Finance and welfare: the impact of two world wars on domestic policy in France

Lynch, F.M.B. 2006. Finance and welfare: the impact of two world wars on domestic policy in France. Historical Journal. 49 (2), pp. 625-633.

TitleFinance and welfare: the impact of two world wars on domestic policy in France
AuthorsLynch, F.M.B.
Abstract

In the traditional historiography of twentieth-century France the period after the Second World War is usually contrasted favourably with that after 1918. After 1945, new men with new ideas, born out of the shock of defeat in 1940 and resistance to Nazi occupation, laid the basis for an economic and social democracy. The welfare state was created, women were given full voting rights, and French security, in both economic and territorial respects, was partially guaranteed by integrating West Germany into a new supranational institutional structure in Western Europe. 1945 was to mark the beginning of the '30 glorious years' of peace and prosperity enjoyed by an expanding population in France. In sharp contrast, the years after 1918 are characterized as a period dominated by France's failed attempts to restore its status as a great power. Policies based on making the German taxpayer finance France's restoration are blamed for contributing to the great depression after 1929 and the rise of Hitler. However, as more research is carried out into the social and economic reconstruction of France after both world wars, it is becoming clear that the basis of what was to become the welfare state after 1945 was laid in the aftermath of the First World War. On the other hand, new reforms adopted in 1945 which did not build on interwar policies, such as those designed to give workers a voice in decision-making at the workplace, proved to be short-lived.

JournalHistorical Journal
Journal citation49 (2), pp. 625-633
ISSN0018-246X
YearJun 2006
FileLynch_2006_final.pdf
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)doi:10.1017/S0018246X06005371
Publication dates
PublishedJun 2006

Related outputs

The Powerlessness of Employees in France: The Spread of Income Taxation, 1945-1980
Lynch, F.M.B. 2018. The Powerlessness of Employees in France: The Spread of Income Taxation, 1945-1980. in: Huerlimann, G., Brownlee, W.E. and Ide, E. (ed.) Worlds of Taxation. The Political Economy of Taxing, Spending, and Redistribution since 1945 Cham, Switzerland Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 131-155

Reading contemporary European history: a Milwardian perspective
Lynch, F.M.B. and Guirao, F. 2015. Reading contemporary European history: a Milwardian perspective. in: Lynch, F.M.B. and Guirao, F. (ed.) Alan S. Milward and Contemporary European History: Collected Academic Reviews Abingdon, Oxon Routledge.

The intellectual legacy of Alan S Milward
Lynch, F.M.B. and Guirao, F. 2014. The intellectual legacy of Alan S Milward. Journal of European Integration History. 20 (1), pp. 17-43.

The Haig-Shoup mission to France in the 1920s
Lynch, F.M.B. 2013. The Haig-Shoup mission to France in the 1920s. in: Brownlee, W.E., Ide, E. and Fukagai, Y. (ed.) The political economy of transnational tax reform: the Shoup mission to Japan in historical context Cambridge Cambridge University Press. pp. 61-85

L’eredità intellettuale di Alan S. Milward (The intellectual legacy of Alan S. Milward)
Lynch, F.M.B. 2012. L’eredità intellettuale di Alan S. Milward (The intellectual legacy of Alan S. Milward). Memoria e Ricerca. 41, p. 26.

A lifetime’s search for a theory of historical change
Lynch, F.M.B. and Guirao, F. 2012. A lifetime’s search for a theory of historical change. in: Lynch, F.M.B., Guirao, F. and Ramirez Perez, S.M. (ed.) Alan S. Milward and a century of European change Routledge. pp. 1-129

"The Implicit Theory of Historical Change in the work of Alan S. Milward" Barcelona Graduate School in Economics Working Paper no. 586
Lynch, F.M.B. and Guirao, F. 2011. "The Implicit Theory of Historical Change in the work of Alan S. Milward" Barcelona Graduate School in Economics Working Paper no. 586. Barcelona Graduate School in Economics.

UKDA Study No. 6358 - EuroPTax. Who pays for the state? The evolution of personal taxation in postwar Europe, 1958-2007
Lynch, F.M.B. and Weingarten, N. 2010. UKDA Study No. 6358 - EuroPTax. Who pays for the state? The evolution of personal taxation in postwar Europe, 1958-2007. Colchester, Essex UK Data Archive [distributor].

