The United Nations Security Council and the enforcement of international humanitarian law

Roscini, M. 2010. The United Nations Security Council and the enforcement of international humanitarian law. Israel Law Review. 43 (2), pp. 330-359.

TitleThe United Nations Security Council and the enforcement of international humanitarian law
AuthorsRoscini, M.
Abstract

This Article discusses the competences and powers of the UN Security Council in securing compliance with international humanitarian law, in particular through the adoption of the measures provided in Chapter VII of the Charter: The competence of the Council in this field can be founded on several legal grounds: on a broad interpretation of the notion of “threat to the peace” (Article 39 of the Charter), on Article 94(2) with regard to the International Court of Justice's judgments establishing violations of the jus in bello and also on the customary duty to ensure respect for international humanitarian law as reflected in Article 1 Common to the 1949 Geneva Conventions on the Protection of the Victims of War. In particular, such customary provision empowers the Security Council to react to any violation of international humanitarian law regardless of a nexus with concerns of international stability. Although the Council has adopted a variety of measures in relation to violations of the laws of war, the most incisive ones are those provided in Articles 41 and 42 of Chapter VII, which however are not without problems. The role the Security Council has played in the enforcement of international humanitarian law has been criticized because of its selective and opportunistic approach, which is due to the political nature of the organ. Also, in several instances the Council, far from securing compliance with the jus in bello, has instead interfered with its application. However selective and imperfect the Council's approach might be, though, its power to adopt decisions binding on UN members and its competence to take or authorize coercive measures involving the use of force make it potentially a formidable instrument against serious violations of international humanitarian law, partly remedying the lack of enforcing mechanisms in the treaties on the laws of war.

JournalIsrael Law Review
Journal citation43 (2), pp. 330-359
ISSN0021-2237
Year2010
PublisherCambridge University Press
FileRoscini_2010_as_published.pdf
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)doi:10.1017/S0021223700000790
Publication dates
Published2010

Related outputs

To what degree do the difficulties in tracing the author of the attack and assessing the extent of the effects remain a challenge for addressing the legal issues raised by “cyber weapons”?
Roscini, M. 2017. To what degree do the difficulties in tracing the author of the attack and assessing the extent of the effects remain a challenge for addressing the legal issues raised by “cyber weapons”? in: de Vidts, B. and Beruto, G.L. (ed.) Weapons and the International Rule of Law Milan, Italy Angeli Franco Editore. pp. 229-234

Animals and the law of armed conflict
Roscini, M. 2017. Animals and the law of armed conflict. Israel Yearbook on Human Rights. 47, pp. 35-67.

Military objectives in cyber warfare
Roscini, M. 2017. Military objectives in cyber warfare. in: Taddeo, M. and Glorioso, L. (ed.) Ethics and Policies for Cyber Operations Springer. pp. 99-113

On the 'inherent' character of the right of states to self-defence
Roscini, M. 2016. On the 'inherent' character of the right of states to self-defence. Cambridge Journal of International and Comparative Law. 4 (3), pp. 634-660.

Digital evidence as a means of proof before the International Court of Justice
Roscini, M. 2016. Digital evidence as a means of proof before the International Court of Justice. Journal of Conflict and Security Law. 21 (3), pp. 541-554.

Is there any room for the doctrine of fundamental rights of states in today's international law?
Joyner Daniel, H. and Roscini, M. 2015. Is there any room for the doctrine of fundamental rights of states in today's international law? Cambridge Journal of International and Comparative Law. 4 (3), pp. 467-481.

On Certain Legal Issues Arising from Article VI of the Treaty on the Non-proliferation of Nuclear Weapons
Roscini, M. 2015. On Certain Legal Issues Arising from Article VI of the Treaty on the Non-proliferation of Nuclear Weapons. in: Caraccioli, I., Pedrazzi, M., Vassalli di Dachenhausen, T. and Caracciolo, I. (ed.) Nuclear Weapons: Strengthening International Legal Regime The Hague, The Netherlands Eleven International Publishing. pp. 15-22

Evidentiary issues in international disputes related to state responsibility for cyber operations
Roscini, M. 2015. Evidentiary issues in international disputes related to state responsibility for cyber operations. in: Finkelstein, C., Ohlin, J.D. and Govern, K. (ed.) Cyber war - Law and ethics for virtual conflicts Oxford Oxford University Press. pp. 215-248

Evidentiary issues in international disputes related to state responsibility for cyber operations
Roscini, M. 2015. Evidentiary issues in international disputes related to state responsibility for cyber operations. Texas International Law Journal. 50 (2), pp. 233-273.

