The treatment of menopausal symptoms by traditional East Asian medicines: review and perspectives

Scheid, V., Ward, T., Wung, S., Kenji, W. and Xing, L. 2010. The treatment of menopausal symptoms by traditional East Asian medicines: review and perspectives. Maturitas. 66 (2), pp. 111-130.

TitleThe treatment of menopausal symptoms by traditional East Asian medicines: review and perspectives
AuthorsScheid, V., Ward, T., Wung, S., Kenji, W. and Xing, L.
Abstract

This article provides an overview and critical evaluation of the management of menopausal symptoms by traditional East Asian medicines (TEAMs). For this purpose we utilise an interdisciplinary perspective that draws on social history, medical anthropology, and clinical research. Our goal is threefold. First, we examine the research literature regarding evidence for the effectiveness of TEAMs in the management of menopausal symptoms. The failure of all studies reviewed to address the problematic articulation between tradition and modernity in the case of menopausal syndrome leads us to examine more closely how this connection has been constructed. In the second part of this review we explain how during the late 20th century various TEAMs currents such as traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), Japanese Kampō, and Korean medicine, explored different responses to a biomedically defined disorder, namely menopause, that was until then not discussed in these traditions. Third, based on the findings of the previous sections we make a number of recommendations as to how research in this field might be improved. We argue that while robust evidence for the efficacy of TEAMs in treating menopausal symptoms is currently lacking, existing studies provide sufficient evidence to warrant further research. A new interdisciplinary research framework that takes account of the actual realities of TEAMs practice will be required however for meaningful answers regarding the two most urgent problems in the field to emerge. These are, first the issue of actual treatment effects, and second the more general problem of how TEAMs might be integrated into personalised health care.

JournalMaturitas
Journal citation66 (2), pp. 111-130
ISSN0378-5122
YearJun 2010
PublisherElsevier
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)doi:10.1016/j.maturitas.2009.11.020
Publication dates
PublishedJun 2010

Related outputs

Promoting free flow in the networks: reimagining the body in early modern Suzhou
Scheid, V. 2018. Promoting free flow in the networks: reimagining the body in early modern Suzhou. History of Science. 56 (2), pp. 131-167.

Chinese herbal medicine for treating menopausal symptoms in London women: developing a good practice protocol via the factor analysis of prescribing patterns in a clinical study
Scheid, V., Tuffrey, V. and Bovey, M. 2017. Chinese herbal medicine for treating menopausal symptoms in London women: developing a good practice protocol via the factor analysis of prescribing patterns in a clinical study. Complementary Therapies in Medicine. 32, pp. 33-40.

From civilising foods for nourishing life to a global TCM dietetics: Changing perceptions of foods in Chinese medicine 
Scheid, V. 2017. From civilising foods for nourishing life to a global TCM dietetics: Changing perceptions of foods in Chinese medicine . in: Leung, A. and Caldwell, M.L. (ed.) Moral Foods: The Construction of Nutrition and Health in Modern Asia Honolulu University of Hawaii Press.

Handbook of Formulas in Chinese Medicine
Scheid, V. and Ellis, A. 2016. Handbook of Formulas in Chinese Medicine. Seatte Eastland Press.

History of Chinese medicine, 1890 - 2010
Scheid, V. and Karchmer, E.I. 2016. History of Chinese medicine, 1890 - 2010. in: Modern Chinese Religion II: 1850-2015, Vol. 1 Leiden Brill. pp. 141-196

Review of Benjamin A. Elman (ed.), Antiquarianism, Language and Medical Philology: From Early Modern to Modern Sino-Japanese Medical Discourses (Leiden and Boston: Brill, 2015), pp. viii, 232, $135.00, hardback, ISBN: 978-90-04-28544-6
Scheid, V. 2016. Review of Benjamin A. Elman (ed.), Antiquarianism, Language and Medical Philology: From Early Modern to Modern Sino-Japanese Medical Discourses (Leiden and Boston: Brill, 2015), pp. viii, 232, $135.00, hardback, ISBN: 978-90-04-28544-6. Medical History. 60 (1), pp. 110-112.

Holism, Chinese medicine and systems ideologies: rewriting the past to imagine the future
Scheid, V. 2016. Holism, Chinese medicine and systems ideologies: rewriting the past to imagine the future. in: Whitehead, A. and Woods, A. (ed.) The Edinburgh Companion to the Critical Medical Humanities Edinburgh Edinburgh University Press. pp. 66-86

Desires: Capitalism, The Pope and Chinese Medicine
Scheid, V. 2016. Desires: Capitalism, The Pope and Chinese Medicine. Somatosphere.