Harmonization through competition? The evolution of taxation in post-war Europe
Lynch, F.M.B. 2007. Harmonization through competition? The evolution of taxation in post-war Europe. in: Nehring, H. and Schui, F. (ed.) Global debates about taxation Basingstoke, UK Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 116-134

Les consequences de l'isolationnisme francais dans les annees 1940 et 1950
Lynch, F.M.B. 2006. Les consequences de l'isolationnisme francais dans les annees 1940 et 1950. in: L'economie francaise dans la competition internationale au XXe siecle: Colloque des 3 et 4 octobre 2002 / ministere de l'economie, des finances et de l'industrie; sous la direction scientifique de Maurice Levy-Leboyer Paris, France Comite pour l'histoire economique et financiere de la France. pp. 219-238

L'évolution des impôts sur le revenu des personnes physiques en France depuis 1945 dans un cadre comparatif
Lynch, F.M.B. 2006. L'évolution des impôts sur le revenu des personnes physiques en France depuis 1945 dans un cadre comparatif. in: L'impot en France aux XIXe et XXe siecles, comite pour l'histoire economique et financiere de la France La Documentation Française. pp. 91-107

Technological non-cooperation: Britain and Airbus, 1965-1969
Johnman, L. and Lynch, F.M.B. 2006. Technological non-cooperation: Britain and Airbus, 1965-1969. Journal of European Integration History. 12 (1), pp. 125-140.

Income tax and elections in Britain, 1950-2001
Johnson, P., Lynch, F.M.B. and Walker, J.G. 2005. Income tax and elections in Britain, 1950-2001. Electoral Studies. 24 (3), pp. 393-408.

Sponging off the poor
Johnson, P. and Lynch, F.M.B. 2004. Sponging off the poor. Guardian.

France and European integration: from the Schuman plan to economic and monetary union
Lynch, F.M.B. 2004. France and European integration: from the Schuman plan to economic and monetary union. Contemporary European History. 13 (1), pp. 117-121.

The road to concorde: Franco-British relations and the supersonic project
Johnman, L. and Lynch, F.M.B. 2002. The road to concorde: Franco-British relations and the supersonic project. Contemporary European History. 11 (2), pp. 229-252.

Les consequences de l'isolationnisme francais dans les annees 1940 et 1950
Lynch, F.M.B. 2002. Les consequences de l'isolationnisme francais dans les annees 1940 et 1950. L'economie Francaise dans la competition internationale ay WWe siecle, Comite pour l'histoire economique et financiere de la France. Paris, France 03-04 Oct 2002

A treaty too far? Britain, France, and concorde, 1961-1964
Johnman, L. and Lynch, F.M.B. 2002. A treaty too far? Britain, France, and concorde, 1961-1964. Twentieth Century British History. 13 (3), pp. 253-276.

L'evolution des impots sur le revenu des personnes physiques en France depuis 1945 dans un cade camparatif
Lynch, F.M.B. 2001. L'evolution des impots sur le revenu des personnes physiques en France depuis 1945 dans un cade camparatif. L'impot en France aux XIXe et XXe siecles, comite pour l'histoire economique et financiere de la France. Paris, France 2-4 May 2001

De Gaulle's first veto: France, the Rueff plan and the free trade area
Lynch, F.M.B. 2000. De Gaulle's first veto: France, the Rueff plan and the free trade area. Contemporary European History. 9 (1), pp. 111-135.

France and the origins of the European Community
Lynch, F.M.B. 1999. France and the origins of the European Community. in: Dahl, S. (ed.) National interest and the EEC/EC/EU Norway Tapir. pp. 15-26

"De Gaulle’s First Veto. France, the Rueff Plan and the Free Trade Area”, EUI Working Paper no. 98/2
Lynch, F.M.B. 1998. "De Gaulle’s First Veto. France, the Rueff Plan and the Free Trade Area”, EUI Working Paper no. 98/2. EUI.

A tax for Europe: the introduction of value added tax in France
Lynch, F.M.B. 1998. A tax for Europe: the introduction of value added tax in France. Journal of European Integration History. 4 (2), pp. 67-87.

“Funding the Modern State. The Introduction of Value Added Tax in France”, EUI Working Paper no. 97/2
Lynch, F.M.B. 1997. “Funding the Modern State. The Introduction of Value Added Tax in France”, EUI Working Paper no. 97/2. EUI.

Restoring France: the road to integration
Lynch, F.M.B. 1997. Restoring France: the road to integration. in: Griffiths, R.T. (ed.) The economic development of the EEC Edward Elgar.

