Explaining the unintended consequences of public sector reform

Ghobadian, A., Viney, H. and Redwood, J. 2009. Explaining the unintended consequences of public sector reform. Management Decision. 47 (10), pp. 1514-1535.

TitleExplaining the unintended consequences of public sector reform
AuthorsGhobadian, A., Viney, H. and Redwood, J.
Abstract

Purpose – The process of public sector reform in the United Kingdom continues to provoke debate. Even among advocates of the reform process there is a concern that improvements in public service provision have not been as marked as originally intended, and that the process has produced a variety of unintended consequences. The purpose of this paper is to explore possible explanations for these unintended consequences, and discuss possible practical solutions for policy makers and service commissioners.

Design/methodology/approach – In this conceptual paper focus is in particular upon attempting to explain managerial behaviour from insights offered by two well-established managerial theories – stakeholder theory and resource dependency theory. Insights from these theories are used to explain the possible causes of the unintended consequences of the reform process. The discussion is illustrated and set in context by reference to a continuum of service delivery modes from monopoly provision through to full competition.

Findings – Theory suggests that managers inevitably prioritise the interests of what they identify as their key stakeholders, and particularly those providing critical resources. In the case of public services this means that the interests of government, as the commissioner and funder of services, are prioritised rather than the end-users of services. Examples of how this distorts the objectives of government are highlighted. It is argued that understanding this aspect of managerial decision-making and stakeholder prioritising opens up the potential to resolve the problem.

Originality/value – This is the first paper to address the question of managerial behaviour from these theoretical perspectives in the area of the public sector reform process.

JournalManagement Decision
Journal citation47 (10), pp. 1514-1535
ISSN0025-1747
Year2009
PublisherEmerald
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)doi:10.1108/00251740911004664
Publication dates
Published2009

Related outputs

Unpacking the mechanism by which corporate responsibility impacts stakeholder relationships
Hillenbrand, C., Money, K. and Ghobadian, A. 2013. Unpacking the mechanism by which corporate responsibility impacts stakeholder relationships. British Journal of Management. 24 (1), pp. 127-146.

Knowledge acquisition in supply chain partnerships: the role of power
He, Q., Ghobadian, A. and Gallear, D. 2013. Knowledge acquisition in supply chain partnerships: the role of power. International Journal of Production Economics. 141 (2), pp. 605-618.

Dynamic capabilities in a sixth-generation family firm: Entrepreneurship and the Bibby Line
Jones, O., Ghobadian, A., O'Regan, N. and Antcliff, V. 2013. Dynamic capabilities in a sixth-generation family firm: Entrepreneurship and the Bibby Line. Business History. 55 (6), pp. 910-941.

Corporate responsibility, supply chain partnership and performance: an empirical examination
Gallear, D., Ghobadian, A. and Chen, W. 2012. Corporate responsibility, supply chain partnership and performance: an empirical examination. International Journal of Production Economics. 140 (1), pp. 83-91.

Organic growth and shareholder value: a case study of the insurance industry
Kling, G., Ghobadian, A. and O'Regan, N. 2009. Organic growth and shareholder value: a case study of the insurance industry. International Journal of Research in Marketing. 26 (4), pp. 276-283.

Back to the future – organic growth driving shareholder value
O'Regan, N., Kling, G. and Ghobadian, A. 2009. Back to the future – organic growth driving shareholder value. 29th Annual International Conference of the Strategic Management Society. Washington D.C. 11 - 14 Oct 2009

Successful strategic re-orientation: lessons from Cadbury's experience: an interview with Todd Stitzer, Chief Executive of Cadbury
O'Regan, N. and Ghobadian, A. 2009. Successful strategic re-orientation: lessons from Cadbury's experience: an interview with Todd Stitzer, Chief Executive of Cadbury. Journal of Strategy and Management. 2 (4), pp. 405-412.

Interview with Sir Mike Rake, Chairman of BT
O'Regan, N. and Ghobadian, A. 2009. Interview with Sir Mike Rake, Chairman of BT. Journal of Strategy and Management. 2 (3), pp. 288-295.

Building a FTSE 100 company by hitting the sweet spot of strategy: an interview with Rod Aldridge OBE
O'Regan, N. and Ghobadian, A. 2009. Building a FTSE 100 company by hitting the sweet spot of strategy: an interview with Rod Aldridge OBE. Journal of Strategy and Management. 2 (2), pp. 188-195.

An empirical study of green supply chain management practices amongst UK manufacturers
Holt, D. and Ghobadian, A. 2009. An empirical study of green supply chain management practices amongst UK manufacturers. Journal of Manufacturing Technology Management. 20 (7), pp. 933-956.

Where do we fit in the swings and roundabouts of strategy?
Ghobadian, A. and O'Regan, N. 2009. Where do we fit in the swings and roundabouts of strategy? Journal of Strategy and Management. 1 (1), pp. 5-15.