Chinese medicine treatment for menopausal symptoms in the UK health service: Is a clinical trial warranted?
Scheid, V., Tuffrey, V., Weijburg, T., Bovey, M. and Ward, T. 2014. Chinese medicine treatment for menopausal symptoms in the UK health service: Is a clinical trial warranted? Maturitas. 80 (2), pp. 179-186.

The institutionalization of Chinese medicine
Scheid, V. and Lei, S.H.L. 2014. The institutionalization of Chinese medicine. in: Andrews, B. and Brown Bullock, M. (ed.) Medical Transitions in Twentieth-Century China Bloomington Indiana University Press. pp. 244-266

Convergent lines of descent: symptoms, patterns, constellations & the emergent interface of systems biology and Chinese medicine
Scheid, V. 2014. Convergent lines of descent: symptoms, patterns, constellations & the emergent interface of systems biology and Chinese medicine. East Asian Science, Technology and Society: an International Journal. 8 (1), pp. 107-139.

Depression, constraint and the liver: (dis)assembling the treatment of emotion-related disorders in Chinese medicine
Scheid, V. 2013. Depression, constraint and the liver: (dis)assembling the treatment of emotion-related disorders in Chinese medicine. Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry. 37 (1), pp. 30-58.

Transmitting Chinese Medicine: Changing Perceptions of Body, Pathology, and Treatment in Late Imperial China
Scheid, V. 2013. Transmitting Chinese Medicine: Changing Perceptions of Body, Pathology, and Treatment in Late Imperial China. East Asian Medicine: Tradition & Modernity. 8 (2), pp. 299-360.

Constraint 鬱 as a Window on Approaches to Emotion-Related Disorders in East Asian Medicine
Scheid, V. 2013. Constraint 鬱 as a Window on Approaches to Emotion-Related Disorders in East Asian Medicine. Culture, Medicine, and Psychiatry. 37 (1), pp. 2-7.

Introduction
Scheid, V. and MacPherson, H. 2012. Introduction. in: Scheid, V. and MacPherson, H. (ed.) Integrating East Asian medicine into contemporary healthcare Elsevier. pp. 1-12

Fei Shengfu 費繩甫 (1851-1914): resolving the exterior to treat fever with loss of consciousness
Scheid, V. 2012. Fei Shengfu 費繩甫 (1851-1914): resolving the exterior to treat fever with loss of consciousness. in: Scheid, V. and MacPherson, H. (ed.) Integrating East Asian medicine into contemporary healthcare Elsevier. pp. 22-23

Defining best practice or cultivating best practitioners
Scheid, V. 2012. Defining best practice or cultivating best practitioners. in: Scheid, V. and MacPherson, H. (ed.) Integrating East Asian medicine into contemporary healthcare Elsevier. pp. 13-38

Contemporary China (chapter 8)
Scheid, V. 2012. Contemporary China (chapter 8). in: Barnes, L. and Hinrichs, T.J. (ed.) Chinese medicine and healing: an illustrated history Harvard University Press.

Constellations, significations, methods: case histories in late imperial China
Scheid, V. 2012. Constellations, significations, methods: case histories in late imperial China. in: Scheid, V. and MacPherson, H. (ed.) Integrating East Asian medicine into contemporary healthcare Elsevier. pp. 126-127

Chinese medicine in the treatment of menopausal symptoms
Scheid, V. 2012. Chinese medicine in the treatment of menopausal symptoms. in: Scheid, V. and MacPherson, H. (ed.) Integrating East Asian medicine into contemporary healthcare Elsevier. pp. 25-26

Case histories in Chinese medicine
Scheid, V. 2012. Case histories in Chinese medicine. in: Scheid, V. and MacPherson, H. (ed.) Integrating East Asian medicine into contemporary healthcare Elsevier.

Constructing an evidence base for East Asian medicines
Flower, A., Scheid, V. and Lewith, G.T. 2012. Constructing an evidence base for East Asian medicines. in: Scheid, V. and MacPherson, H. (ed.) Integrating East Asian medicine into contemporary healthcare Elsevier. pp. 139-156

Mapping the epistemological diversity of Chinese medicine; a Q methodology study
Ward, T. 2011. Mapping the epistemological diversity of Chinese medicine; a Q methodology study. PhD thesis University of Westminster School of Life Sciences

A research oxymoron: objectifying human skills
Ward, T. 2011. A research oxymoron: objectifying human skills. in: Scheid, V. and MacPherson, H. (ed.) Integrating East Asian medicines into contemporary healthcare Churchill Livingstone.

Realising enactments of Chinese medicine
Ward, T. 2011. Realising enactments of Chinese medicine. in: Scheid, V. and MacPherson, H. (ed.) Integrating East Asian medicines into contemporary healthcare Elsevier.