France and the international economy: from Vichy to the treaty of Rome
Lynch, F.M.B. 1997. France and the international economy: from Vichy to the treaty of Rome. Routledge.

A missed opportunity to plan the reconstruction of Europe? Franco-British relations 1945-1947
Lynch, F.M.B. 1994. A missed opportunity to plan the reconstruction of Europe? Franco-British relations 1945-1947. in: Dumoulin, M. (ed.) Plans des temps de guerre pour l'Europe d'après-guerre, 1940-1947 – Wartime for Postwar Europe 1940-1947, Actes du colloque de Bruxelles 12-14 mai 1993, Contributions to the Symposium in Brussels, 12-14 May 1993 Brussels Bruylant. pp. 459-467

France and the European Payments Union
Lynch, F.M.B. 1993. France and the European Payments Union. in: Comité pour l’Histoire économique et financière du Ministère de l’Economie, des Finances et du Budget, Le Plan Marshall et le relèvement économique de l’Europe Paris Imprimerie Nationale. pp. 237-243

Le franc français 1952-1957. Débat sur la convertibilité
Lynch, F.M.B. 1993. Le franc français 1952-1957. Débat sur la convertibilité. in: Comité pour l’Histoire économique et financière du Ministère de l’Economie, des Finances et du Budget, Du franc Poincaré à l’Ecu Paris Imprimerie Nationale. pp. 385-395

The frontier of national sovereignty: history and theory, 1945-1992
Milward, A.S., Lynch, F.M.B., Romero, F., Ranieri, R. and Sorensen, V. 1993. The frontier of national sovereignty: history and theory, 1945-1992. Routledge.

Restoring France: the road to integration
Lynch, F.M.B. 1993. Restoring France: the road to integration. in: Milward, A.S., Lynch, F.M.B., Romero, F., Ranieri, R. and Sorensen, V. (ed.) The frontier of national sovereignty: history and theory, 1945-1992 Routledge. pp. 59-87

La France, la Grande Bretagne et le problème du dollar 1945-1950
Lynch, F.M.B. 1990. La France, la Grande Bretagne et le problème du dollar 1945-1950. Matériaux pour l’histoire de notre temps. 18, pp. 12-19.

France
Lynch, F.M.B. 1990. France. in: Graham, A. and Seldon, A. (ed.) Government and Economies in the Postwar World: Economic policies and comparative performance 1945-1985 Routledge. pp. 54-78

Le Conseil tripartite 1944-1948
Lynch, F.M.B. and Griffiths, R.T. 1988. Le Conseil tripartite 1944-1948. Guerres mondiales et conflits contemporaines. 152, pp. 39-62.

The Role of Jean Monnet in setting up the European Coal and Steel Community
Lynch, F.M.B. 1988. The Role of Jean Monnet in setting up the European Coal and Steel Community. in: Schwabe, K. (ed.) The Beginnings of the Schuman Plan Nomos Verlag. pp. 117-129

“The economic effects of the Korean War in France 1950-52”, EUI Working Paper no. 253
Lynch, F.M.B. 1986. “The economic effects of the Korean War in France 1950-52”, EUI Working Paper no. 253. EUI.

L’Echec de la petite Europe
Lynch, F.M.B. and Griffiths, R.T. 1986. L’Echec de la petite Europe. Revue historique. CCLXXIV (I), p. 1986.

“The impact of rearmament on French reconstruction”, EUI Colloquium Paper no. 4/86
Lynch, F.M.B. 1985. “The impact of rearmament on French reconstruction”, EUI Colloquium Paper no. 4/86. EUI.

“The Fritalux-Finebel negotiations 1947-1950”, EUI Working Paper no. 117
Lynch, F.M.B. 1985. “The Fritalux-Finebel negotiations 1947-1950”, EUI Working Paper no. 117. EUI.

“French Reconstruction in a European Context”, EUI Working Paper no. 86
Lynch, F.M.B. 1984. “French Reconstruction in a European Context”, EUI Working Paper no. 86. EUI.

Resolving the paradox of the Monnet Plan: national and international planning in French reconstruction
Lynch, F.M.B. 1984. Resolving the paradox of the Monnet Plan: national and international planning in French reconstruction. The Economic History Review. 37 (2), pp. 229-243.

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/92272/finance-and-welfare-the-impact-of-two-world-wars-on-domestic-policy-in-france


Share this
Tweet
Email