The Haunted Landscape of the Uncanny North: Scott Graham’s Shell (2012) and Gordon Napier’s 1745 (2017)

Germanà, M. 2022. The Haunted Landscape of the Uncanny North: Scott Graham’s Shell (2012) and Gordon Napier’s 1745 (2017). Gothic Studies. 24 (1), pp. 93-109. https://doi.org/10.3366/gothic.2022.0124

TitleThe Haunted Landscape of the Uncanny North: Scott Graham’s Shell (2012) and Gordon Napier’s 1745 (2017)
TypeJournal article
AuthorsGermanà, M.
AbstractFocussing on the spatial dimension of historical haunting, this article analyses the depiction of northern scenery in contemporary Scottish cinema, to highlight a shift from the romanticised landscape of historical figurations of Scottish identity to a territory haunted both by the nation’s past traumas and its dark secrets. I examine Scott Graham’s film Shell (2012) and Gordon Napier’s 1745: An Untold Story of Slavery (2017) to demonstrate how, while they reference the sublime aesthetics and identity politics conventionally attached to the representation of the north and the cultural construction of the Scottish Highlands, these films also interrogate the relationship between history and landscape. Shell and 1745 consequently point to an ambivalent definition of belonging, made more complicated by the specific historical and political references rooted in the landscape. The Scottish north is unveiled as an uncanny territory, where a sense of belonging based on established national history narratives is replaced by the subversive (re)possession of the landscape by the less visible stories that continue to haunt it: the contemporary legacy of Highland Clearances in Shell and Scotland’s involvement in Empire and slavery in 1745.
KeywordsLiterature and Literary Theory
History
Contemporary Scottish cinema
Scott Graham
haunted landscape
Gordon Napier
Scotland and slavery
Scottish Highlands
Scottish north
JournalGothic Studies
Journal citation24 (1), pp. 93-109
ISSN1362-7937
2050-456X
Year2022
PublisherEdinburgh University Press
Accepted author manuscript
File Access Level
Open (open metadata and files)
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.3366/gothic.2022.0124
Publication dates
PublishedMar 2022

Related outputs

Vanishing Landmarks: Artivisim and Climate
Germanà, M. 2024. Vanishing Landmarks: Artivisim and Climate. The Soho Poly Nov 2024 - Jan 2025

“‘Sometimes the Old Ways Are the Best’”: A Gothic Reading of Technology and the Body in Sam Mendes’s Skyfall
Germanà, M. 2024. “‘Sometimes the Old Ways Are the Best’”: A Gothic Reading of Technology and the Body in Sam Mendes’s Skyfall. in: Hines, C., Sweeney, T. and Joy, S. (ed.) James Bond Will Return: Critical Perspectives on the 007 Film Franchise New York Wallflower Press. pp. 276-287

Skeleton Woman and the Haunted Underwater: A Three-Part Podcast Series
Germanà, M. 2023. Skeleton Woman and the Haunted Underwater: A Three-Part Podcast Series.

‘Engendering Globalgothic: The “hideous progeny” of Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein’
Germanà, M. 2023. ‘Engendering Globalgothic: The “hideous progeny” of Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein’. in: Duncan, R. (ed.) The Edinburgh Companion to Global Gothic Edinburgh Edinburgh University Press. pp. 84-99

‘Between Desire and Control: The Fashioned Image in Muriel Spark’s Life and Fiction’
Germanà, M. 2022. ‘Between Desire and Control: The Fashioned Image in Muriel Spark’s Life and Fiction’. in: Carruthers, G. and Stoddart, H. (ed.) The Crooked Dividend: Essays on Muriel Spark Glasgow Association for Scottish Literary Studies. pp. 63-87

Ghost-Tours, Body Snatchers, and Optical Illusions: An Introduction to Haunted Scotlands
Germanà, M. 2022. Ghost-Tours, Body Snatchers, and Optical Illusions: An Introduction to Haunted Scotlands. Gothic Studies. 24 (1), pp. 1-17. https://doi.org/10.3366/gothic.2022.0117

Ali Smith
Germanà, M. 2020. Ali Smith. in: The Wiley-Blackwell Encyclopedia of Contemporary British and Irish Literature Oxford Wiley. pp. 451-460

Bond Girls: Body, Fashion and Gender
Germanà, M. 2019. Bond Girls: Body, Fashion and Gender. London and New York Bloomsbury Academic.