More like hairdressing than acupuncture
Ward, T. 2011. More like hairdressing than acupuncture. in: Scheid, V. and MacPherson, H. (ed.) Integrating East Asian medicines into contemporary healthcare Churchill Livingstone.

Comparing TCM textbook descriptions of menopausal syndrome with the lived experience of London women at midlife and the implications for Chinese medicine research
Scheid, V., Ward, T. and Tuffrey, V. 2010. Comparing TCM textbook descriptions of menopausal syndrome with the lived experience of London women at midlife and the implications for Chinese medicine research. Maturitas. 66 (4), pp. 408-416.

Women's mid-life health experiences in urban UK: an international comparison
Ward, T., Scheid, V. and Tuffrey, V. 2010. Women's mid-life health experiences in urban UK: an international comparison. Climacteric: the journal of the International Menopause Society. 13 (3), pp. 278-288.

Negotiating contradictory information in Chinese medicine practice
Ward, T. 2010. Negotiating contradictory information in Chinese medicine practice. in: Hendry, J. (ed.) Anthropologists, indigenous scholars and the research endeavour : seeking bridges towards mutual respect. Oxford Berghahn.

Chinese medicine in the West 2009
Deadman, P., MacPherson, H., Maxwell, D., Moir, F. and Scheid, V. 2009. Chinese medicine in the West 2009. Journal of Chinese Medicine. 90, pp. 6-18.

Chinese medicine practitioners perspectives on the use of biomedical information in their practice: a Q methodological study
Ward, T. 2009. Chinese medicine practitioners perspectives on the use of biomedical information in their practice: a Q methodological study. in: Wangchuk, D. (ed.) Proceedings of ICTAM VII: Seventh International Congress on Traditional Asian Medicine, September 7th to 11th, 2009, Institute for traditional medicine services, Thimphu, Bhutan IASTAM.

Chinese herbal medicine: formulas & strategies. 2nd revised edition
Scheid, V., Bensky, D., Ellis, A. and Barolet, R. 2009. Chinese herbal medicine: formulas & strategies. 2nd revised edition. Vista, CA Eastland Press.

Globalising Chinese medical understandings of menopause
Scheid, V. 2008. Globalising Chinese medical understandings of menopause. East Asian Science, Technology and Society: an International Journal. 2 (4), pp. 485-506.

Developing research strategies in complementary and alternative medicine
MacPherson, H., Thomas, K., Armstrong, B., de Valois, B., Relton, C., Mullinger, B., White, A., Flower, A. and Scheid, V. 2008. Developing research strategies in complementary and alternative medicine. Complementary Therapies in Medicine. 16 (6), pp. 359-362.

Transforming emotions with Chinese medicine: an ethnographic account from contemporary China (review)
Scheid, V. 2008. Transforming emotions with Chinese medicine: an ethnographic account from contemporary China (review). Bulletin of the History of Medicine. 82 (3), pp. 762-764.

The mangle of practice and the practice of Chinese medicine: a case study from nineteenth-century China
Scheid, V. 2008. The mangle of practice and the practice of Chinese medicine: a case study from nineteenth-century China. in: Pickering, A. and Guzik, K. (ed.) The mangle in practice: science, society, and becoming Durham ; London Duke University Press. pp. 110-128

Authenticity, best practice, and the evidence mosaic: the challenge of integrating traditional East Asian medicines into Western health care
Scheid, V. 2008. Authenticity, best practice, and the evidence mosaic: the challenge of integrating traditional East Asian medicines into Western health care. Complementary Therapies in Medicine. 16 (2), pp. 107-108.

Acupuncture for hypertension: a tale of two trials. From the perspective of the anthropologist
Scheid, V. 2007. Acupuncture for hypertension: a tale of two trials. From the perspective of the anthropologist. Forschende Komplementärmedizin. 14 (6), pp. 371, 374-375.

Traditional Chinese medicine - what are we investigating? The case of menopause
Scheid, V. 2007. Traditional Chinese medicine - what are we investigating? The case of menopause. Complementary Therapies in Medicine. 15 (1), pp. 54-68.

Yun Tieqiao
Scheid, V. 2007. Yun Tieqiao. in: Bynum, W.F. and Bynum, H. (ed.) Dictionary of Medical Biography, vol 5 Westport, CT ; London Greenwood Press. pp. 480-842

Fei Boxiong
Scheid, V. 2007. Fei Boxiong. in: Bynum, W.F. and Bynum, H. (ed.) Dictionary of Medical Biography, vol 2 Westport, CT ; London Greenwood Press. pp. 480-842

Ding Ganren
Scheid, V. 2007. Ding Ganren. in: Bynum, W.F. and Bynum, H. (ed.) Dictionary of Medical Biography, vol 2 Westport, CT ; London Greenwood Press. pp. 480-842

Currents of tradition in Chinese medicine, 1626-2006
Scheid, V. 2007. Currents of tradition in Chinese medicine, 1626-2006. Seattle, USA Eastland Press.

