The Double Bind of Metrics

Elkington, E. 2022. The Double Bind of Metrics. in: Mowles, C. and Norman, K. (ed.) Complexity and the Public Sector Routledge.

Chapter titleThe Double Bind of Metrics
AuthorsElkington, E.
EditorsMowles, C. and Norman, K.
Abstract

Higher Education (HE) in the UK, like much of the rest of the public sector, has undergone significant changes in the last 25 years. Changes to funding of UK universities have meant that they have come under increasing scrutiny and criticism and there has been an increased focus on results and accountability. As HE has expanded in the UK, it has increasingly been required to justify the expenditure of public funds. Those in charge of universities are now expected to ensure that value for money is provided and to be held to account for the ‘quality’ of the provision of their ‘products’. This chapter focusses on the use of performance metrics in managing in HE and explores the behaviours which emerge when middle managers in HE use metrics as a tool to measure organisational performance. Whilst recognising that metrics may be useful at an abstract level as a means of opening an exploration of what gets done and what is valued, this chapter identifies that metrics can be taken up in ways that may also be used to blame and shame others. Managing using metrics in this way can lead middle managers to feel as if they are stuck ‘in the middle’ and may present middle managers with a double bind (being stuck between two unpalatable choices) which can lead to feelings of futility and a lack of agency.

Book titleComplexity and the Public Sector
Year2022
PublisherRoutledge
Publication dates
Published10 Oct 2022
ISBN9780367569204
9781003099925
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003099925-3
Web address (URL)https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003099925-3

Related outputs

Engaging Students in Work Experience: A Placement Preparation Module at the University of Westminster
Lowe, T., Elkington, E., Brew-Riverson, I., Benamraoui, A., Petratos, P., Ze-To, S., Vindis, T., Whinnett, E. and Dr David Scott 2026. Engaging Students in Work Experience: A Placement Preparation Module at the University of Westminster. BAFA Accounting Education conference 2026. Sheffield Management School 26 - 29 May 2026

Embedding Employment into Accounting and Finance Curricula
Elkington, E. 2026. Embedding Employment into Accounting and Finance Curricula. BAFA Accounting Education conference 2026. Sheffield Management School 26 - 29 May 2026

Teaching and learning approaches that students show up for - An exploratory study of student engagement and attendance in UK Higher Education.
Elkington, E., Brew-Riverson, I. and Lowe, T. 2026. Teaching and learning approaches that students show up for - An exploratory study of student engagement and attendance in UK Higher Education. Journal of Perspectives in Applied Academic Practice. 14 (2), pp. 391-403. https://doi.org/10.56433/tgt56z85

Embedding Employability in the Accounting Curriculmn
Elkington, E. 2026. Embedding Employability in the Accounting Curriculmn. BAFA Accounting Education conference 2026. Sheffield Management School 26 - 29 May 2026

Facilitating the Development of Humanistic Capabilities in Accounting
Elkington, E. 2026. Facilitating the Development of Humanistic Capabilities in Accounting. 48th Annual Congress of the European Accounting Association. Prague, Czech Republic 27 - 29 May 2026

Embedding Employability into the Curriculum: From 100% exams to 100% authentic assessment
Elkington, E. 2026. Embedding Employability into the Curriculum: From 100% exams to 100% authentic assessment. Chartered Association of Business Schools: Learning, Teaching and Student Experience Conference 2026. Manchester, UK 18 - 19 May 2026

Belonging through storytelling: why narrative matters in accounting education
Elkington, E. and Hyde, C. 2026. Belonging through storytelling: why narrative matters in accounting education. Accounting Cafe.

Using stories in Accounting Education to create belonging
Elkington, E. and Hyde, C. 2026. Using stories in Accounting Education to create belonging . Accounting Cafe Symposium 2026. London 06 Feb 2026

What works to increase student attendance and engagement in timetabled sessions - An exploratory study of student engagement in Finance and Accounting education
Elkington, E., Brew-Riverson, I. and Lowe, T. 2025. What works to increase student attendance and engagement in timetabled sessions - An exploratory study of student engagement in Finance and Accounting education. RAISE Annual Conference 2025. University of Glasgow, Scotland 04 - 05 Sep 2025

An invitation to change the culture
Elkington, E. 2024. An invitation to change the culture. University of Hertfordshire Complexity and Management Conference. Roffey Park 07 - 09 Jun 2024

Exploration on The Double Bind of Metrics
Elkington, E. 2023. Exploration on The Double Bind of Metrics . University of Hertfordshire Complexity and Management Conference. Roffey Park Institute 02 - 04 Jun 2023

Ethical Problems of Insider Research
Elkington, E. 2022. Ethical Problems of Insider Research. University of Hertfordshire Research Conference. Hatfield, Hertfordshire 15 Jun 2022

The use of Higher Order MCQs in assessment
Elkington, E. 2022. The use of Higher Order MCQs in assessment. University of Hertfordshire, Teaching and Learning Conference. Hatfield, United Kingdom 05 - 07 Jul 2022

The backstage effects of working with metrics
Elkington, E. 2021. The backstage effects of working with metrics. Hertfordshire Business School’s Complexity Management Centre Symposium on ‘Exploring Complexity of Conflict and Organising in the Time of Covid-19’. Online Nov 2021

Subjugation and Subterfuge: Struggling with Metrics as a Middle Manager in a UK Business School
Elkington, E. 2021. Subjugation and Subterfuge: Struggling with Metrics as a Middle Manager in a UK Business School. Prof Doc Thesis University of Hertfordshire https://doi.org/10.18745/th.27194

How to manage continuation of accounting students
Elkington, E. 2018. How to manage continuation of accounting students. Committee for Departments of Accounting and Finance Annual Conference. 2018

Extending Contact Time with Students
Elkington, E. 2012. Extending Contact Time with Students. University of Hertfordshire Business School Teaching and Learning Conference. 2012

Changes in the UK HE market and the implication for Australian Universities
Elkington, E. 2011. Changes in the UK HE market and the implication for Australian Universities. Australian and New Zealand Finance and Accounting conference (AFINZ). Melbourne 2012

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/w6732/the-double-bind-of-metrics


Share this

Usage statistics

162 total views
0 total downloads
These values cover views and downloads from WestminsterResearch and are for the period from September 2nd 2018, when this repository was created.