Authorship, “Ghost-filled” Islands, and the Haunting Feminine: Contemporary Scottish Female Gothic’
Germanà, M. 2017. Authorship, “Ghost-filled” Islands, and the Haunting Feminine: Contemporary Scottish Female Gothic’. in: Germanà, M. and Davison, C. (ed.) The Edinburgh Companion to Scottish Gothic Edinburgh Edinburgh University Press. pp. 222-235

Ali Smith, Girl Meets Boy (2007)
Germanà, M. 2017. Ali Smith, Girl Meets Boy (2007). Studies in Scottish Literature. 43 (2), pp. 209-210.

Other Stories: Strangers and Intrusions in Ali Smith’s Fiction
Germanà, M. 2017. Other Stories: Strangers and Intrusions in Ali Smith’s Fiction. in: Acheson, J. (ed.) The Contemporary British Novel since 2000 Edinburgh Edinburgh University Press. pp. 99-108

Community Spirit? Haunting Secrets and Displaced Selves in Contemporary Scottish Fiction
Germanà, M. 2016. Community Spirit? Haunting Secrets and Displaced Selves in Contemporary Scottish Fiction. in: Lyall, S. (ed.) Community in Modern Scottish Literature Leiden Brill. pp. 235-253

The Coming of Age of Graphic Narratives
Germanà, M. 2015. The Coming of Age of Graphic Narratives . in: Berberich, C. (ed.) The Bloomsbury Introduction to Popular Fiction London Bloomsbury. pp. 163-181

Brownies
Germanà, M. 2014. Brownies. in: Weinstock, J. (ed.) Ashgate Encyclopedia of Literary and Cinematic Monsters Ashgate. pp. 61-66

“What Are All Those Things He Once Thought He Knew, and Where Have They Gone?”: The End of the Wor(l)d in Margaret Atwood’s Oryx and Crake (2003)
Germanà, M. 2014. “What Are All Those Things He Once Thought He Knew, and Where Have They Gone?”: The End of the Wor(l)d in Margaret Atwood’s Oryx and Crake (2003). in: Germanà, M. and Mousoutzanis, A. (ed.) Apocalyptic Discourse in Contemporary Culture: Post-Millennial Perspectives of the End of the World New York Routledge. pp. 206-219

The Awakening of Caledonias? Scottish Literature in the 1980s
Germanà, M. 2014. The Awakening of Caledonias? Scottish Literature in the 1980s. in: Wilson, L.G., Horton, E. and Tew, P. (ed.) 1980s: A Decade of Contemporary British Fiction London Bloomsbury Academic. pp. 51-74

The Death of the Lady: Haunted Garments and (Re-)Possession in Sarah Waters’s The Little Stranger’
Germanà, M. 2013. The Death of the Lady: Haunted Garments and (Re-)Possession in Sarah Waters’s The Little Stranger’. in: Mitchell, K. (ed.) Contemporary Critical Perspectives: Sarah Waters London Bloomsbury. pp. 114-128

‘The Uncanny can happen’: Desire and Belief in Ali Smith’s The Seer’
Germanà, M. 2013. ‘The Uncanny can happen’: Desire and Belief in Ali Smith’s The Seer’. in: Germanà, M. and Horton, E. (ed.) Contemporary Critical Perspectives: Ali Smith London Bloomsbury. pp. 115-129

Madness and the city: the collapse of reason and sanity in Alan Moore’s From Hell
Germanà, M. 2013. Madness and the city: the collapse of reason and sanity in Alan Moore’s From Hell. in: Green, M. (ed.) Alan Moore and the gothic tradition Manchester Manchester University Press.

Contemporary fiction
Germanà, M. 2012. Contemporary fiction. in: Norquay, G. (ed.) The Edinburgh companion to Scottish women's writing Edinburgh University Press.

Being human? Twenty-first century monsters
Germanà, M. 2012. Being human? Twenty-first century monsters. in: Edwards, J.D. and Soltysik Monnet, A. (ed.) The Gothic in Contemporary Literature and Popular Culture: Pop Goth Routledge.

