Recognising and Addressing Unconscious Bias and Structural Inequalities: A Case Study Within Television Idea Development

Brown, L., Davies, R. and Oyebanjo, F. 2022. Recognising and Addressing Unconscious Bias and Structural Inequalities: A Case Study Within Television Idea Development. Alphaville: Journal of Film and Screen Media. 24, pp. 97-117. https://doi.org/10.33178/alpha.24.06

TitleRecognising and Addressing Unconscious Bias and Structural Inequalities: A Case Study Within Television Idea Development
TypeJournal article
AuthorsBrown, L., Davies, R. and Oyebanjo, F.
Abstract

This article examines the idea development process within the UK television industry and raises the question of who has power and agency within it. Recently, there has been much discussion within the television industry about the commercial and social imperative for greater diversity, inclusion and risk taking in programme making, in order to both represent and appeal to contemporary audiences. However, our research suggests that there is at the same time a sense of disempowerment, a feeling that television culture itself is inhibiting this change and that individuals can do little to influence it. Building on existing research in the creative industries, this case study draws on observations, interviews and surveys carried out within the context of a talent development scheme and wider consultation with television development professionals. We will discuss the reasons for these contradictory currents of feeling, including the ways in which unconscious bias may operate to perpetuate inequalities and exclusions. Our article proposes that recognising and addressing unconscious bias within the idea development process is an important element in the wider process of tackling structural inequality in the television industry through collective action and institutional change.

JournalAlphaville: Journal of Film and Screen Media
Journal citation24, pp. 97-117
ISSN2009-4078
Year2022
PublisherDepartment of Film and Screen Media at University College Cork
Publisher's version
License
CC BY-NC 4.0
File Access Level
Open (open metadata and files)
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.33178/alpha.24.06
Web address (URL)http://www.alphavillejournal.com/
Publication dates
Published2022

Related outputs

The Ultimate Event TV: How Happy Valley Defies Ageism and Sexism in the Television Industry
Brown, L. 2023. The Ultimate Event TV: How Happy Valley Defies Ageism and Sexism in the Television Industry. Reflections: A TV Foundation Review. 1 (1).

Script Development on Unscripted Television: Grand Designs & The Spectacle of the Reveal
Brown, L. 2022. Script Development on Unscripted Television: Grand Designs & The Spectacle of the Reveal. in: Taylor, S. and Batty, C. (ed.) The Palgrave Handbook of Script Development Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 71-86

Working together: Uniting screen educators and industry to support gender equality inside the academy and beyond
Brown, L. 2022. Working together: Uniting screen educators and industry to support gender equality inside the academy and beyond. Non Traditional Research Outcomes. 40.

Female Editors - a New Frontier
Brown, L. 2022. Female Editors - a New Frontier.

Lockdown in London – COVID reflections
Brown, L. 2021. Lockdown in London – COVID reflections. Non Traditional Research Outcomes.

Teaching Media Production: Understanding Unconscious Bias in Creative Idea Development
Oyebanjo, F, Brown, L. and Davies, R 2021. Teaching Media Production: Understanding Unconscious Bias in Creative Idea Development. Media Education Research Journal. 10 (1&2). https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.5763747

Women in Film: The Changing Landscape
Brown, L. 2021. Women in Film: The Changing Landscape.

BFF Thelma & Louise: Tanya & Lucy Revisit 30 Years On
Brown, L. 2021. BFF Thelma & Louise: Tanya & Lucy Revisit 30 Years On.

Media Making out of the Classroom: Best Practice in a Pandemic
Brown, L. 2021. Media Making out of the Classroom: Best Practice in a Pandemic. Teachers Talking: Media Education in the 21st Century, from Primary to HE. 13 Feb 2021

Memory gender and filming: Exploring Thelma & Louise
Brown, L. 2021. Memory gender and filming: Exploring Thelma & Louise. Viewfinder.

The Legacy of Thelma & Louise - A Panel Discussion
Brown, L. 2021. The Legacy of Thelma & Louise - A Panel Discussion.

Teaching media production: understanding unconscious bias in creative idea development
Brown, L., Davies, R. and Oyebanjo, F. 2021. Teaching media production: understanding unconscious bias in creative idea development. International Media Education Summit. Online 31 Mar - 01 Apr 2021

Grand Designs: Exploring the casting process in popular factual television
Brown, L. 2021. Grand Designs: Exploring the casting process in popular factual television. The Politics of Casting in Media Conference. Online 20 - 21 Nov 2021

Sound and Cinema: Past, Present and Future
Brown, L. 2020. Sound and Cinema: Past, Present and Future.

Live from the 2019 Edinburgh TV Festival - C21 Podcast
Brown, L. 2019. Live from the 2019 Edinburgh TV Festival - C21 Podcast.

Lightning Talk: Empowering Creative Talent
Brown, L. 2019. Lightning Talk: Empowering Creative Talent. 45th Edinburgh International Television Festival. Edinburgh 22 - 25 Aug 2019

Taking the Lead: Why we need more female bosses in the film & TV industries to close the real-life gender gap
Brown, L. 2018. Taking the Lead: Why we need more female bosses in the film & TV industries to close the real-life gender gap. Edge.

How to Make the Next Big Global TV Studio Hit
Brown, L. 2017. How to Make the Next Big Global TV Studio Hit.

Teaching TV studio production
Brown, L. and Duthie, L. 2016. Teaching TV studio production. BFI Media Conference. British Film Institute, London 01 - 30 Jul 2016

The TV Studio Production Handbook
Brown, L. and Duthie, L. 2016. The TV Studio Production Handbook. I.B. Tauris.

TV Production in the Academy: Bringing Commercial Practices into the Classroom
Brown, L. 2015. TV Production in the Academy: Bringing Commercial Practices into the Classroom. New Directions in Film & TV Production Studies for University of West of England & Royal Television Society Bristol. Watershed, UWE Bristol 14 - 15 Apr 2015

Creating Reality Television - The Programme Maker Viewpoint
Brown, L. and Duthie, L. 2015. Creating Reality Television - The Programme Maker Viewpoint. Kimposium! A symposium about all things Kardashian. Brunel University London 26 Nov 2015

Studio Television Production – How to make programmes within a Commercial and Academic Context
Duthie, L. and Brown, L. 2014. Studio Television Production – How to make programmes within a Commercial and Academic Context. Sightlines: Filmmaking in the Academy conference. Melbourne 24 - 25 Nov 2014

Mother's Day
Brown, L. 2014. Mother's Day. Sightlines: Filmmaking in the Academy conference. Melbourne 24 - 25 Nov 2014

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/x1q84/recognising-and-addressing-unconscious-bias-and-structural-inequalities-a-case-study-within-television-idea-development


Share this

Usage statistics

72 total views
39 total downloads
These values cover views and downloads from WestminsterResearch and are for the period from September 2nd 2018, when this repository was created.