Observing the implementation of a social experiment

Walker, R., Hoggart, L. and Hamilton, G. 2008. Observing the implementation of a social experiment. Evidence and Policy. 4 (3), pp. 183-203.

TitleObserving the implementation of a social experiment
AuthorsWalker, R., Hoggart, L. and Hamilton, G.
Abstract

Large-scale, randomised social experiments remain rare in Britain despite random assignment being widely regarded as the gold-standard evaluative methodology. Random assignment involves randomly allocating potential programme recipients to one or more groups that receive a service and others that do not. One perceived impediment to randomised social experiments is the practical difficulty of implementing them in the field. This article reports on research on the implementation of the largest randomised social policy experiment yet undertaken in Britain - the Employment Retention and Advancement (ERA) evaluation. Such 'evaluations of evaluations' rarely have been done within randomised experiments, and the article highlights some of the tensions between operational realities and research ambitions in such experiments and suggests ways that researchers can attempt to resolve these tensions in the context of real-world programmes and institutions.

JournalEvidence and Policy
Journal citation4 (3), pp. 183-203
ISSN1744-2648
YearAug 2008
PublisherPolicy Press
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)doi:10.1332/174426408X338848
Web address (URL)http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/tpp/ep/2008/00000004/00000003/art00003
Publication dates
PublishedAug 2008

Related outputs

Draft evaluation plan for NSPCC HomeBuilders Commission
Morris, S., Hoggart, L. and Gulyurtlu, S. 2011. Draft evaluation plan for NSPCC HomeBuilders Commission. for the National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children.

Better off working? Work, poverty and benefit cycling
Ray, K., Hoggart, L., Vegeris, S. and Taylor, R.F. 2010. Better off working? Work, poverty and benefit cycling. York Joseph Rowntree Foundation.

Design options for the evaluation of the Progression to Work Pathfinders
Morris, S., Knight, G. and Hoggart, L. 2009. Design options for the evaluation of the Progression to Work Pathfinders. Department for Work and Pensions.

Rewarding responsibility? Long-term unemployed men and the welfare-to-work agenda
Ray, K., Hoggart, L., Taylor, R.F., Vegeris, S. and Campbell-Barr, V. 2009. Rewarding responsibility? Long-term unemployed men and the welfare-to-work agenda. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy. 27 (6), pp. 975-990.

Random assignment and informed consent: a case study of multiple perspectives
Walker, R., Hoggart, L. and Hamilton, G. 2008. Random assignment and informed consent: a case study of multiple perspectives. American Journal of Evaluation. 29 (2), pp. 156-174.

Implementation and second-year impacts for lone parents in the UK Employment Retention and Advancement (ERA) demonstration
Riccio, J.A., Bewley, H., Campbell-Barr, V., Dorsett, R., Hamilton, G., Hoggart, L., Marsh, A., Miller, C., Ray, K. and Vegeris, S. 2008. Implementation and second-year impacts for lone parents in the UK Employment Retention and Advancement (ERA) demonstration. Leeds Corporate Document Services.

Implementation and second-year impacts for New Deal 25 Plus customers in the UK Employment Retention and Advancement (ERA) demonstration
Miller, C., Bewley, H., Campbell-Barr, V., Dorsett, R., Hamilton, G., Hoggart, L., Homonoff, T., Marsh, A., Ray, K., Riccio, J.A. and Vegeris, S. 2008. Implementation and second-year impacts for New Deal 25 Plus customers in the UK Employment Retention and Advancement (ERA) demonstration. Leeds Corporate Document Services.

Lone parents and the challenge to make work pay
Hoggart, L. and Vegeris, S. 2008. Lone parents and the challenge to make work pay. in: Strelitz, J. and Lister, R. (ed.) Why money matters: family income, poverty and children's lives London Save the Children. pp. 44-51

London student pledge evaluation
Hoggart, L., MacKinnon, K., Ray, K., Taylor, R.F., Vegeris, S. and Parsons, C. 2008. London student pledge evaluation. Department for Children, Schools and Families.

The Lone Parents Pilots: A qualitative evaluation of Quarterly Work Focused Interviews (12+), Work Search Premium and In Work Credit
Ray, K., Vegeris, S., Brooks, S., Campbell-Barr, V., Hoggart, L., MacKinnon, K. and Shutes, I. 2007. The Lone Parents Pilots: A qualitative evaluation of Quarterly Work Focused Interviews (12+), Work Search Premium and In Work Credit. Leeds Corporate Document Services.

