Reconceptualising the standard of care in sport: The case of youth rugby in England and South Africa

Greenfield, S., Karstens, K., Osborn, G. and Rossouw, J.P. 2015. Reconceptualising the standard of care in sport: The case of youth rugby in England and South Africa. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal. 18 (6), pp. 2184-2217. doi:10.4314/PELJ.V18I6.05

TitleReconceptualising the standard of care in sport: The case of youth rugby in England and South Africa
AuthorsGreenfield, S., Karstens, K., Osborn, G. and Rossouw, J.P.
Abstract

Sport is an important area of civil society in both South Africa and England, and this article is broadly concerned with the relationship between sport and personal injury. More specifically, the article compares how rugby is regulated by the tort of negligence in England and delict in South Africa respectively. Regarding liability, for sport there are very specific factors that need to be taken into account. The article is concerned with, firstly, the broader context of sport as an important social and cultural activity, and secondly the specific sporting context that includes the rules of the game as well as the playing culture, with a focus on rugby at junior level. Through a critical and comparative analysis of how the standards of care in sport have been developed in both jurisdictions, the aim of this article is to consider how sport specific elements can be incorporated into the traditional legal principles. This comparative analysis contextualises the various discussions in the light of the differences between the English tort of negligence and the South African law of delict. Our argument is that the context and specificity of rugby should be more explicitly taken into account when evaluating potential liability. To establish a standard of care for sport is complex, with many factors to be taken into account and balanced against one another. The law of negligence/delict therefore needs to be adaptable and flexible to resolve new situations where injuries have occurred. Even in established situations where liability has been previously determined, novel events do occur and knowledge develops that requires a reconsideration of the principles that govern liability. In junior rugby, the risk of very serious injuries is relatively small and the law needs to tread a cautious path through liability, ensuring it is a vehicle that promotes sport rather than creating barriers to its enjoyment and practice. A greater understanding of sport, informed by detailed research, can unearth new areas of potential liability that will need to be considered in the future.

Keywords Negligence; Delict; Standards of care; Sport; South Africa; England; Public Policy; Litigation; Youth Rugby
JournalPotchefstroom Electronic Law Journal
Journal citation18 (6), pp. 2184-2217
ISSN1727-3781
Year2015
PublisherAcademy of Science of South Africa
Publisher's version06.pdf
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)doi:10.4314/PELJ.V18I6.05
Publication dates
Published2015

Related outputs

Pliant Bodies: Generic event laws and the normalisation of the exceptional
Osborn, G. and James, M. 2018. Pliant Bodies: Generic event laws and the normalisation of the exceptional. Australian and New Zealand Sports Law Journal.

Aspects Of London’s Evening And Night Time Economy: A Report for the Mayor of London/ GLA
Roberts, M., Osborn, G., Eldridge, A., Robinson, J. and Flacks, S. 2018. Aspects Of London’s Evening And Night Time Economy: A Report for the Mayor of London/ GLA. London MusicTank.

Standing in the Line of Fire: Cricket Umpires, Injuries and Liability
Greenfield, S. 2018. Standing in the Line of Fire: Cricket Umpires, Injuries and Liability. National University of Juridical Sciences Law Review.

Risk and lifestyle sports: the case of bouldering
Osborn, G. 2017. Risk and lifestyle sports: the case of bouldering. Entertainment and Sports Law Journal. 15 (5), p. 5. doi:10.16997/eslj.211

Signposting risk: Parkour parks and the materialities of regulation
Gilchrist, P. and Osborn, G. 2017. Signposting risk: Parkour parks and the materialities of regulation. in: Turner, D. and Carnicelli, S. (ed.) Lifestyle Sports and Public Policy London Routledge. pp. 157-179

Beyond Kolpak: EU Law’s unforeseen contribution to the movement of African Cricketers
Greenfield, S., Osborn, G. and Rossouw, J. 2017. Beyond Kolpak: EU Law’s unforeseen contribution to the movement of African Cricketers. International Journal of the History of Sport. 33 (15), pp. 1748-1766. doi:10.1080/09523367.2017.1320987

Risk and benefits in lifestyle sports: parkour, law and social value
Gilchrist, P. and Osborn, G. 2017. Risk and benefits in lifestyle sports: parkour, law and social value. International Journal of Sport Policy and Politics. 9 (1), pp. 55-69. doi:10.1080/19406940.2016.1272619

