‘Every Coward’s Choice’? Political Objection to Military Service in Apartheid South Africa as Sexual Citizenship

Conway, D. 2004. ‘Every Coward’s Choice’? Political Objection to Military Service in Apartheid South Africa as Sexual Citizenship. Citizenship Studies. 8 (1), pp. 25-45. doi:10.1080/1362102042000178418

Title‘Every Coward’s Choice’? Political Objection to Military Service in Apartheid South Africa as Sexual Citizenship
AuthorsConway, D.
Abstract

Sexuality was articulated by the apartheid state as a means of disciplining the white population and marginalizing white opponents of apartheid. As such, homophobia was a recurrent feature of political and legal discourse. The End Conscription Campaign (ECC) opposed compulsory conscription for all white men in the apartheid era South African Defence Force (SADF). Its challenge was a potentially radical and profoundly destabilizing one and it articulated a competing definition of citizenship to that offered by the state. The pro‐ and anti‐conscription discourse was inherently gendered and overtly sexualized. The South African government regularly associated men who objected to military service with effeminacy, cowardice and sexual ‘deviance’. The case of Dr Ivan Toms' objection, a gay objector who wished to cite his sexuality as a primary motivation for his objection, reveals the unwillingness of the ECC to engage in sexual politics. Using Shane Phelan's and Zygmunt Bauman's concept of friends, enemies and strangers, this paper investigates the construction of both white gay men and white people who opposed apartheid as ‘strangers’ and suggests that the deployment of homophobia by the state was a stigmatizing discourse aimed at purging the ECC's political message from the public realm. In this context the ECC adopted an assimilatory discursive strategy, whereby they attempted to be ‘respectable whites’, negotiating over shared republican territory. This populist strategy, arguably safer in the short term, avoided issues of sexuality and the fundamental conflation of sexuality and citizenship in apartheid South Africa. The ECC thus circumscribed its radical and deconstructive political potential and did not offer a ‘radical democratic’ message in opposition to apartheid.

Keywordsmilitarisation, conscription, war resistance, conscientious objection, sexual citizenship, LGBT, homophobia, South Africa, apartheid
JournalCitizenship Studies
Journal citation8 (1), pp. 25-45
ISSN1362-1025
Year2004
PublisherTaylor & Francis
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)doi:10.1080/1362102042000178418
Publication dates
Published22 Oct 2010

Related outputs

Transgressing Transnational Normativity? British Migration and Interracial Marriage in South Africa
Conway, D. and Leonard, P. 2018. Transgressing Transnational Normativity? British Migration and Interracial Marriage in South Africa. in: Leonard, P. and Walsh, K. (ed.) British Migration: Privilege, Diversity and Vulnerability London Routledge. pp. 94-114

Banning Taste: Boycotts, Identity, and Resistance
Conway, D., Brighi, E., Kaul, N. and Khalili, L. 2018. Banning Taste: Boycotts, Identity, and Resistance. in: Schwabe, A., Pascu, D.F. and Connuck, J. (ed.) The Empire Remains Shop New York, US Columbia University Press. pp. 47-50

Shades of White Complicity: The End Conscription Campaign and the Politics of White Liberal Ignorance in South Africa
Conway, D. 2017. Shades of White Complicity: The End Conscription Campaign and the Politics of White Liberal Ignorance in South Africa. in: Afxentiou, A., Dunford, R. and Neu. M. (ed.) Exploring Complicity: Concept, Cases and Critique London Rowman & Littlefield. pp. 119-142

Margaret Thatcher, Dress and the Politics of Fashion
Conway, D. 2016. Margaret Thatcher, Dress and the Politics of Fashion. in: Behnke, A. (ed.) The International Politics of Fashion: Being Fab in a Dangerous World London Routledge. pp. 161-185

Struggles for Citizenship in South Africa
Conway, D. 2014. Struggles for Citizenship in South Africa. in: Isin, E.F. and Nyers, P. (ed.) Routledge Handbook of Global Citizenship Studies London Routledge. pp. 240-251

Migration, Space and Transnational Identities: The British in South Africa
Conway, D. and Leonard, P. 2014. Migration, Space and Transnational Identities: The British in South Africa. London Palgrave Macmillan.

Masculinities, Militarisation and the End Conscription Campaign: War Resistance in Apartheid South Africa
Conway, D. 2012. Masculinities, Militarisation and the End Conscription Campaign: War Resistance in Apartheid South Africa. Manchester Manchester University Press.

Intersecting Whiteness: Interdisciplinary Debates
Steyn, M. and Conway, D. 2010. Intersecting Whiteness: Interdisciplinary Debates. Ethnicities. 10 (3), pp. 283-291. doi:10.1177/1468796810372309

Queering Apartheid: The National Party’s 1987 ‘Gay Rights’ Election Campaign in Hillbrow
Conway, D. 2009. Queering Apartheid: The National Party’s 1987 ‘Gay Rights’ Election Campaign in Hillbrow. Journal of Southern African Studies. 35 (4), pp. 849-863. doi:10.1080/03057070903313210

“Somewhere on the Border - Of Credibility”: The Cultural Construction and Contestation of ‘the Border’ in White Society
Conway, D. 2008. “Somewhere on the Border - Of Credibility”: The Cultural Construction and Contestation of ‘the Border’ in White Society. in: Baines, G. and Vale, P. (ed.) Beyond the Border War: New Perspectives on Southern Africa’s Late Cold War Conflicts University of South Africa (UNISA) Press.

Contesting the Masculine State: White Male War Resisters in Apartheid South Africa
Conway, D. 2008. Contesting the Masculine State: White Male War Resisters in Apartheid South Africa. in: Parpart, J.L. and Zalewski, M. (ed.) Rethinking the Man Question: Sex, Gender and Violence in International Relations Zed Books. pp. 127-142

The Masculine State in Crisis: War Resistance in Apartheid South Africa
Conway, D. 2008. The Masculine State in Crisis: War Resistance in Apartheid South Africa. Men and Masculinities. 10 (4), pp. 422-439. doi:10.1177/1097184X07306742

Masculinities and Narrating the Past: Experiences of Researching White men who Refused to Serve in the Apartheid Army
Conway, D. 2008. Masculinities and Narrating the Past: Experiences of Researching White men who Refused to Serve in the Apartheid Army. Qualitative Research. 8 (3), pp. 347-354. doi:10.1177/1468794106093631

White Masculinities
Conway, D. 2006. White Masculinities. in: Jones, A. (ed.) Men of the Global South: A Reader London Zed.

Masculinitiy,Citizenship and Objection to Military Service in the South African Defence Force
Conway, D. 2005. Masculinitiy,Citizenship and Objection to Military Service in the South African Defence Force. in: Gouws, A. (ed.) (Un)Thinking Citizenship: Feminist Debates in Contemporary South Africa Aldershot Ashgate.

Africa in the International System
Conway, D. 2002. Africa in the International System. in: Nel, P. and McGowan, P. (ed.) Power, Wealth and Global Order: An International Relations Textbook in Africa University of Cape Town Press.

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/9wyzw/-every-coward-s-choice-political-objection-to-military-service-in-apartheid-south-africa-as-sexual-citizenship


Share this
Tweet
Email