Between the state and citizens: Changing governance of intermediary organisations for inclusive and sustainable urban regeneration in Seoul

Kim, K., Križnik, B. and Kamvasinou, K. 2021. Between the state and citizens: Changing governance of intermediary organisations for inclusive and sustainable urban regeneration in Seoul. Land Use Policy. 105 (2021) 105433. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2021.105433

TitleBetween the state and citizens: Changing governance of intermediary organisations for inclusive and sustainable urban regeneration in Seoul
TypeJournal article
AuthorsKim, K., Križnik, B. and Kamvasinou, K.
Abstract

Cities across East Asia once experienced rapid economic growth and urban development under a strong interventionist state. The recent economic slowdown and political changes have pressured them to find alternatives to the previous state-led or market-driven urban development. New forms of participatory governance have been devised to mobilise citizen participation in decision-making. Citizen participation, however, is not simply about direct interactions between the state and citizens. It is also guided and facilitated by intermediary organisations that are state- or self-funded bodies working between the state and citizens. Seoul in South Korea is a case in point. Over the past decade, Seoul Metropolitan Government has institutionalised intermediary organisations to expand citizen participation in diverse areas of urban life. In urban development, a more inclusive approach has been
put forward through new partnerships between government, intermediary organisations, and citizens.
In this article, a case study of such partnership is critically examined. Urban regeneration in the
Changsin-Sungin Area shows two meaningful changes in the governance of the intermediary organisation. The first change occurred when the intermediary organisation recruited residents as staff members and helped them to create a new local cooperative. The second change happened when the
local cooperative took over the role of the intermediary organisation. Analysis of these changes revealed that intermediaries have a contradictory role in urban regeneration. On the one hand, the intermediary
intervention has expanded citizen participation and improved consistently the engagement of the community of practice. On the other hand, intermediary intervention has served to instrumentalise citizen participation and constrain the growth of an autonomous community of practice while helping
the state to retain control over urban regeneration. In this sense, the intermediary-led participation contains seeds of yet-to-be realised potential, albeit with the current flaws, for more inclusive and sustainable urban regeneration, which this study recognises as an integral part of emerging postdevelopmental urbanisation in South Korea.

KeywordsCitizen participation; Intermediary organisation; Participatory governance; Urban regeneration; Post-developmental urbanisation; South Korea
Article number105433
JournalLand Use Policy
Journal citation105 (2021)
ISSN0264-8377
Year2021
PublisherElsevier
Accepted author manuscript
License
CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
File Access Level
Open (open metadata and files)
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2021.105433
Publication dates
Published31 Mar 2021

Related outputs

Intermediary-led Participation in Regeneration: Governing and Networking Communities in Post- Developmental Urbanism - A Study of Seoul
Kim, K. 2021. Intermediary-led Participation in Regeneration: Governing and Networking Communities in Post- Developmental Urbanism - A Study of Seoul. PhD thesis University of Westminster Architecture and Cities

Experiencing interim landscapes: ephemerality and place-making
Kamvasinou, K. 2021. Experiencing interim landscapes: ephemerality and place-making . in: Heatherington, C. (ed.) Revealing Change in Cultural Landscapes: Material, Spatial and Ecological Considerations Abingdon, Oxon Routledge. pp. 34-45

The politics of rurality (editorial)
Kamvasinou, K. and Stringer, B. 2019. The politics of rurality (editorial). Landscape Research. 44 (7), pp. 783-786. https://doi.org/10.1080/01426397.2019.1641260

The politics of rurality
Kamvasinou, K. and Stringer, B. 2019. The politics of rurality. Taylor & Francis. https://doi.org/10.1080/01426397.2019.1641260

Alternative Urbanism in the Historic City Centre: A Transnational Perspective on Theory and Practice
Kamvasinou, K. and Akl, A. 2019. Alternative Urbanism in the Historic City Centre: A Transnational Perspective on Theory and Practice. AESOP Annual Congress Venice 2019. IUAV Venice, Italy 09 - 13 Jul 2019 Universita IUAV di Venezia.

Rethinking Temporary Use Coordinators for the Regeneration of Underused Urban Spaces in Seoul
Kim, K. 2019. Rethinking Temporary Use Coordinators for the Regeneration of Underused Urban Spaces in Seoul. Journal of Regional and City Planning. 30 (1), pp. 1-12 1. https://doi.org/10.5614/jpwk.2019.30.1.1

Documenting interim spaces as 21st century heritage
Kamvasinou, K. 2019. Documenting interim spaces as 21st century heritage. AMPS Tangible-Intangible Heritage(s): Design, social and cultural critiques on the past, the present and the future. University of East London 13 - 15 Jun 2018 AMPS CIO.

Surveying the Creative Use of Vacant Space in London, c.1945-95
Kamvasinou, K. and Milne, S. 2019. Surveying the Creative Use of Vacant Space in London, c.1945-95. in: Campbell, C.J., Giovine, A. and Keating, J. (ed.) Empty Spaces: Confronting emptiness in national, cultural and urban history London Institute of Historical Research, University of London.

Implementation Processes and Planning Standards of Small-Scale Housing Redevelopment in the United Kingdom (영국의 소규모주택 정비사업방식 및 계획기준 연구)
Kim, K. 2018. Implementation Processes and Planning Standards of Small-Scale Housing Redevelopment in the United Kingdom (영국의 소규모주택 정비사업방식 및 계획기준 연구). Urban Design Institute of Korea. 19 (5), pp. 21-36 2.

