Contextualising Individual Diversity Perceptions: A Relational Study across Egypt, Germany, and the United Kingdom Technology Industries

Maatwk, F. 2020. Contextualising Individual Diversity Perceptions: A Relational Study across Egypt, Germany, and the United Kingdom Technology Industries. PhD thesis University of Westminster Organisations, Economy and Society https://doi.org/10.34737/v11y0

TitleContextualising Individual Diversity Perceptions: A Relational Study across Egypt, Germany, and the United Kingdom Technology Industries
TypePhD thesis
AuthorsMaatwk, F.
Abstract

For this research, the influence of context on individual diversity perceptions was investigated. A relational approach was adopted to account for the influence of national culture, industry, organisation and identity on diversity perceptions. Current diversity literature has been criticised for being decontextualized and for not considering intersections between diversity dimensions. The dynamic and contextual nature of diversity has been, to a great extent, disregarded. Critical diversity studies call for a revitalisation of diversity research through comparative, contextual and intersectional research, which is the focus of this research. To preserve the context-specific nature of the diversity construct, a qualitative social constructionism epistemology was adopted. Thematic analysis was employed to analyse semi-structured in-depth interviews conducted with a total of 68 employees in the technology industry across three countries: Egypt, Germany and the United Kingdom. At the macro level, national culture was accounted for using Hofstede’s cultural dimensions, cultural tightness-looseness theory and the World Values Survey. At the meso level, industry diversity dynamics and organisational diversity management were considered. At the micro individual level, identity was theoretically conceptualised through social identity theory, professional role identity and intersectionality.

Findings have shown that perceived diversity is individually unique and is shaped by the interaction of the multiple contexts individuals exist within, as well as their social and professional identities. National culture has been shown to influence the diversity discourse, taboo topics, gender dynamics and individual diversity attitudes. The research has shown that in Egypt, individual diversity attitudes were avoidance and apprehension. In Germany, individual diversity attitudes were pragmatism and avoidance, and in the UK, individual diversity attitudes were evasiveness and simplification. The industry and organisation contexts have been found to influence individual diversity management perceptions. Three reactions to diversity management are proposed: frustration, incomprehension, and cynicism. The empirical study of perceived diversity is a conceptual contribution to knowledge. A framework of the influence of context on diversity perceptions has been proposed. The current study’s outcomes, in addition to theory and knowledge contributions, allow for explanations to be provided for diversity management practitioners regarding how employees perceive their diversity policies.

Year2020
File
File Access Level
Open (open metadata and files)
PublisherUniversity of Westminster
Publication dates
PublishedJan 2020
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.34737/v11y0

Related outputs

Can we decolonise Organisation Studies?
Limki, r and Maatwk, F. 2023. Can we decolonise Organisation Studies? University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w837w

Can we decolonise Business Management and Marketing?
Ahonen, P. and Maatwk, F. 2023. Can we decolonise Business Management and Marketing? University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w837v

Christopher Newfield: American schooling, Critical University Studies and decolonising university funding
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2022. Christopher Newfield: American schooling, Critical University Studies and decolonising university funding . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12vw

Kate M. Graham: Black History Year, white allyship and decolonial pedagogy in English Literature (Part 2)
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2022. Kate M. Graham: Black History Year, white allyship and decolonial pedagogy in English Literature (Part 2) . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12vv

Kate M. Graham: Black History Year, white allyship and decolonial pedagogy in English Literature (Part 1)
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2022. Kate M. Graham: Black History Year, white allyship and decolonial pedagogy in English Literature (Part 1) . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12vq

Ipshita Basu: “Politics of a New Normal”, decolonial storytelling and academics in social justice work
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2022. Ipshita Basu: “Politics of a New Normal”, decolonial storytelling and academics in social justice work . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12v9

Lola Olufemi: Feminism Interrupted, PhD Research and thinking about higher education through a feminist lens
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2022. Lola Olufemi: Feminism Interrupted, PhD Research and thinking about higher education through a feminist lens . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12v7

Tino Rwodzi: Identity work, Black women in STEM and dismantling racist assumptions in Biomedical Science
Maatwk, F., Araneta, K. and Fraser, J. 2022. Tino Rwodzi: Identity work, Black women in STEM and dismantling racist assumptions in Biomedical Science . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12v6

Remi-Joseph Salisbury: Critical Race Theory in the UK, decriminalising the classroom and decolonising educational research
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2022. Remi-Joseph Salisbury: Critical Race Theory in the UK, decriminalising the classroom and decolonising educational research . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12v5

Derin Fadina: “Unsettled Subjects” and decolonising Architecture
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2022. Derin Fadina: “Unsettled Subjects” and decolonising Architecture. University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12v4

Séagh Kehoe: The media as a colonial force, online politics of representation and decolonising Chinese Studies
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2022. Séagh Kehoe: The media as a colonial force, online politics of representation and decolonising Chinese Studies . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12v3

Zahra Butt: Student Unions, political activism and decolonising the curriculum
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2022. Zahra Butt: Student Unions, political activism and decolonising the curriculum. University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12v2

