Violations of the Right to Property in Libya and the Promise of Transitional Justice

Fowler, Alexandra and Radan, Mohamed 2022. Violations of the Right to Property in Libya and the Promise of Transitional Justice. International Human Rights Law Review. 11 (1), pp. 62-96. https://doi.org/10.1163/22131035-11010001

TitleViolations of the Right to Property in Libya and the Promise of Transitional Justice
TypeJournal article
AuthorsFowler, Alexandra and Radan, Mohamed
AbstractAbstract Libya’s Law No. 4 of 1978, which authorised the confiscation of real estate from private owners and its redistribution to other needy citizens, reflected elements of a long debate at the international level about the human right to property. This article examines Law No. 4 against Libya’s obligations under international law and finds that it led to violations of the right to property for which redress still remains outstanding today. Noting also the extensive violations of property rights and displacement in Libya due to civil conflict since 2011, as well as previous ineffective efforts at transitional justice, the article argues for a new concerted attempt at a comprehensive property claims mechanism applying the Pinheiro Principles and complementary international instruments within a broad-ranging transitional justice process. More broadly, Libya’s experience lends weight to calls for encapsulating the right to real property in multilateral treaty form.
KeywordsLaw
Sociology and Political Science
JournalInternational Human Rights Law Review
Journal citation11 (1), pp. 62-96
ISSN2213-1027
2213-1035
Year2022
PublisherBrill
Accepted author manuscript
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.1163/22131035-11010001
Publication dates
Published online01 Apr 2022
Page range1-35

Related outputs

The Constitution of the United Kingdom: A Contextual Analysis, 4th edition by Peter Leyland (2021)
Fowler, A. 2023. The Constitution of the United Kingdom: A Contextual Analysis, 4th edition by Peter Leyland (2021). Public Law Review.

Comparing Australia’s Brereton Inquiry and New Zealand’s Burnham Inquiry: A Discussion
Lloydd, M., Cormier, M., Fowler, A. et al 2023. Comparing Australia’s Brereton Inquiry and New Zealand’s Burnham Inquiry: A Discussion. New Zealand Journal of Public and International Law.

The Shadow of Operation Northmoor: Salient Lessons for Australia’s Own Prosecutions
Fowler, A. 2023. The Shadow of Operation Northmoor: Salient Lessons for Australia’s Own Prosecutions. Australian International Law Journal.

Reparations for Afghan Victims of Australian War Crimes
Fowler, A. 2023. Reparations for Afghan Victims of Australian War Crimes. Centre for Law and Social Justice, University of Newcastle, Australia.

Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe’s Release may Depend on the UK Repaying its Debt to Iran – But can it Lawfully Pay?
Fowler, A. 2021. Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe’s Release may Depend on the UK Repaying its Debt to Iran – But can it Lawfully Pay? The Conversation.

Repaying Iran that Outstanding £400 million: What does International Law Say?
Fowler, A. 2021. Repaying Iran that Outstanding £400 million: What does International Law Say? The Conversation.

Australian War Crimes in Afghanistan: Prosecutions Face an Uncertain Road Ahead
Fowler, A. 2021. Australian War Crimes in Afghanistan: Prosecutions Face an Uncertain Road Ahead. International Law Association (Australian Branch).

Written Evidence on the Proposal for a Statutory Presumption Against Prosecution of Alleged UK War Crimes after a Period of Five Years
Fowler, A. 2020. Written Evidence on the Proposal for a Statutory Presumption Against Prosecution of Alleged UK War Crimes after a Period of Five Years. UK Parliament.

Blog post: Proposed Amendments to the Human Rights Act to Disadvantage UK War Crimes Victims
Fowler, A. 2020. Blog post: Proposed Amendments to the Human Rights Act to Disadvantage UK War Crimes Victims. OxHRH Blog.

Blog post: UK Accountability for War Crimes in Doubt
Fowler, A. 2020. Blog post: UK Accountability for War Crimes in Doubt. IELR Blog.

More than just 'Protecting Veterans’: How the UK Government Plans to Get Rid of the ECHR in Overseas Operations
Fowler, A. 2020. More than just 'Protecting Veterans’: How the UK Government Plans to Get Rid of the ECHR in Overseas Operations. Verfassungsblog. https://doi.org/10.17176/20200331-133123-0

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/vvzz6/violations-of-the-right-to-property-in-libya-and-the-promise-of-transitional-justice


Share this

Usage statistics

101 total views
145 total downloads
These values cover views and downloads from WestminsterResearch and are for the period from September 2nd 2018, when this repository was created.