Intermediary-led Participation in Regeneration: Governing and Networking Communities in Post- Developmental Urbanism - A Study of Seoul

Kim, K. 2021. Intermediary-led Participation in Regeneration: Governing and Networking Communities in Post- Developmental Urbanism - A Study of Seoul. PhD thesis University of Westminster Architecture and Cities

TitleIntermediary-led Participation in Regeneration: Governing and Networking Communities in Post- Developmental Urbanism - A Study of Seoul
TypePhD thesis
AuthorsKim, K.
Abstract

This thesis investigates the dynamics of community participation led by intermediary organisations in the urban regeneration of South Korea. Since the 2010s, the Korean government has tried to institutionalise community participation in its planning system by devising new partnerships between the state, citizens, and intermediary organisations. Intermediary organisations act as brokers to promote community participation throughout the regeneration process. Such intermediary intervention is a distinctive part of the recent planning system, which forms the basis for alternative approaches to past state-led or market-driven urban development in Korea. Despite its importance, the dynamics behind intermediary intervention have rarely been addressed. In particular, little attention has been paid to power relationships and social networks that are constructed through intermediary intervention, which can provide an additional insight into the fundamental nature of community participation in Korea’s planning system. Using research data collected mainly from fieldwork in Korea, this study explores the dynamics of community participation, with a focus on the governance arrangements and network structures that have evolved through intermediary intervention.

This thesis argues that intermediary intervention remains largely under state control, which restricts the financial resources and legal rights of intermediaries. While intermediary intervention has been managed by professional firms, its transformative potential for community empowerment has been undermined due to new rules and norms armed with expertise and professionalism, which were preferred by the state. On the other hand, more autonomous intermediary intervention has contributed to community empowerment but gained less institutional support, and this has enabled the state to maintain control over community participation, albeit in indirect ways. This thesis concludes that new challenges facing community participation emerging from intermediary intervention can be understood as a developmental legacy of the interventionist state in the post-developmental context in Korea. At the same time, it highlights that intermediary intervention can serve as a long-term platform to address such new challenges by constantly attempting to communicate with the citizens and negotiate with the state throughout the regeneration process. Investigating the dynamics of community participation also provides an opportunity to expand the empirical basis for a wider discourse on post-developmental urbanism in Korea and East Asia.

Year2021
File
File Access Level
Open (open metadata and files)
Publication dates
PublishedMay 2021

Related outputs

Between the state and citizens: Changing governance of intermediary organisations for inclusive and sustainable urban regeneration in Seoul
Kim, K., Križnik, B. and Kamvasinou, K. 2021. Between the state and citizens: Changing governance of intermediary organisations for inclusive and sustainable urban regeneration in Seoul. Land Use Policy. 105 (2021) 105433. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2021.105433

Rethinking Temporary Use Coordinators for the Regeneration of Underused Urban Spaces in Seoul
Kim, K. 2019. Rethinking Temporary Use Coordinators for the Regeneration of Underused Urban Spaces in Seoul. Journal of Regional and City Planning. 30 (1), pp. 1-12 1. https://doi.org/10.5614/jpwk.2019.30.1.1

Implementation Processes and Planning Standards of Small-Scale Housing Redevelopment in the United Kingdom (영국의 소규모주택 정비사업방식 및 계획기준 연구)
Kim, K. 2018. Implementation Processes and Planning Standards of Small-Scale Housing Redevelopment in the United Kingdom (영국의 소규모주택 정비사업방식 및 계획기준 연구). Urban Design Institute of Korea. 19 (5), pp. 21-36 2.

The Types of Small-Scale Housing Development and Their Design Standard in the UK (영국의 소규모주택 정비사업방식 및 계획기준 사례연구)
Kim, K. 2017. The Types of Small-Scale Housing Development and Their Design Standard in the UK (영국의 소규모주택 정비사업방식 및 계획기준 사례연구). in: 2017 국외 신진연구자 지원사업 결과집 (2017 Collection of the Papers in Early-Career Oversea Researcher Support Programme) Daejeon City, South Korea 한국토지주택연구소 (Korea Land and Housing Institute). pp. pp.607-646

Study on Street Revilisation based on Tactical Urbanism (택티컬 어바니즘 기반의 가로활성화 방안 연구)
Son, D. P., Ko, Y.H., Yoon, Z.S., Kim, K., Lee, J.E, Lee, J.K. and Chung, K.S. 2017. Study on Street Revilisation based on Tactical Urbanism (택티컬 어바니즘 기반의 가로활성화 방안 연구). Sejong City, South Korea 건축도시공간연구소 (Architecture and Urban Research Institute).

The Role of Community Anchor Organisations and their meaning in the UK (영국의 공동체 앵커 조직의 역할과 의미)
Kim, K. 2017. The Role of Community Anchor Organisations and their meaning in the UK (영국의 공동체 앵커 조직의 역할과 의미). in: 건축과 도시공간 (Architectural and Urban Space, vol.28) Sejong City, South Korea 건축도시공간연구소 (Architecture and Urban Research Institute). pp. 50-57

Commualising Local Assets: Community right to bid in the United Kingdom (지역자산을 커뮤니티 소유로: 영국의 지역공동체 입찰권리제도)
Kim, K. 2017. Commualising Local Assets: Community right to bid in the United Kingdom (지역자산을 커뮤니티 소유로: 영국의 지역공동체 입찰권리제도). in: 건축과 도시공간 (Architectural and Urban Space, vol.26) Sejong City, South Korea 건축도시공간연구소 (Architecture and Urban Research Institute). pp. 70-75

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/v51w8/intermediary-led-participation-in-regeneration-governing-and-networking-communities-in-post-developmental-urbanism-a-study-of-seoul


Share this
Tweet
Email

Usage statistics

18 total views
12 total downloads
1 views this month
2 downloads this month
These values are for the period from September 2nd 2018, when this repository was created

Export as