Cyber operations as a use of force
Roscini, M. 2015. Cyber operations as a use of force. in: Tsagourias, N. and Buchan, R. (ed.) Research handbook on international law and cyberspace Cheltenham Edward Elgar. pp. 233-254

International law, nuclear weapon-free zones and the proposed zone free of weapons of mass destruction in the Middle East
Roscini, M. 2014. International law, nuclear weapon-free zones and the proposed zone free of weapons of mass destruction in the Middle East. in: Nystuen, G., Casey-Maslen, S. and Golden Bersagel, A. (ed.) Nuclear weapons under international law Cambridge Cambridge University Press. pp. 321-346

Establishing state responsibility for historical injustices: the Armenian case
Roscini, M. 2014. Establishing state responsibility for historical injustices: the Armenian case. International Criminal Law Review. 14 (2), pp. 291-316.

Cyber-opérations et principe de proportionnalité en droit international humanitaire
Roscini, M. 2014. Cyber-opérations et principe de proportionnalité en droit international humanitaire. in: Société française pour le droit international, Internet et le droit international (Colloque de Rouen) Paris Pedone. pp. 261-271

Cyber operations and the use of force in international law
Roscini, M. 2014. Cyber operations and the use of force in international law. Oxford Oxford University Press.

Cyber operations as nuclear counterproliferation measures
Roscini, M. 2014. Cyber operations as nuclear counterproliferation measures. Journal of Conflict and Security Law. 19 (1), pp. 133-157.

Withdrawal from and termination of non-proliferation treaties
Roscini, M. and Joyner, D.H. 2012. Withdrawal from and termination of non-proliferation treaties. in: Joyner, D.H. and Roscini, M. (ed.) Non-proliferation law as a special regime Cambridge Cambridge University Press. pp. 151-171

Introduction
Roscini, M. and Joyner, D.H. 2012. Introduction. in: Joyner, D.H. and Roscini, M. (ed.) Non-proliferation law as a special regime Cambridge Cambridge University Press. pp. 1-14

Conclusions
Roscini, M. and Joyner, D.H. 2012. Conclusions. in: Joyner, D.H. and Roscini, M. (ed.) Non-proliferation law as a special regime Cambridge Cambridge University Press. pp. 270-277

Negative security assurances in the protocols additional to the treaties establishing nuclear weapon-free zones
Roscini, M. 2011. Negative security assurances in the protocols additional to the treaties establishing nuclear weapon-free zones. in: Gartner, H. (ed.) Obama and the Bomb - The Vision of a World Free of Nuclear Weapons Frankfurt am Main Peter Lang.

World wide warfare: Jus ad bellum and the use of cyber force
Roscini, M. 2010. World wide warfare: Jus ad bellum and the use of cyber force. in: von Bogdandy, A., Wolfrum, R. and Philipp, C.E. (ed.) Max Planck Yearbook of United Nations Law Leiden Martinus Nijhoff.

Book review: Daniel H. Joyner, International law and the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2009)
Roscini, M. 2010. Book review: Daniel H. Joyner, International law and the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2009). International and Comparative Law Quarterly. 59 (3), pp. 883-884.

Neighbourhood watch? The African Great Lakes Pact and ius ad bellum
Roscini, M. 2009. Neighbourhood watch? The African Great Lakes Pact and ius ad bellum. Zeitschrift für ausländisches öffentliches Recht und Völkerrecht. 69 (4), pp. 931-959.

Something old, something new: the 2006 Semipalatinsk Treaty on a nuclear weapon-free zone in Central Asia
Roscini, M. 2008. Something old, something new: the 2006 Semipalatinsk Treaty on a nuclear weapon-free zone in Central Asia. Chinese Journal of International Law. 7 (3), pp. 593-624.

Protection of natural environment in time of armed conflict
Roscini, M. 2008. Protection of natural environment in time of armed conflict. in: Bhuiyan, J.H., Doswald-Beck, L. and Chowdhury, A.R. (ed.) International humanitarian law: an anthology Nagpur LexisNexis Butterworths. pp. 155-179

Editorial
Roscini, M. 2008. Editorial. International Community Law Review. 10 (2), pp. 107-108.

Book review: Diritto internazionale-Problemi fondamentali by Tullio Treves [Giuffrè, Milano, 2005, 782 pp, ISBN 8814112967, €55 (p/bk)]
Roscini, M. 2008. Book review: Diritto internazionale-Problemi fondamentali by Tullio Treves [Giuffrè, Milano, 2005, 782 pp, ISBN 8814112967, €55 (p/bk)]. International and Comparative Law Quarterly. 57 (2), pp. 487-489.

