The role of paradigm analysis in the development of policies for a resource efficient economy

Vanner, R. and Bicket, M. 2016. The role of paradigm analysis in the development of policies for a resource efficient economy. Sustainability. 8 (7).

TitleThe role of paradigm analysis in the development of policies for a resource efficient economy
AuthorsVanner, R. and Bicket, M.
Abstract

Policy makers are often called upon to navigate between scientists’ urgent calls for long-term concerted action to reduce the environmental impacts due to resource use, and the public’s concerns over policies that threaten lifestyles or jobs. Against these political challenges, resource efficiency policy making is often a changeable and even chaotic process, which has fallen short of the political ambitions set by democratically elected governments. This article examines the importance of paradigms in understanding how the public collectively responds to new policy proposals, such as those developed within the project DYNAmic policy MiXes for absolute decoupling of environmental impact of EU resource use from economic growth (DYNAMIX). The resulting proposed approach provides a framework to understand how different concerns and worldviews converge within public discourse, potentially resulting in paradigm change. Thus an alternative perspective on how resource efficiency policy can be development is proposed, which envisages early policies to lay the ground for future far-reaching policies, by altering the underlying paradigm context in which the public receive and respond to policy. The article concludes by arguing that paradigm change is more likely if the policy is conceived, framed, designed, analyzed, presented, and evaluated from the worldview or paradigm pathway that it seeks to create (i.e. the destination paradigm).

Keywordsparadigm; worldview; discourse; DYNAMIX; policy; sequencing; practice; attitudes; behaviour; sustainability
JournalSustainability
Journal citation8 (7)
ISSN2071-1050
Year2016
PublisherMDPI
Publisher's versionsustainability-08-00645.pdf
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)doi:10.3390/su8070645
Web address (URL)http://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/8/7/645
Publication dates
Published08 Jul 2016

Related outputs

Development of DYNAMIX Policy Mixes - Deliverable 4.2, revised version, of the DYNAMIX project
Ekvall, T., Elander, M., Umpfenbach, K., Hirschnitz-Garbers, M., Hudson, C., Wunder, S., Nesbit, M., Keenleyside, C., Mazza, L., Russi, D., Tucker, G., Underwood, E., Withana, S., Bicket, M., Vanner, R., Kong, M.A., Tan, A., Bigano, A., Eboli, F., Gaska, J. and Sniegocki, A. 2016. Development of DYNAMIX Policy Mixes - Deliverable 4.2, revised version, of the DYNAMIX project. Gothenburg, Sweden IVL Swedish Environmental Research Institute.

Policy mixes for resource efficiency – conceptual issues, design and assessment challenges
Montevecchi, F., Hirschnitz-Garbers, M., Ekvall, T., Bicket, M. and ten Brink, P. 2016. Policy mixes for resource efficiency – conceptual issues, design and assessment challenges. MDPI.

Designing Policy Mixes for Resource Efficiency: The Role of Public Acceptability
Bicket, M. and Vanner, R. 2016. Designing Policy Mixes for Resource Efficiency: The Role of Public Acceptability. Sustainability. 8 (4), p. 366.

Breaking down barriers to a circular economy
Shaw, B. and Bicket, M. 2015. Breaking down barriers to a circular economy. The ENDS Report. 480, pp. 14-15.

How Much Greater Than the Sum of Its Parts? Evaluating Interactions Between Complex Policies
Bicket, M. How Much Greater Than the Sum of Its Parts? Evaluating Interactions Between Complex Policies. The 8th Annual Dupont Summit 2015 on Science, Technology, and Environmental Policy. The Historic Whittemore House, Washington DC, USA 04 - 04 Dec 2015

Children’s Independent Mobility: an international comparison and recommendations for action
Shaw, B., Bicket, M., Elliott, B., Fagan-Watson, B., Mocca, E., Hillman, M. and Fagan-Watson, B. 2015. Children’s Independent Mobility: an international comparison and recommendations for action. London Policy Studies Institute.

What range of methods is available to evaluate the implementation and impact of complex environmental policies on complex systems?
Fagan-Watson, B., Watson, T., Elliott, B., Vanner, R., Shaw, Ben and Morris, S. 2014. What range of methods is available to evaluate the implementation and impact of complex environmental policies on complex systems? A report to the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs. Policy Studies Institute. Defra, London.