An integrative framework for strategy process based on its theoretical roots
Ghobadian, A. 2009. An integrative framework for strategy process based on its theoretical roots. BAM 2009: British Academy of Management Conference 2009. Brighton Centre, Brighton 15 - 17 Sep 2009

A stakeholder identification and salience theory for non-traditional operating modes
Viney, H. and Ghobadian, A. 2008. A stakeholder identification and salience theory for non-traditional operating modes. British Academy of Management Conference 2008. Majestic Hotel, Harrogate 9 - 11 Sep 2008

Generic strategies and performance
Veeti, M.K., Ghobadian, A., O'Regan, N. and Gallear, D. 2008. Generic strategies and performance. British Academy of Management Conference 2008. Majestic Hotel, Harrogate 9 - 11 Sep 2008

Outsourcing: enhancing organisational performance
O'Regan, N., Sims, M.A. and Ghobadian, A. 2008. Outsourcing: enhancing organisational performance. Stretegic Management Society 28th Annual International Conference. Cologne 12 - 15 Oct 2008

Outsourcing: enhancing organisational performance
O'Regan, N., Sims, M.A. and Ghobadian, A. 2008. Outsourcing: enhancing organisational performance. British Academy of Management Conference 2008. Majestic Hotel, Harrogate 9 - 11 Sep 2008

Does R&D really drive competitive advantage and performance?
O'Regan, N., Ghobadian, A. and Sims, M.A. 2008. Does R&D really drive competitive advantage and performance? International Journal of Manufacturing Technology and Management. 15 (3/4), pp. 376-403.

Back to the future: a fresh look at Pearce and Robinson grand strategies
O'Regan, N., Ghobadian, A. and Kling, G. 2008. Back to the future: a fresh look at Pearce and Robinson grand strategies. 2008 Academy of Management Annual Meeting. Anaheim, California 08 - 13 Aug 2008

Ownership and the strategic behaviour of small and medium size manufacturing firms
Ghobadian, A., Urwin, P.J., O'Regan, N. and Buscha, F. 2008. Ownership and the strategic behaviour of small and medium size manufacturing firms. British Academy of Management Conference 2008. Majestic Hotel, Harrogate 9 - 11 Sep 2008

Formal strategic planning, operating environment, size, sector and performance
Ghobadian, A., O'Regan, N., Thomas, H. and Liu, J. 2008. Formal strategic planning, operating environment, size, sector and performance. Journal of General Management. 34 (2), pp. 1-20.

Drivers of strategic direction in high technology small firms
Ghobadian, A., O'Regan, N. and Sims, M.A. 2008. Drivers of strategic direction in high technology small firms. in: Groen, A., van der Sijde, P. and Cook, G. (ed.) New technology-based firms in the new millennium Bingley Emerald.

The middle ground – a dangerous place to be
Ghobadian, A. 2008. The middle ground – a dangerous place to be. Financial Times. 8 December 2008.

Digital/web-based technology in purchasing and supply management: a UK study
Gallear, D., Ghobadian, A. and O'Regan, N. 2008. Digital/web-based technology in purchasing and supply management: a UK study. Journal of Manufacturing Technology Management. 19 (3), pp. 346-360.

An explanatory study of partner selection and retention decisions and risk perceptions on buyers-suppliers partnership orientation
Gallear, D. and Ghobadian, A. 2008. An explanatory study of partner selection and retention decisions and risk perceptions on buyers-suppliers partnership orientation. British Academy of Management Conference 2008. Majestic Hotel, Harrogate 9 - 11 Sep 2008

An explanatory study of partner selection and retention decisions and risk perceptions on buyers-suppliers partnership orientation
Gallear, D. and Ghobadian, A. 2008. An explanatory study of partner selection and retention decisions and risk perceptions on buyers-suppliers partnership orientation. British Academy of Management Conference 2008. Majestic Hotel, Harrogate 9 - 11 Sep 2008

Comment & response: the implications of changing environments for business education
Ghobadian, A. 2008. Comment & response: the implications of changing environments for business education. Business Leadership Review. 5 (1), pp. 1-10.

The impact of ownership on small firm behaviour and performance
Ghobadian, A. and O'Regan, N. 2006. The impact of ownership on small firm behaviour and performance. International Small Business Journal. 24 (6), pp. 555-586.

The impact of management techniques on performances in technology-based firms
O'Regan, N., Sims, M.A. and Ghobadian, A. 2004. The impact of management techniques on performances in technology-based firms. Technovation. 24 (3), pp. 265-273.

Testing the homogeneity of SMEs: the impact of size on managerial and organisational processes
O'Regan, N. and Ghobadian, A. 2004. Testing the homogeneity of SMEs: the impact of size on managerial and organisational processes. European Business Review. 16 (1), pp. 64-77.

TQM implementation: an empirical examination and proposed generic model
Ghobadian, A. and Gallear, D. 2001. TQM implementation: an empirical examination and proposed generic model. Omega: International Journal of Management Science. 29 (4), pp. 343-359.

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/90x2x/explaining-the-unintended-consequences-of-public-sector-reform


Share this
Tweet
Email