Legal Cultures and the Regulation of Coaching Practice: Different Jurisdictions, Different Approaches?
Greenfield, S. 2016. Legal Cultures and the Regulation of Coaching Practice: Different Jurisdictions, Different Approaches? in: Sport coaching: Historical and cultural perspectives De Boeck Supérieur. pp. 87-96

Tobias Beecher: Law as a Refuge from Uncertainty?
Greenfield, S. 2016. Tobias Beecher: Law as a Refuge from Uncertainty? in: Picart , C.J., Jacobsen, M.H. and Greek, C. (ed.) Framing Law and Crime: An Interdisciplinary Anthology Maryland USA ; London The Fairleigh Dickinson University Press. pp. 455-476

Dancing on the Edge of Disciplines: Law and the Interdisciplinary Turn
Foster, K. and Osborn, G. 2016. Dancing on the Edge of Disciplines: Law and the Interdisciplinary Turn. in: Vamplew, W. and Dyreson, M. (ed.) Sports History. Volume IV: Flexible Boundaries Sage. pp. 17-30

Criminalising contract: does ticket touting warrant the protection of the criminal law?
James, M. and Osborn, G. 2016. Criminalising contract: does ticket touting warrant the protection of the criminal law? Criminal Law Review. 2016 (1), pp. 4-19.

The Olympics, transnational law and legal transplants: the International Olympic Committee, ambush marketing and ticket touting
James, M. and Osborn, G. 2016. The Olympics, transnational law and legal transplants: the International Olympic Committee, ambush marketing and ticket touting. Legal Studies. 36 (1), pp. 93-110. doi:10.1111/lest.12095

The Magic Screen: A History of Regent Street Cinema
Hunningher, J., Morgan-Tamosunas, R., Osborn, G. and Spankie, R. Penn, E. (ed.) 2015. The Magic Screen: A History of Regent Street Cinema. London University of Westminster.

Olympic brandscapes: London 2012 and the seeping commercialisation of public space
Osborn, G. and Smith, A. 2015. Olympic brandscapes: London 2012 and the seeping commercialisation of public space. in: Poynter, G., Viehoff, V. and Li, Y. (ed.) The London Olympics and urban development: the mega-event city London Routledge. pp. 139-153

The legal history of the Old Cinema: from 'disorderly house' to high-class cinematograph
Osborn, G. 2015. The legal history of the Old Cinema: from 'disorderly house' to high-class cinematograph. in: Hunningher, J., Morgan-Tamosunas, R., Osborn, G. and Spankie, R. (ed.) The magic screen: a history of Regent Street Cinema London University of Westminster. pp. 65-103

Is it possible to identify a category of ‘Law Film’ and how might it be applied?
Greenfield, S. 2014. Is it possible to identify a category of ‘Law Film’ and how might it be applied? PhD thesis University of Westminster Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities

The impact of film and television on perceptions of law and justice: towards a realisable methodology?
Greenfield, S., Osborn, G. and Robson, P. 2014. The impact of film and television on perceptions of law and justice: towards a realisable methodology? in: Sherwin, R.K. and Wagner, A. (ed.) Law culture and visual studies Dordrecht, Netherlands Springer. pp. 1011-1028

The missing link: the coming out of ambush marketing?
Osborn, G. 2014. The missing link: the coming out of ambush marketing? lawinsport.com.

Sochi and protesting in the zone
Osborn, G. 2014. Sochi and protesting in the zone. thejusticegap.com.

IOC rules at Sochi go too far with ban on black armbands
James, M. and Osborn, G. 2014. IOC rules at Sochi go too far with ban on black armbands. theconversation.com.

World Cup 2014, right to protest and ‘über’ law
Osborn, G. 2014. World Cup 2014, right to protest and ‘über’ law. thejusticegap.com.

Wearing badges is not enough...
Osborn, G. 2014. Wearing badges is not enough... thejusticegap.com.

The responsible tweeter
Osborn, G. 2013. The responsible tweeter. thejusticegap.com.

Guilty by association: Olympic law and the IP effect
Osborn, G. and James, M. 2013. Guilty by association: Olympic law and the IP effect. Intellectual Property Quarterly. 2, pp. 97-113.

State executioner Pierrepoint: a cinematic portrayal of moral disengagement?
Greenfield, S. 2013. State executioner Pierrepoint: a cinematic portrayal of moral disengagement? in: International library of essays on capital punishment Farnham Ashgate.

Keeping children safe whilst playing sport: what can South Africa learn from the United Kingdom experience?
Greenfield, S. 2013. Keeping children safe whilst playing sport: what can South Africa learn from the United Kingdom experience? De Jure. 46 (1), pp. 366-384.

