

KeywordsEU Social Policy; Social Constitution; Employment relationships; Social Pillar
Book titleLaw, Labour and the Humanities: Contemporary European Perspectives
Year2019
PublisherRoutledge
Publication dates
Published30 Oct 2019
Place of publicationLondon
ISBN0367077175
9780367077174

Related outputs

Il pluralismo giuridico e la crime fiction italiana: Le forme letterarie come opere di filosofia del diritto, l’autore come giuslavorista
Mason, L. 2020. Il pluralismo giuridico e la crime fiction italiana: Le forme letterarie come opere di filosofia del diritto, l’autore come giuslavorista. in: Baghetti, C, Ceteroni, A, Iandoli, G and Summa, R (ed.) Il lavoro raccontato. Studi su letteratura e cinema italiani dal postmodernismo all'ipermodernismo Franco Cesati Editore.

英 国
Mason, L. 2020. 英 国. in: 平台经济与劳动立法国际趋势 中国工人出版社 (China Workers Publishing House). pp. 182-201

Locating Unity in the Fragmented Platform Economy: Labour law and the Platform Economy in the United Kingdom
Mason, L. 2020. Locating Unity in the Fragmented Platform Economy: Labour law and the Platform Economy in the United Kingdom. Comparative Labor Law and Policy Journal. 41 (2), p. 101.

Royaume-Uni
Mason, L. 2019. Royaume-Uni. European Trade Union Institute. 2019 (10), pp. 126-128.

Le salarié-actionnaire en droit anglais : l’histoire d’un échec législatif
Mason, L. 2019. Le salarié-actionnaire en droit anglais : l’histoire d’un échec législatif. in: Mazuyer, E (ed.) La place des salariés dans l’entreprise France Mare&Martin.

Make it new! The redeeming Modernism of law and the collapsing of its polarities
Condello, A. and Mason, L. 2019. Make it new! The redeeming Modernism of law and the collapsing of its polarities. Polemos. 13 (1), pp. 149-165. https://doi.org/10.1515/pol-2019-0008

Vers une « constitution sociale » européenne ? La constitutionnalisation du droit du travail et le droit de l’Union européenne
Mason, L. 2019. Vers une « constitution sociale » européenne ? La constitutionnalisation du droit du travail et le droit de l’Union européenne. Titre VII : La Revue Du Conseil Constitutionnel. 2 (1), pp. 41-50.

Le particularisme anglais et le juge Common Law : la déjudiciarisation et le rejudiciarisation du droit du travail
Mason, L. 2019. Le particularisme anglais et le juge Common Law : la déjudiciarisation et le rejudiciarisation du droit du travail. Revue de droit du travail. 2019, p. 277.

Le barème des indemnités de licenciement en droit anglais : entre les contraintes législatives et la créativité de la Common Law
Mason, L. 2019. Le barème des indemnités de licenciement en droit anglais : entre les contraintes législatives et la créativité de la Common Law. Revue de droit du travail. 2019, p. 352.

Idealism, Empiricism, Pluralism, Law: Legal truth after modernity
Mason, L. 2019. Idealism, Empiricism, Pluralism, Law: Legal truth after modernity. in: Condello, A and Andina, T (ed.) Post-Truth, Law and Philosophy London Routledge.

Labouring under inauthentic conceptions: Some caveats to the predominant visions of artistic and contractual freedom
Mason, L. 2019. Labouring under inauthentic conceptions: Some caveats to the predominant visions of artistic and contractual freedom. Caveat.

A Modest Proposal (in a black box)
Mason, L. 2018. A Modest Proposal (in a black box). Pump House Gallery 03 Oct - 16 Dec 2018

A Modest Proposal (film)
Mason, L. 2018. A Modest Proposal (film). UK/Belgium Jubilee.

The Art of Equity/The Equity of Art; The History and Future of a Malleable Concept
Mason, L. 2018. The Art of Equity/The Equity of Art; The History and Future of a Malleable Concept. in: A Modest Proposal Brussels Jubilee.

Brexit, the end of history and the Constitution of Social Europe: critical reflections on the Social Pillar and its limits
Mason, L. 2018. Brexit, the end of history and the Constitution of Social Europe: critical reflections on the Social Pillar and its limits. Lex Social. 8 (2), pp. 311-340.

Law
Mason, L. 2018. Law. in: Kinchin, I and Winstone, N (ed.) Exploring Pedagogic Frailty and Resilience Brill.

SQEezing the jurisprudence out of the SRA's Super Exam: The SQE's Bleak Legal Realism and the rejection of law's multimodal truth
Mason, L. 2018. SQEezing the jurisprudence out of the SRA's Super Exam: The SQE's Bleak Legal Realism and the rejection of law's multimodal truth. The Law Teacher. 52 (4), pp. 409-424. https://doi.org/10.1080/03069400.2018.1532170

Reclaiming our discipline
Mason, L. and Guth, J 2018. Reclaiming our discipline. The Law Teacher. 52 (4), pp. 379-383. https://doi.org/10.1080/03069400.2018.1533163

Labour Rights
Mason, L. 2017. Labour Rights. in: Cassese, S., von Bogdandy, A. and Huber, P. (ed.) Max Planck Encyclopedia of Comparative Constitutional Law Oxford Oxford University Press (OUP).

Les contrats à zéro heure et l'exception anglaise
Mason, L. 2015. Les contrats à zéro heure et l'exception anglaise. Bulletin du COMPTRASEC. 2015 (2) 4.

The intractably unknowable nature of law : Kadi, Kafka, and the law's competing claims to authority
Mason, L. 2014. The intractably unknowable nature of law : Kadi, Kafka, and the law's competing claims to authority. in: Avbelj, M, Fontanelli, F and Martinico, G (ed.) Kadi on Trial: A Multifaceted Analysis of the Kadi Trial Routledge.

Labour law, the Industrial Constitution and the EU's accession to the ECHR: the constitutional nature of the market and the limits of rights-based approaches to labour law
Mason, L. 2014. Labour law, the Industrial Constitution and the EU's accession to the ECHR: the constitutional nature of the market and the limits of rights-based approaches to labour law. in: Dzehtsiarou, K, Konstadinides, T, Lock, T and O'Meara, N (ed.) Human Rights Law in Europe: The Influence, Overlaps and Contradictions of the EU and the ECHR Routledge.

The Hollow Legal Shell of European Race Discrimination Policy: The EC Race Directive
Mason, L. 2010. The Hollow Legal Shell of European Race Discrimination Policy: The EC Race Directive. American Behavioral Scientist. 53 (12), pp. 1731-1748. https://doi.org/10.1177/0002764210368094

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/v68wx/on-working-and-being-the-legal-metaphysics-of-labour-and-the-constitutional-errors-of-social-europe


Share this
Tweet
Email

Usage statistics

14 total views
0 total downloads
3 views this month
0 downloads this month
These values are for the period from September 2nd 2018, when this repository was created

Export as