Scoping study to identify potential circular economy actions, priority sectors, material flows and value chains
Bicket, M., Guilcher, S., Hestin, M., Hudson, C., Razzini, P., Tan, A., ten Brink, P., van Dijl, E., Vanner, R. and Watkins, E. 2014. Scoping study to identify potential circular economy actions, priority sectors, material flows and value chains. Luxembourg Publications Office of the European Union.

Social barriers to the adoption of smart homes
Balta-Ozkan, N., Davidson, R., Bicket, M. and Whitmarsh, L. 2013. Social barriers to the adoption of smart homes. Energy Policy. 63, pp. 363-374.

The development of smart homes market in the UK
Balta-Ozkan, N., Davidson, R., Bicket, M. and Whitmarsh, L. 2013. The development of smart homes market in the UK. Energy. 60, pp. 361-372.

The Big Society Concept in a Natural Environment Setting
Bell, S. and Vanner, R. 2011. The Big Society Concept in a Natural Environment Setting. A report to the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs. Policy Studies Institute. Defra, London.

Expanding the evidence base for the design of policy influencing consumer choice for products and services with environmental impacts: final report
Shaw, Ben, Mudgal, S., Bain, J., Kong, M.A., Muehmel, K., Shaw, Ben, McGeevor, K., Vanner, R. and Gruenig, M. 2011. Expanding the evidence base for the design of policy influencing consumer choice for products and services with environmental impacts: final report. European Commission, DG Environment.

Expanding the evidence base for the design of policy influencing consumer choice for products and services with environmental impacts: policy briefing
Mudgal, S., Bain, J., Kong, M.A., Muehmel, K., Shaw, Ben, McGeevor, K., Vanner, R. and Gruenig, M. 2011. Expanding the evidence base for the design of policy influencing consumer choice for products and services with environmental impacts: policy briefing. European Commission, DG Environment.

Sectoral sustainability and sustainability assessment methodologies: a review of methodology in light of collaboration with the UK oil and gas sector
Ekins, P. and Vanner, R. 2007. Sectoral sustainability and sustainability assessment methodologies: a review of methodology in light of collaboration with the UK oil and gas sector. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management. 50 (1), pp. 87-111.

Decommissioning of offshore oil and gas facilities: a comparative assessment of different scenarios
Ekins, P., Vanner, R. and Firebrace, J. 2006. Decommissioning of offshore oil and gas facilities: a comparative assessment of different scenarios. Journal of Environmental Management. 79 (4), pp. 420-438.

Zero emissions of oil in water from offshore oil and gas installations: economic and environmental implications
Ekins, P., Vanner, R. and Firebrace, J. 2006. Zero emissions of oil in water from offshore oil and gas installations: economic and environmental implications. Journal of Cleaner Production.

Management of produced water on offshore oil installations: a comparative assessment
Dymond, P., Ekins, P., Vanner, R. and Firebrace, J. 2006. Management of produced water on offshore oil installations: a comparative assessment. Produced Water Workshop. Aberdeen, UK 24-25 May 2006

Energy use in offshore oil and gas production: trends and drivers for efficiency from 1975 to 2025
Vanner, R. 2005. Energy use in offshore oil and gas production: trends and drivers for efficiency from 1975 to 2025. London, UK Policy Studies Institute.

Management of produced water on offshore oil installations: a comparative assessment using flow analysis
Ekins, P., Vanner, R. and Firebrace, J. 2005. Management of produced water on offshore oil installations: a comparative assessment using flow analysis. London, UK Policy Studies Institute.

A sectoral sustainable development methodology for the UK offshore oil and gas sector
Ekins, P., Vanner, R. and Firebrace, J. 2005. A sectoral sustainable development methodology for the UK offshore oil and gas sector. UKOOA Stakeholder Forum. London, UK 19 Apr 2005

A comparative assessment of options for produced water management in the North Sea
Ekins, P., Vanner, R. and Firebrace, J. 2005. A comparative assessment of options for produced water management in the North Sea. Offshore Europe: Oil and Gas Exhibition and Conference. Aberdeen, UK 06-09 Sep 2005

Management of produced water on offshore oil and gas facilities: comparative assessment using flow analysis
Ekins, P. and Vanner, R. 2005. Management of produced water on offshore oil and gas facilities: comparative assessment using flow analysis. Offshore Forum. London, UK 08 Feb 2005

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/9x0y9/the-role-of-paradigm-analysis-in-the-development-of-policies-for-a-resource-efficient-economy


Share this
Tweet
Email