Grounds for benefit: developing and protecting community benefit in football stadia
Brown, A., McGee, F. and Osborn, G. 2013. Grounds for benefit: developing and protecting community benefit in football stadia. Supporters Direct.

From beyond the grave: the legal regulation of mediumship
Osborn, G., Greenfield, S. and Roberts, S. 2012. From beyond the grave: the legal regulation of mediumship. International Journal of Law in Context. 8 (1), pp. 97-114. doi:10.1017/S1744552311000383

The poacher turned gamekeeper: James Ferman and the increasing intervention of the law
Osborn, G. and Sinclair, A. 2012. The poacher turned gamekeeper: James Ferman and the increasing intervention of the law. in: Lamberti, E. (ed.) Behind the scenes at the BBFC: film classification from the silver screen to the digital age Palgrave Macmillan.

The Olympics, the law and the contradictions of olympism
Osborn, G., James, M. and Greenfield, S. 2012. The Olympics, the law and the contradictions of olympism. in: Jefferson Lenskyj, H. and Wagg, S. (ed.) The Palgrave handbook of Olympic studies Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 304-317

The Olympic laws and the tensions and contradictions of promoting and preserving the Olympic ideal
Osborn, G. and James, M. 2012. The Olympic laws and the tensions and contradictions of promoting and preserving the Olympic ideal. in: Girnigov, V. (ed.) Handbook of the the London 2012 Olympic and Paralympic Games Routledge. pp. 74-86

London 2012 and the impact of the UK’s Olympic and Paralympic legislation: protecting commerce or preserving culture?
James, M. and Osborn, G. 2011. London 2012 and the impact of the UK’s Olympic and Paralympic legislation: protecting commerce or preserving culture? Modern Law Review. 74 (3), pp. 410-429. doi:10.1111/j.1468-2230.2011.00853.x

The juridification of sport: a comparative analysis of children’s rugby and cricket in England and South Africa
Greenfield, S., Osborn, G. and Rossouw, J.P. 2011. The juridification of sport: a comparative analysis of children’s rugby and cricket in England and South Africa. Journal for Juridical Science. 36 (1), pp. 85-104.

Sport and the law: considerations for sports managers
Greenfield, S. and Osborn, G. 2011. Sport and the law: considerations for sports managers. in: Trenberth, L. and Hassan, D. (ed.) Managing sport business: an introduction Taylor & Francis. pp. 285-298

Developing football regulation to encourage supporter community ownership in football
Brown, A., Jaquiss, K., James, M., Kiernan, A., Osborn, G., Boyle, D. and Hall, T. 2011. Developing football regulation to encourage supporter community ownership in football. Supporters Direct.

Developing public policy to encourage supporter community ownership in football
Brown, A., Jaquiss, K., James, M., Kiernan, A. and Osborn, G. 2011. Developing public policy to encourage supporter community ownership in football. Supporters Direct.

Dancing on the edge of disciplines: law and the interdisciplinary turn
Foster, K. and Osborn, G. 2010. Dancing on the edge of disciplines: law and the interdisciplinary turn. Entertainment and Sports Law Journal. 8 (1), p. 2. doi:10.16997/eslj.41

Film and the law. 2nd edition
Greenfield, S., Osborn, G. and Robson, P. 2010. Film and the law. 2nd edition. Oxford Hart.

Regulating sport: finding a role for the law?
Greenfield, S. and Osborn, G. 2010. Regulating sport: finding a role for the law? Sport in Society: Cultures, Commerce, Media, Politics. 13 (2), pp. 367-379. doi:10.1080/17430430903523127

Law and regulation in sport
Greenfield, S. and Osborn, G. 2010. Law and regulation in sport. in: Chadwick, S. and Hamil, S. (ed.) Managing football: an international perspective London Butterworth Heinemann. pp. 73-84

Tickets, policy and social inclusion: can the European white paper on sport deliver?
James, M. and Osborn, G. 2009. Tickets, policy and social inclusion: can the European white paper on sport deliver? International Sports Law Journal. 2009 (1-2).

