The Iraq invasion as a recent United Kingdom 'contribution to international law'

Carty, A. 2005. The Iraq invasion as a recent United Kingdom 'contribution to international law'. European Journal of International Law. 16 (1), pp. 143-151.

TitleThe Iraq invasion as a recent United Kingdom 'contribution to international law'
AuthorsCarty, A.
Abstract

The UK (as indeed the US) gave as its formal legal ground for the invasion of Iraq reliance upon interpretations of Security Council resolutions. In other words, there was no open admission by official legal advisers that the British invasion of Iraq created a new precedent for the development of international law, in particular a doctrine of pre-emptive attack. However, an understanding of state practice as a source of customary international law requires that one challenge the view that a state’s contribution to practice must be taken to be its stated legal position. Instead, one has to engage in an in-depth study of the motivations of state officials that move the institutions of the state. These need to be pieced together from official declarations and also from the work of known government advisers who are systematically developing policy with legal implications. Furthermore, one needs to consider the practice of a state as embedded in institutional continuities, including especially institutional planning for the future. This can be gleaned from a variety of official documents, such as White Papers, which set out the purposes for which institutions of the state, especially the armed forces, are being shaped. On this basis it is clear that the UK has committed itself to set a precedent for pre-emptive attack through its invasion of Iraq. That is clear from the studies considered in this essay.

JournalEuropean Journal of International Law
Journal citation16 (1), pp. 143-151
ISSN0938-5428
YearFeb 2005
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)doi:10.1093/ejil/chi109
Publication dates
PublishedFeb 2005

Related outputs

The distance and contemporaneity in exploring the practice of states: the British Archives in relation to the 1957 Oman and Muscat incident
Carty, A. 2005. The distance and contemporaneity in exploring the practice of states: the British Archives in relation to the 1957 Oman and Muscat incident. Singapore Year Book of International Law. 9, pp. 1-11.

Marxism and international law: perspectives for the American (twenty-first) century?
Carty, A. 2004. Marxism and international law: perspectives for the American (twenty-first) century? Leiden Journal of International Law. 17 (2), pp. 247-270.

State and nation in the international law tradition: a history of French-German antagonisms and possible responses in the Spanish late medieval tradition
Carty, A. 2004. State and nation in the international law tradition: a history of French-German antagonisms and possible responses in the Spanish late medieval tradition. in: Stolleis, M. and Yanagihara, M. (ed.) East Asian and European Perspectives in the History of International Law Baden-Baden, Germany Nomos Verlag.

The Corfu channel case: and the missing admiralty orders
Carty, A. 2004. The Corfu channel case: and the missing admiralty orders. Law and Practice of International Courts and Tribunals: a practitioners' journal. 3 (1), pp. 1-35.

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/92q3q/the-iraq-invasion-as-a-recent-united-kingdom-contribution-to-international-law


Share this
Tweet
Email