A ‘right to have rights’ in the EU public sphere? An Arendtian justification for the application of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights

Frantziou, E. 2016. A ‘right to have rights’ in the EU public sphere? An Arendtian justification for the application of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights. University of Birmingham.

TitleA ‘right to have rights’ in the EU public sphere? An Arendtian justification for the application of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights
AuthorsFrantziou, E.
Abstract

This paper discusses the Court’s reasoning in interpreting the EU Charter, using recent case law on horizontal effect as a case study. It identifies two possible means of interpreting the provisions of the Charter: firstly, an approach based on common values (e.g. equality or solidarity) and, secondly, an approach based on access to the public sphere. It argues in favour of the latter. Whereas an approach based on common values is more consonant with the development of the case law so far, it is conceptually problematic: it involves subjective assessments of the importance and degree of ‘sharedness’ of the value in question, which can undermine the equal constitutional status of different Charter provisions. Furthermore, it marginalises the Charter’s overall politically constructional character, which distinguishes it from other sources of rights protection listed in Art 6 TEU. The paper argues that, as the Charter’s provisions concretise the notion of political status in the EU, they have a primarily constitutional, rather than ethical, basis. Interpreting the Charter based on the very commitment to a process of sharing, drawing on Hannah Arendt’s idea of the ‘right to have rights’ (a right to access a political community on equal terms), is therefore preferable. This approach retains the pluralistic, post-national fabric of the EU polity, as it accommodates multiple narratives about its underlying values, while also having an inclusionary impact on previously underrepresented groups (e.g. non-market-active citizens or the sans-papiers) by recognising their equal political disposition.

Year2016
Output mediaIEL Working Paper 09/2016
KeywordsEU, Charter, Fundamental Rights, Hannah Arendt, Politics, Law
PublisherUniversity of Birmingham
Publication dates
PublishedAug 2016
File

Related outputs

Constitutional Reasoning in the European Union and the Charter of Fundamental Rights: In Search of Public Justification
Frantziou, E. 2019. Constitutional Reasoning in the European Union and the Charter of Fundamental Rights: In Search of Public Justification. European Public Law. 25 (2), p. 183–203.

Brexit and Article 50 TEU: A Constitutionalist Reading
Frantziou, E. and Eeckhout, P. 2017. Brexit and Article 50 TEU: A Constitutionalist Reading. Common Market Law Review. 54 (2017), pp. 695-734.

Brexit and Article 50 TEU: A Constitutionalist Reading
Eeckhout, P. and Frantziou, E. 2016. Brexit and Article 50 TEU: A Constitutionalist Reading. London UCL European Institute.

The Horizontal Effect of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights: Rediscovering the Reasons for Horizontality
Frantziou, E. 2015. The Horizontal Effect of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights: Rediscovering the Reasons for Horizontality. European Law Journal. 21 (5), pp. 657-679. doi:10.1111/eulj.12137

‘Further developments in the right to be forgotten: The European Court’s judgment in Case C-131/12, Google Spain, SL, Google Inc v Agencia Espanola de Proteccion de Datos’
Frantziou, E. 2014. ‘Further developments in the right to be forgotten: The European Court’s judgment in Case C-131/12, Google Spain, SL, Google Inc v Agencia Espanola de Proteccion de Datos’. Human Rights Law Review. 14 (4), pp. 761-777. doi:10.1093/hrlr/ngu033

Case C-176/12 Association de Médiation Sociale v Hichem Laboubi – Some Reflections on the Horizontal Effect of the Charter and the Reach of Fundamental Employment Rights in the European Union
Frantziou, E. 2014. Case C-176/12 Association de Médiation Sociale v Hichem Laboubi – Some Reflections on the Horizontal Effect of the Charter and the Reach of Fundamental Employment Rights in the European Union. European Constitutional Law Review (EuConst). 10 (2), pp. 332-348. doi:10.1017/S1574019614001205

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/9xy3x/a-right-to-have-rights-in-the-eu-public-sphere-an-arendtian-justification-for-the-application-of-the-eu-charter-of-fundamental-rights


Share this
Tweet
Email

Usage statistics

37 total views
26 total downloads
0 views this month
0 downloads this month
These values are for the period from September 2nd 2018, when this repository was created

Export as