Book review: Comunità internazionale e obblighi «erga omnes» by Paolo Picone [Jovene, Napoli, 2006, 684 pp, ISBN 8824316018, €35 (p/bk)]
Roscini, M. 2008. Book review: Comunità internazionale e obblighi «erga omnes» by Paolo Picone [Jovene, Napoli, 2006, 684 pp, ISBN 8824316018, €35 (p/bk)]. International and Comparative Law Quarterly. 57 (2), pp. 489-451.

Threats of armed force and contemporary international law
Roscini, M. 2007. Threats of armed force and contemporary international law. Netherlands International Law Review. 54 (2), pp. 229-277.

Great expectations: the implementation of the Rome Statute in Italy
Roscini, M. 2007. Great expectations: the implementation of the Rome Statute in Italy. Journal of International Criminal Justice. 5 (2), pp. 493-512.

La giurisdizione della Corte penale internazionale tra risoluzioni del Consiglio di sicurezza e accordi bilaterali di esenzione (The international criminal court’s jurisdiction between security council resolutions and bilateral exemption agreements)
Roscini, M. 2007. La giurisdizione della Corte penale internazionale tra risoluzioni del Consiglio di sicurezza e accordi bilaterali di esenzione (The international criminal court’s jurisdiction between security council resolutions and bilateral exemption agreements). in: Comunicazioni e Studi Giuffrè.

La giurisdizione della Corte penale internazionale tra risoluzioni del Consiglio di sicurezza e accordi bilaterali di esenzione
Roscini, M. 2007. La giurisdizione della Corte penale internazionale tra risoluzioni del Consiglio di sicurezza e accordi bilaterali di esenzione. in: Lanciotti, A. and Tanzi, A. (ed.) Le immunità nel diritto internazionale : temi scelti : atti del Convegno di Perugia, 23-25 maggo 2006 Turin Giappichelli. pp. 83-115

The efforts to limit the International Criminal Court's jurisdiction over nationals of non-party states: a comparative study
Roscini, M. 2006. The efforts to limit the International Criminal Court's jurisdiction over nationals of non-party states: a comparative study. Law and Practice of International Courts and Tribunals. 5 (3), pp. 495-527.

Targeting and contemporary aerial bombardment
Roscini, M. 2005. Targeting and contemporary aerial bombardment. International and Comparative Law Quarterly. 54 (2), pp. 411-444.

Italy: Law reform needed to implement the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court
Roscini, M. 2005. Italy: Law reform needed to implement the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court. Amnesty International.

I compiti delle Forze di pace dell'Unione Europea' (The tasks of the EU peace-keeping forces)
Roscini, M. 2005. I compiti delle Forze di pace dell'Unione Europea' (The tasks of the EU peace-keeping forces). in: Ronzitti, N. (ed.) Le forze di pace dell'Unione Europea (The peace-keeping forces of the European Union) Catanzaro, Italy Rubbettino. pp. 49-79

Democratic Republic of the Congo. Comments and recommendations of the July 2003 draft law implementing the Rome statute of the international criminal court
Roscini, M. 2004. Democratic Republic of the Congo. Comments and recommendations of the July 2003 draft law implementing the Rome statute of the international criminal court. London Amnesty International.

Le zone denuclearizzate (Nuclear weapon-free zones)
Roscini, M. 2003. Le zone denuclearizzate (Nuclear weapon-free zones). Turin, Italy G. Giappichelli.

The navigational rights of nuclear ships
Roscini, M. 2002. The navigational rights of nuclear ships. Leiden Journal of International Law. 15 (1), pp. 251-265.

La zone denuclearisee du sud-est asiatique: prpblemes de droit de la mer
Roscini, M. 2001. La zone denuclearisee du sud-est asiatique: prpblemes de droit de la mer. Revue Generale de Droit. 105, pp. 617-645.

La sesta Conferenza di riesame del Trattato sulla non proliferazione delle armi nucleari
Roscini, M. 2000. La sesta Conferenza di riesame del Trattato sulla non proliferazione delle armi nucleari. La Communita internazionale. 55, pp. 661-685.

La libertà di esprimere dichiarazioni razziste e blasfeme nella giurisprudenza della Corte europea dei diritti dell’uomo
Roscini, M. 1998. La libertà di esprimere dichiarazioni razziste e blasfeme nella giurisprudenza della Corte europea dei diritti dell’uomo. Rivista internazionale dei diritti dell’uomo. 11, pp. 95-118.

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/907q8/the-united-nations-security-council-and-the-enforcement-of-international-humanitarian-law


Share this
Tweet
Email