Matlock - America's greatest lawyer? A transatlantic perspective
Greenfield, S., Osborn, G. and Robson, P. 2009. Matlock - America's greatest lawyer? A transatlantic perspective. in: Asimow, M. (ed.) Lawyers in your living room! Law on television Chicago ABA Press. pp. 105-116

Judge John Deed! British TV lawyers in the 21st century
Greenfield, S., Osborn, G. and Robson, P. 2009. Judge John Deed! British TV lawyers in the 21st century. in: Asimow, M. (ed.) Lawyers in your living room: law on television Chicago ABA Press. pp. 205-216

Solstorm: developing a semantic/syntactic approach to law films
Greenfield, S. 2009. Solstorm: developing a semantic/syntactic approach to law films. Stetson law review. 39, pp. 119-152.

Contradictions within the criminalisation of ticket touting: what should be the role of the law?
Greenfield, S., Osborn, G. and Roberts, S. 2008. Contradictions within the criminalisation of ticket touting: what should be the role of the law? Web Journal of Current Legal Issues. 2008 (3).

Understanding commercial music contracts: the place of contractual theory
Osborn, G. 2007. Understanding commercial music contracts: the place of contractual theory. Journal of Contract Law. 23, pp. 248-268.

Genre, iconography and British legal film
Greenfield, S., Osborn, G. and Robson, P. 2007. Genre, iconography and British legal film. Baltimore Law Review. 36 (3), pp. 371-391.

A continental ambience? Lessons in managing alcohol-related evening and night-time entertainment from four European capitals
Roberts, M., Turner, C., Greenfield, S. and Osborn, G. 2006. A continental ambience? Lessons in managing alcohol-related evening and night-time entertainment from four European capitals. Urban Studies. 43 (7), pp. 1105-1125. doi:10.1080/00420980600711423

Law, music and the creative process: who is an author?
Greenfield, S. and Osborn, G. 2006. Law, music and the creative process: who is an author? in: Greenfield, S. and Osborn, G. (ed.) Readings in law and popular culture London, UK Routledge. pp. 310-324

Law, legal education and popular culture
Greenfield, S. and Osborn, G. 2006. Law, legal education and popular culture. in: Greenfield, S. and Osborn, G. (ed.) Readings in law and popular culture London, UK Routledge. pp. 1-11

Perceptions of lawyers: a transnational study of student views on the image of law and lawyers
Asimow, M., Greenfield, S., Jorge, G., Machura, S., Osborn, G., Robson, P., Sharp, C. and Sockloskie, R. 2005. Perceptions of lawyers: a transnational study of student views on the image of law and lawyers. International Journal of the Legal Profession. 12 (3), pp. 407-436. doi:10.1080/09695950500420358

The double meaning of law: does it matter if film lawyers are unethical?
Greenfield, S. and Osborn, G. 2005. The double meaning of law: does it matter if film lawyers are unethical? in: Freeman, M. (ed.) Law and popular culture Oxford, UK Oxford University Press.

Copyright law and power in the music industry
Greenfield, S. and Osborn, G. 2004. Copyright law and power in the music industry. in: Simon, F. and Marshall, L. (ed.) Music and copyright. 2nd edition Edinburgh Edinburgh University Press. pp. 89-102

A continental ambience? A study of the urban management of mixed-use entertainment neighbourhoods in northern European cities
Roberts, M., Newman, P., Bailey, Nick, Greenfield, S., Osborn, G. and Edmundson, T. 2002. A continental ambience? A study of the urban management of mixed-use entertainment neighbourhoods in northern European cities. London, UK Institute of Alcohol Studies.

Borders and boundaries: locating the law in film
Osborn, G. 2001. Borders and boundaries: locating the law in film. Journal of Law and Society. 28 (1), pp. 164-176. doi:10.1111/1467-6478.00185

Hero or villain?: Cinematic lawyers and the delivery of justice
Greenfield, S. 2001. Hero or villain?: Cinematic lawyers and the delivery of justice. Journal of Law and Society. 28 (1), pp. 25-39. doi:10.1111/1467-6478.00176

Film and the law
Greenfield, S., Osborn, G. and Robson, P. 2001. Film and the law. London, UK Cavendish Publishing.

Regulating football: commodification consumption and the law
Greenfield, S. and Osborn, G. 2001. Regulating football: commodification consumption and the law. London, UK Pluto.

The ties that bind: charting contemporary sporting contractual relation
Greenfield, S. 2000. The ties that bind: charting contemporary sporting contractual relation. in: Greenfield, S. and Osborn, G. (ed.) Law and sport in contemporary society London, UK Frank Cass. pp. 129-154

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/9w3v3/reconceptualising-the-standard-of-care-in-sport-the-case-of-youth-rugby-in-england-and-south-africa


Share this
Tweet
Email