Contemporary education in Chinese medicine under a strategy of standardization: a response
Scheid, V. 2007. Contemporary education in Chinese medicine under a strategy of standardization: a response. in: Thieme Almanac 2007: acupuncture and Chinese medicine Thieme Medical Publishers. pp. 203-204

Chinese medicine and the problem of tradition
Scheid, V. 2006. Chinese medicine and the problem of tradition. Asian Medicine. 7 (2), pp. 59-71.

Safety concerns involving Chinese herbal medicine
Ward, T. 2005. Safety concerns involving Chinese herbal medicine. in: Mills, S. and Bone, K. (ed.) The essential guide to herbal safety Edinburgh, UK Elsevier. pp. 119-127

Restructuring the field of Chinese medicine: a study of the Menghe and Ding scholarly currents, 1600-2000 (Part 2)
Scheid, V. 2005. Restructuring the field of Chinese medicine: a study of the Menghe and Ding scholarly currents, 1600-2000 (Part 2). East Asian Science, Technology, and Medicine. 23, pp. 10-68.

Restructuring the field of Chinese medicine: a study of the Menghe and Ding scholarly currents, 1600-2000 (Part 1)
Scheid, V. 2004. Restructuring the field of Chinese medicine: a study of the Menghe and Ding scholarly currents, 1600-2000 (Part 1). East Asian Science, Technology, and Medicine. 22, pp. 10-68.

Menghe yixue xintan (a new enquiry into Menghe physicians)
Scheid, V. 2004. Menghe yixue xintan (a new enquiry into Menghe physicians). Zhonghua Yixuehui Zazhishe / Chinese Journal of Medical History. 34 (2), pp. 67-73.

Ye Tianshi's strategies for the treatment of bloody stools
Scheid, V. 2003. Ye Tianshi's strategies for the treatment of bloody stools. Journal of Chinese Medicine. 71, pp. 41-55.

Remodeling the arsenal of Chinese medicine: shared pasts, alternative futures
Scheid, V. 2002. Remodeling the arsenal of Chinese medicine: shared pasts, alternative futures. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science. 583 (1), pp. 136-159.

Wujin medicine remembered: memory, networks and social identity in Chinese medicine, 1800-2000
Scheid, V. 2002. Wujin medicine remembered: memory, networks and social identity in Chinese medicine, 1800-2000. Taiwanese Journal for Studies of Science, Technology, and Medicine. 2, pp. 121-184.

Kexue and guanxixue: plurality, tradition and modernity in contemporary Chinese medicine
Scheid, V. 2002. Kexue and guanxixue: plurality, tradition and modernity in contemporary Chinese medicine. in: Ernst, W. (ed.) Plural medicine, tradition and modernity, 1800-2000 London, UK Routledge. pp. 130-152

Famous contemporary chinese physicians: Professor Shen Zhong-li
Scheid, V. 2002. Famous contemporary chinese physicians: Professor Shen Zhong-li. Journal of Chinese Medicine. 65, pp. 33-40.

Chinese medicine in contemporary China: plurality and synthesis
Scheid, V. 2002. Chinese medicine in contemporary China: plurality and synthesis. Durham, USA Duke University Press.

Shaping Chinese medicine: two case studies from contemporary China
Scheid, V. 2001. Shaping Chinese medicine: two case studies from contemporary China. in: Hsu, E. (ed.) Innovation in Chinese Medicine Cambridge, UK Cambridge University Press. pp. 370-404

The globalisation of Chinese medicine
Scheid, V. 1999. The globalisation of Chinese medicine. The Lancet. 354 (Supplement 4), p. siv10.

Book review: a Qin Bowei anthology: clinical essays
Scheid, V. 1998. Book review: a Qin Bowei anthology: clinical essays. European Journal of Oriental Medicine. 2 (5).

Chinese acupuncture (Review of L'Acuponcture Chinoise by G. Soulié de Morant)
Scheid, V. 1996. Chinese acupuncture (Review of L'Acuponcture Chinoise by G. Soulié de Morant). China Review International. 3 (1), pp. 269-271.

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/90298/the-treatment-of-menopausal-symptoms-by-traditional-east-asian-medicines-review-and-perspectives


Share this
Tweet
Email