Time and value at Bath Abbey: Erosion, fragmentation and the role of the replica

Littlefield, D. 2020. Time and value at Bath Abbey: Erosion, fragmentation and the role of the replica. ACHS 2020 Futures: the fifth biennial conference of the Association of Critical Heritage Studies. University College London, UK 26 - 30 Aug 2020

TitleTime and value at Bath Abbey: Erosion, fragmentation and the role of the replica
AuthorsLittlefield, D.
TypeConference paper
Abstract

Bath Abbey is undergoing a substantial programme of conservation and change; including the removal and reinstatement/replacement of the 847 ledger stones comprising its floor. The floor is, in fact, almost entirely comprised of these burial markers. These ledgers, however, were removed and repositioned in the 1860s, and no longer mark the remains of those buried directly beneath them. Present works will result in further repositioning, while those that are already damaged and/or eroded (or become damaged during the removal process) may not be reinstated at all.

My work, presently the subject of a public exhibition at the Abbey, addresses issues of time, erasure, authenticity and value. My study involves the use of photogrammetry to capture ledger stones which will likely not be reinstated. The digital and CNC-routed models of these stones record their present state as an authentic expression of their place in time; I argue that it is important to consider the status of the replica, especially one of an eroded and fragmented artefact, as something of value.

Digital techniques have already enabled partial replications of sensitive heritage sites; might they play a useful role in cultivating a response to time which, referencing Michael Shanks, considers the past as a “resource” subject to “creative process”? Can the replica, which captures (even ossifies) the present (itself the result of processes over deep time) become a useful object to serve the future? Which artefacts are deserving of such special attention and re-making? How is “pastness” or memory preserved or generated here: through form, or “aura”?

This work draws on the thinking of academics including Siân Jones, Cornelius Holtorf, Rodney Harrison, and Emma Waterton & Steve Watson who address heritage as an emergent product of a dynamic set of social relationships.

KeywordsHeritage, authenticity, replica, representation, interpretation, Bath Abbey, time, change, decay
Year2020
ConferenceACHS 2020 Futures: the fifth biennial conference of the Association of Critical Heritage Studies
Publication dates
Published26 Aug 2020
Web address (URL) of conference proceedingshttps://achs2020london.com/book-of-abstracts/
Web address (URL)https://achs2020london.com/
File

Related outputs

What is a thing? Considering the 'extended object' and the relationships from which it emerges.
Littlefield, D. 2023. What is a thing? Considering the 'extended object' and the relationships from which it emerges. London Conference in Critical Thought. London Metropolitan University 30 Jun - 01 Jul 2023

Plural Authenticities: How Can Digital Representation Enhance, Extend and Even Rival the Original Object?
Littlefield, D. 2023. Plural Authenticities: How Can Digital Representation Enhance, Extend and Even Rival the Original Object? in: Griffin, H. (ed.) (In)tangible Heritage(s): a conference on design, culture and technology - past, present and future Architecture, Media, Politics, Society (AMPS) Proceedings Journal Series. pp. 88-99

The agency of small things: indicators of ownership on the streets of Liverpool and Belfast
Littlefield, D. 2023. The agency of small things: indicators of ownership on the streets of Liverpool and Belfast. in: Martire, A., Hausleitner, B. and Clossick, J. (ed.) Everyday Streets: inclusive approaches to understanding and designing streets London UCL Press. pp. 17-32

A House and its Atmosphere
Littlefield, D. 2020. A House and its Atmosphere. Home cultures: The Journal of Architecture, Design and Domestic Space. 17 (3), pp. 233-237. https://doi.org/10.1080/17406315.2020.1954401

Replicas and representation – reflections on authenticity at Bath Abbey
Littlefield, D. 2020. Replicas and representation – reflections on authenticity at Bath Abbey. University of Stirling.

Creating Interior Atmosphere: mise-en-scène and interior design
Littlefield, D. 2019. Creating Interior Atmosphere: mise-en-scène and interior design. Interiors Design/Architecture/Culture. 9 (3), pp. 376-379. https://doi.org/10.1080/20419112.2019.1616925

Authentic reconstruction: authenticity, architecture and the built Heritage
Littlefield, D. 2019. Authentic reconstruction: authenticity, architecture and the built Heritage. International Journal of Heritage Studies. 25 (2), pp. 221-224. https://doi.org/10.1080/13527258.2018.1476399

Urban design, place and integration: A study of Liverpool one
Littlefield, D. and Devereux, M. 2019. Urban design, place and integration: A study of Liverpool one.

A literature review on the privatisation of public space
Littlefield, D. and Devereux, M. 2017. A literature review on the privatisation of public space.

Heritage and time: mapping what is not there
Littlefield, D. 2017. Heritage and time: mapping what is not there. in: Counsell, J., Mahdjoubi, L. and Arayici, Y. (ed.) Heritage Building Information Modelling Oxford Routledge. pp. 32-44

The living and the dead; an investigation into the status of erasure within the floor of Bath Abbey
Littlefield, D. 2016. The living and the dead; an investigation into the status of erasure within the floor of Bath Abbey. Interiors Design/Architecture/Culture. 7 (1), pp. 3-26. https://doi.org/10.1080/20419112.2016.1163957

Architecture and Culture / Transgression: body and space
Sara, R. and Littlefield, D. 2014. Architecture and Culture / Transgression: body and space. Architecture and Culture. 2 (3), pp. 295-304. https://doi.org/10.2752/205078214X14107818390513

Ashes thrown to the wind; the elusive nature of transgression
Littlefield, D. 2013. Ashes thrown to the wind; the elusive nature of transgression. in: Sara, R. and Mosley, J. (ed.) The Architecture of Transgression / Architectural Design Chichester Wiley. pp. 124-129

Installation and performance
Littlefield, D. 2013. Installation and performance. in: Brooker, G. and Weinthal, L. (ed.) The Handbook of Interior Architecture and Design London Bloomsbury. pp. 226-238

Datum
Littlefield, D. and Wilder, K. 2012. Datum.

Heritage at the Periphery; the York Street vaults, the Roman baths, Bath
Littlefield, D. 2012. Heritage at the Periphery; the York Street vaults, the Roman baths, Bath. in: Morrow, R. and Abdelmonem, M. (ed.) Peripheries Oxford Routledge. pp. 129-141

New Architecture Japan
Littlefield, D., Pollock, N., Sumner, E. (photographer) and Sumner, Y. 2010. New Architecture Japan. London, New York Merrell.

Good Office Design
Littlefield, D. 2009. Good Office Design. London RIBA.

Liverpool One: Remaking a City Centre
Littlefield, D. 2009. Liverpool One: Remaking a City Centre. London Wiley.

HOME: Investing in Design
Littlefield, D. 2008. HOME: Investing in Design. London Wiley.

Space Craft: developments in architectural computing
Littlefield, D. Littlefield, D. (ed.) 2008. Space Craft: developments in architectural computing. London RIBA.

Architectural voices: listening to old buildings
Littlefield, D. and Lewis, S 2007. Architectural voices: listening to old buildings. London Wiley.

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/vq14v/time-and-value-at-bath-abbey-erosion-fragmentation-and-the-role-of-the-replica


Share this

Usage statistics

116 total views
36 total downloads
These values cover views and downloads from WestminsterResearch and are for the period from September 2nd 2018, when this repository was created.