Camden Childcare Needs Assessment
Campbell-Barr, V., Hoggart, L., Soberman, P. and Andrei, L. 2007. Camden Childcare Needs Assessment. London Policy Studies Institute.

The sexual health needs of unaccompanied minors in Enfield and Haringey
Bradford, M., Hoggart, L. and Young, D. 2007. The sexual health needs of unaccompanied minors in Enfield and Haringey. Enfield and Haringey Teenage Pregnancy Partnership.

Young women, sexual behaviour and sexual decision-making
Hoggart, L. 2007. Young women, sexual behaviour and sexual decision-making. in: Thom, B., Sales, R. and Pearce, J. (ed.) Growing up with risk Bristol, UK Policy Press.

Implementation and first-year impacts of the UK Employment Retention and Advancement (ERA) demonstration
Dorsett, R., Campbell-Barr, V., Hamilton, G., Hoggart, L., Marsh, A., Miller, C., Phillips, J., Ray, K., Riccio, J.A., Rich, S. and Vegeris, S. 2007. Implementation and first-year impacts of the UK Employment Retention and Advancement (ERA) demonstration. Leeds, UK Corporate Document Services.

Making random assignment happen: evidence from the UK Employment Retention and Advancement (ERA) demonstration
Walker, R., Hoggart, L., Hamilton, G. and Blank, S. 2006. Making random assignment happen: evidence from the UK Employment Retention and Advancement (ERA) demonstration. Leeds, UK Corporate Document Services.

Young women, sex and choices: a study of young motherhood in Haringey
Hoggart, L., Nasserzadeh, S. and Shamash, M. 2006. Young women, sex and choices: a study of young motherhood in Haringey. London, UK Middlesex University and Haringey Teenage Pregnancy Unit.

Staying in work and moving up: evidence from the UK Employment Retention and Advancement (ERA) demonstration
Hoggart, L., Campbell-Barr, V., Ray, K. and Vegeris, S. 2006. Staying in work and moving up: evidence from the UK Employment Retention and Advancement (ERA) demonstration. Leeds, UK Corporate Document Services.

Sexual health
Hoggart, L. 2006. Sexual health. in: Fitzpatrick, T., Manning, N., Midgely, J., Kwon, H.J. and Pascall, G. (ed.) International encyclopedia of social policy London, UK Routledge.

Qualitative evaluation of Quarterly Work Focused Interviews (QWFI) and In Work Credit (IWC) for lone parents and partners and Work Search Premium (WSP) for lone parents: stage one report
Campbell-Barr, V., Vegeris, S., Hoggart, L. and Ray, K. 2006. Qualitative evaluation of Quarterly Work Focused Interviews (QWFI) and In Work Credit (IWC) for lone parents and partners and Work Search Premium (WSP) for lone parents: stage one report. London, UK Department for Work and Pensions.

Risk: young women and sexual decision-making
Hoggart, L. 2006. Risk: young women and sexual decision-making. Forum: Qualitative Social Research. 7 (1), p. Art 28.

Risk, young women and sexual decision-making
Hoggart, L. 2005. Risk, young women and sexual decision-making. ESRC Research network – Social Contexts and Responses to Risk – Launch Conference. University of Kent, Canterbury 28 - 29 Jan 2015

Young women, sexual behaviour and sexual decision-making
Hoggart, L. 2005. Young women, sexual behaviour and sexual decision-making. SCARR Launch Conference: Learning About Risk. Canterbury, UK 28-29 Jan 2005

Neoliberalism, the new right and sexual politics
Hoggart, L. 2005. Neoliberalism, the new right and sexual politics. in: Saad Filho, A. and Johnston, D. (ed.) Neoliberalism: a critical reader London, UK Pluto. pp. 149-155

The Employment Retention and Advancement scheme - the early months of implementation: summary and conclusions
Hall, N., Hoggart, L., Marsh, A., Phillips, J., Ray, K. and Vegeris, S. 2005. The Employment Retention and Advancement scheme - the early months of implementation: summary and conclusions. Leeds, UK Corporate Document Services.

Book review: Hera Cook (2004), The long sexual revolution: English women, sex, and contraception 1800 - 1975, Oxford; Oxford University Press, 412 pp., £35 hbk, ISBN 0-19-925239-4
Hoggart, L. 2005. Book review: Hera Cook (2004), The long sexual revolution: English women, sex, and contraception 1800 - 1975, Oxford; Oxford University Press, 412 pp., £35 hbk, ISBN 0-19-925239-4. Journal of Social Policy. 34 (2), pp. 337-339.

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/911zz/observing-the-implementation-of-a-social-experiment


Share this
Tweet
Email