Introduction: the sick body and the fractured self: (contemporary) Scottish gothic
Germanà, M. 2011. Introduction: the sick body and the fractured self: (contemporary) Scottish gothic. Gothic Studies. 13 (2), pp. 1-8.

Becoming Hyde: excess, pleasure and cloning
Germanà, M. 2011. Becoming Hyde: excess, pleasure and cloning. Gothic Studies. 13 (2), pp. 98-115. https://doi.org/10.7227/GS.13.2.9

The dear green place
Germanà, M. 2011. The dear green place. in: Book Ashby-de-la-Zouch Inkermen Press.

From hijab to sweatshops: segregated bodies and contested space in Monica Ali’s Brick Lane
Germanà, M. 2011. From hijab to sweatshops: segregated bodies and contested space in Monica Ali’s Brick Lane. in: Teverson, A. and Upstone, S. (ed.) Postcolonial spaces: the politics of place in contemporary culture London Palgrave Macmillan.

Beyond the gaps: postmodernist representations of the metropolis
Germanà, M. 2011. Beyond the gaps: postmodernist representations of the metropolis. in: Berberich, C., Hudson, R. and Campbell, N. (ed.) Land and identity: theory, memory and practice Amsterdam Rodopi.

Scottish women's gothic and fantastic writing: fiction since 1978
Germanà, M. 2010. Scottish women's gothic and fantastic writing: fiction since 1978. Edinburgh Edinburgh University Press.

Red stiletto
Germanà, M. 2009. Red stiletto. in: Cold turkey: a Christmas selection Ashby-de-la-Zouch Inkermen Press.

Lost and found
Germanà, M. 2009. Lost and found. in: Loss Ashby-de-la-Zouch Inkermen Press.

Plagiarising the Ettrick shepherd? A note on the manuscript of Charlotte Brontë's tales of the islanders and Winifred Gérin's Emily Brontë
Germanà, M. 2008. Plagiarising the Ettrick shepherd? A note on the manuscript of Charlotte Brontë's tales of the islanders and Winifred Gérin's Emily Brontë. Notes and Queries. 55 (4), pp. 461-463. https://doi.org/10.1093/notesj/gjn144

In and outside post-devolution Scotland: Scottish national identity and women writers
Germanà, M. 2008. In and outside post-devolution Scotland: Scottish national identity and women writers. in: Lunan, L., Macdonald, K.A. and Sassi, C. (ed.) Re-Visioning Scotland: new readings of the cultural canon Frankfurt am Main ; Oxford Peter Lang.

Crossing dream boundaries: decoding nonsense and fantastic ambiguities in Naomi Mitchison’s beyond this limit
Germanà, M. 2008. Crossing dream boundaries: decoding nonsense and fantastic ambiguities in Naomi Mitchison’s beyond this limit. in: MacPherson, P., Murray, C., Spark, G. and Corstorphine, K. (ed.) Sub-versions: cultural status, genre and critique Newcastle Cambridge Scholars Publishing. pp. 135-148

'Une Petite Mort’: Death, Love and Liminality in the Fiction of Ali Smith
Germanà, M. 2003. 'Une Petite Mort’: Death, Love and Liminality in the Fiction of Ali Smith. Ecloga. 3 (2003).

Real Gorgons or Fantastic Chimeras? Re-shaping Myth and Tradition: Alice Thompson’s Justine
Germanà, M. 2003. Real Gorgons or Fantastic Chimeras? Re-shaping Myth and Tradition: Alice Thompson’s Justine. esharp. 1 (1).

Historical Places of Interest, Books, Tourism and Advertising: Scottish Icons in Contemporary Halifax (Nova Scotia)
Germanà, M. 2003. Historical Places of Interest, Books, Tourism and Advertising: Scottish Icons in Contemporary Halifax (Nova Scotia). International Review of Scottish Studies. (28), pp. 22-46.

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/vv203/the-haunted-landscape-of-the-uncanny-north-scott-graham-s-shell-2012-and-gordon-napier-s-1745-2017


Share this

Usage statistics

118 total views
140 total downloads
These values cover views and downloads from WestminsterResearch and are for the period from September 2nd 2018, when this repository was created.