The Types of Small-Scale Housing Development and Their Design Standard in the UK (영국의 소규모주택 정비사업방식 및 계획기준 사례연구)
Kim, K. 2017. The Types of Small-Scale Housing Development and Their Design Standard in the UK (영국의 소규모주택 정비사업방식 및 계획기준 사례연구). in: 2017 국외 신진연구자 지원사업 결과집 (2017 Collection of the Papers in Early-Career Oversea Researcher Support Programme) Daejeon City, South Korea 한국토지주택연구소 (Korea Land and Housing Institute). pp. pp.607-646

Study on Street Revilisation based on Tactical Urbanism (택티컬 어바니즘 기반의 가로활성화 방안 연구)
Son, D. P., Ko, Y.H., Yoon, Z.S., Kim, K., Lee, J.E, Lee, J.K. and Chung, K.S. 2017. Study on Street Revilisation based on Tactical Urbanism (택티컬 어바니즘 기반의 가로활성화 방안 연구). Sejong City, South Korea 건축도시공간연구소 (Architecture and Urban Research Institute).

The Role of Community Anchor Organisations and their meaning in the UK (영국의 공동체 앵커 조직의 역할과 의미)
Kim, K. 2017. The Role of Community Anchor Organisations and their meaning in the UK (영국의 공동체 앵커 조직의 역할과 의미). in: 건축과 도시공간 (Architectural and Urban Space, vol.28) Sejong City, South Korea 건축도시공간연구소 (Architecture and Urban Research Institute). pp. 50-57

Commualising Local Assets: Community right to bid in the United Kingdom (지역자산을 커뮤니티 소유로: 영국의 지역공동체 입찰권리제도)
Kim, K. 2017. Commualising Local Assets: Community right to bid in the United Kingdom (지역자산을 커뮤니티 소유로: 영국의 지역공동체 입찰권리제도). in: 건축과 도시공간 (Architectural and Urban Space, vol.26) Sejong City, South Korea 건축도시공간연구소 (Architecture and Urban Research Institute). pp. 70-75

Interim Spaces and Creative Use
Kamvasinou, K. 2017. Interim Spaces and Creative Use.

Short Term Projects, Long Term Ambitions: Facets of Transience in Two London Development Sites
Kamvasinou, K. 2017. Short Term Projects, Long Term Ambitions: Facets of Transience in Two London Development Sites. in: Henneberry, J. (ed.) Transience and Permanence in Urban Development Hoboken, NJ Wiley-Blackwell. pp. 88-107

Temporary Intervention and Long Term Legacy: Lessons from London Case Studies
Kamvasinou, K. 2017. Temporary Intervention and Long Term Legacy: Lessons from London Case Studies. Journal of Urban Design. 22 (2), pp. 187-207. https://doi.org/10.1080/13574809.2015.1071654

Reimagining Interim Landscapes
Kamvasinou, K. 2014. Reimagining Interim Landscapes. in: Deriu, D., Kamvasinou, K. and Shinkle, E. (ed.) Emerging Landscapes: Between Production and Representation Farnham Routledge. pp. 147-159

Interim spaces: vacant land, creativity and innovation in the context of uncertainty
Kamvasinou, K. and Roberts, M. 2014. Interim spaces: vacant land, creativity and innovation in the context of uncertainty. in: Mariani, M. and Barron, P. (ed.) Terrain vague: interstices at the edge of the pale London Routledge. pp. 187-200

Critical perspectives on landscape: introduction
Deriu, D. and Kamvasinou, K. 2012. Critical perspectives on landscape: introduction. The Journal of Architecture. 17 (1), pp. 1-9. https://doi.org/10.1080/13602365.2012.659896

The public value of vacant urban land
Kamvasinou, K. 2011. The public value of vacant urban land. Municipal Engineer. 164 (3), pp. 157-166. https://doi.org/10.1680/muen.9.00020

Editing the field: video tales from globalised cityscapes
Kamvasinou, K. 2011. Editing the field: video tales from globalised cityscapes. in: Ewing, S., McGowan, J.M., Speed, C. and Bernie, V.C. (ed.) Architecture and field/work London Routledge. pp. 151-159

Notation timelines and the aesthetics of disappearance
Kamvasinou, K. 2010. Notation timelines and the aesthetics of disappearance. The Journal of Architecture. 15 (4), pp. 397-423. https://doi.org/10.1080/13602365.2010.507517

Vague parks: the politics of late twentieth-century urban landscapes
Kamvasinou, K. 2006. Vague parks: the politics of late twentieth-century urban landscapes. Architectural Research Quarterly. 10 (3-4), pp. 255-262. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1359135506000364

Reclaiming the obsolete in transitional landscapes: perception, motion, engagement
Kamvasinou, K. 2006. Reclaiming the obsolete in transitional landscapes: perception, motion, engagement. Journal of Landscape Architecture. 2006/2, pp. 16-27.

Contemporary urban gateways
Kamvasinou, K. 2005. Contemporary urban gateways. Annals for Aesthetics. 43, pp. 193-204.

The poetics of the ordinary: ambience in the moving transitional landscape
Kamvasinou, K. 2004. The poetics of the ordinary: ambience in the moving transitional landscape. in: Dorrian, M. and Rose, G. (ed.) Deterritorialisations: revisioning landscapes and politics London, UK Black Dog Publishing. pp. 182-185

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/v4q8y/between-the-state-and-citizens-changing-governance-of-intermediary-organisations-for-inclusive-and-sustainable-urban-regeneration-in-seoul


Restricted files

Accepted author manuscript

Under embargo until 31 Mar 2022
Share this
Tweet
Email

Usage statistics

24 total views
0 total downloads
1 views this month
0 downloads this month
These values are for the period from September 2nd 2018, when this repository was created

Export as