The role of supervisors in asynchronous learning models for dissertation teaching
Specht, D. and Lowe, H. 2025. The role of supervisors in asynchronous learning models for dissertation teaching. Journal of the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning.
Specht, D. and Lowe, H. 2025. The role of supervisors in asynchronous learning models for dissertation teaching. Journal of the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning.
| Title | The role of supervisors in asynchronous learning models for dissertation teaching |
|---|---|
| Type | Journal article |
| Authors | Specht, D. and Lowe, H. |
| Abstract | This study examines the extent to which the timing of supervisor allocation, module commencement date, and mode of delivery impact MA dissertation students' final outcomes within asynchronous learning environments. While the importance of dissertation supervision is widely acknowledged, the relative effect of supervisory support compared to structured online learning resources remains understudied, particularly in traditional universities adopting pandemic-era remote teaching models. The research addresses this gap by analysing data from 240 master students at a post-92 university who undertook fully remote dissertations without campus access or in-person tutorials during COVID-19 restrictions. Through quantitative analysis of academic outcomes and qualitative surveys, the study reveals how varied supervision patterns (including early vs delayed allocation), course timelines, and prior campus access influenced engagement with asynchronous materials and final dissertation grades. Results demonstrate that supervisor allocation timing emerged as the most critical factor, with cohorts receiving supervisors in Term 1 achieving significantly higher dissertation scores and deeper engagement with online resources than those allocated supervisors later. These findings highlight the enduring centrality of human mentorship even within structured asynchronous learning systems while challenging assumptions about the sufficiency of self-directed digital resources alone for complex research projects. The study contributes new empirical evidence about balancing technological and interpersonal supports in postgraduate research education. |
| Keywords | Online learning, asynchronous, dissertation supervision, self-directed learning, research education. |
| Journal | Journal of the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning |
| ISSN | 1527-9316 |
| Year | 2025 |
| Publisher | Indiana University Press |
| Accepted author manuscript | File Access Level Open (open metadata and files) |