Eddie Bruce-Jones: Research on race in higher education and decolonising Law curricula
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2022. Eddie Bruce-Jones: Research on race in higher education and decolonising Law curricula . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12v1

Kyra Araneta: Sociology to International Relations, decolonising the Social Sciences and working in partnership
Maatwk, F., Araneta, K. and Fraser, J. 2022. Kyra Araneta: Sociology to International Relations, decolonising the Social Sciences and working in partnership . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12v0

University of Westminster Student Partnership Framework
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2022. University of Westminster Student Partnership Framework. London University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w0qz4

Fatima Maatwk: Student-staff partnership in the University and decolonising Business Studies
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2021. Fatima Maatwk: Student-staff partnership in the University and decolonising Business Studies . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12v8

Aishwarya Tiku: The British curriculum in an African context and decolonising Business Management Studies
Maatwk, F., Araneta, K. and Fraser, J. 2021. Aishwarya Tiku: The British curriculum in an African context and decolonising Business Management Studies . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12qz

Samir Pandya: ‘Equity’, Diversity and Inclusion and decolonising Architecture curricula
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2021. Samir Pandya: ‘Equity’, Diversity and Inclusion and decolonising Architecture curricula. University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12qy

Tamara Naouri: “All the spaces within Counselling Psychology have been colonised”
Maatwk, F., Araneta, K. and Fraser, J. 2021. Tamara Naouri: “All the spaces within Counselling Psychology have been colonised” . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12qx

Cheyenne Holborough: Creative writing as a tool for activism and decolonising English Literature
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2021. Cheyenne Holborough: Creative writing as a tool for activism and decolonising English Literature . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12qw

Moonisah Usman: Student partnership, anti-racist approaches to biomedical research and decolonising the Life Sciences
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2021. Moonisah Usman: Student partnership, anti-racist approaches to biomedical research and decolonising the Life Sciences . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12qv

Catherine Charrett: Settler colonialism, sovereignty and decolonising International Relations
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2021. Catherine Charrett: Settler colonialism, sovereignty and decolonising International Relations . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12qq

Raidat Suleiman: The “angry Black woman” stereotype, attacks on Critical Race Theory and decolonising Sociology (No. 11)
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2021. Raidat Suleiman: The “angry Black woman” stereotype, attacks on Critical Race Theory and decolonising Sociology (No. 11). University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12q9

Mrinalini Greedharry: ‘The limits of literature as liberation’ and decolonising English Literature curricula
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2021. Mrinalini Greedharry: ‘The limits of literature as liberation’ and decolonising English Literature curricula . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12q8

Tamara Reid: Inclusion, student partnership and decolonial work in higher education
Maatwk, F., Araneta, K. and Fraser, J. 2021. Tamara Reid: Inclusion, student partnership and decolonial work in higher education . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12q7

Olimpia Burchiellaro: LGBTQ Studies, queer politics and coloniality
Maatwk, F., Araneta, K. and Fraser, J. 2021. Olimpia Burchiellaro: LGBTQ Studies, queer politics and coloniality . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12q6

Dibyesh Anand: Colonial rule in China, securitization and decolonising International Relations
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2021. Dibyesh Anand: Colonial rule in China, securitization and decolonising International Relations . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12q5

Lubna Bin Zayyad: Representations in the media and decolonising Journalism
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2021. Lubna Bin Zayyad: Representations in the media and decolonising Journalism . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12q4

Tanveer Ahmed: Decolonising Fashion Design and shifting the Western canon
Maatwk, F., Fraser, J. and Araneta, K. 2021. Tanveer Ahmed: Decolonising Fashion Design and shifting the Western canon . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12q3

Deanne Bell: Decolonial atmospheres, retrospective autoethnography and decolonising Psychology
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2021. Deanne Bell: Decolonial atmospheres, retrospective autoethnography and decolonising Psychology . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12q2

Lubaba Khalid: Multiraciality, the attainment gap and student unions
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2021. Lubaba Khalid: Multiraciality, the attainment gap and student unions . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12q1

Yahlnaaw: Indigenous worldviews, language revitalisation and Psychology as a discipline
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2021. Yahlnaaw: Indigenous worldviews, language revitalisation and Psychology as a discipline . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w12q0

Welcome to the podcast! with Jennifer Fraser, Fatima Maatwk and Kyra Araneta
Araneta, K., Fraser, J. and Maatwk, F. 2021. Welcome to the podcast! with Jennifer Fraser, Fatima Maatwk and Kyra Araneta . University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w129y

Profiling successful change in Diversity & Inclusion: Law Firm Case Studies
Urwin, P. and Maatwk, F. 2021. Profiling successful change in Diversity & Inclusion: Law Firm Case Studies. Black Solicitors Network.

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/v11y0/contextualising-individual-diversity-perceptions-a-relational-study-across-egypt-germany-and-the-united-kingdom-technology-industries


Share this

Usage statistics

239 total views
658 total downloads
These values cover views and downloads from WestminsterResearch and are for the period from September 2nd 2018, when this repository was created.