You Should Never Look a Gift Horse in the Mouth: One-Size-Fits-All Compensation in Wrongful Conception

Clayton Thompson, J. 2012. You Should Never Look a Gift Horse in the Mouth: One-Size-Fits-All Compensation in Wrongful Conception. Westminster Law Review. 2 (1), pp. 73-96.

TitleYou Should Never Look a Gift Horse in the Mouth: One-Size-Fits-All Compensation in Wrongful Conception
AuthorsClayton Thompson, J.
Abstract

This article reconsiders the House of Lords decision in Rees v. Darlington Memorial Hospital NHS Trust (2003) and the decision to award a conventional award of £15,000 in all cases of failed sterilisation resulting in the birth of an unwanted child. In so doing, it briefly recites the history of the Wrongful Conception action and the unique facts of Rees. It then goes on the consider the implications of two fundamental aspects of the judgment. Firstly, it looks at the 'conventional award' itself and considers the reasoning behind the award and the effect that it has on our understanding of (particularly women's) reproductive autonomy. Secondly, it analyses the rather 'unique' judgment of Lord Scott and his decision to evaluate these cases using the possessory analogy of an unwanted foal; particular focus is given to the notion of parental 'choice' in these cases and whether mitigation (i.e. abortion or adoption) can ever be considered "reasonable".

JournalWestminster Law Review
Journal citation2 (1), pp. 73-96
YearSep 2012
PublisherUniversity of Westminster
Publisher's versionYou Should Never Look A Gift Horse in the Mouth - Jack Clayton Thompson.pdf
Web address (URL)http://www.westminsterlawreview.org/wlr7.php
Publication dates
PublishedSep 2012

Related outputs

All-or-Nothing: Mental Capacity, Autonomy and Consent
Clayton Thompson, J. All-or-Nothing: Mental Capacity, Autonomy and Consent.

Male Suicide, Masculinity and Vulnerability
Clayton Thompson, J. Male Suicide, Masculinity and Vulnerability.

The Rights Network: 100 Years of the Hohfeldian Rights Analytic
Clayton Thompson, J. 2018. The Rights Network: 100 Years of the Hohfeldian Rights Analytic. Laws. 7 (3).

The Rights Network: 100 Years of the Hohfeldian Rights Analytic
Clayton Thompson, J. 2018. The Rights Network: 100 Years of the Hohfeldian Rights Analytic. Preprints.

All or Nothing: Capacity, Vulnerability and Autonomy
Clayton Thompson, J. 2018. All or Nothing: Capacity, Vulnerability and Autonomy.

Let’s talk about sex: deception, ethics and consent
Clayton Thompson, J. and Brooks, V. 2018. Let’s talk about sex: deception, ethics and consent.

All-or-Nothing: Capacity, Vulnerability and Autonomy
Clayton Thompson, J. 2017. All-or-Nothing: Capacity, Vulnerability and Autonomy.

Law, Rights and Reproduction: Reproductive Autonomy in Ethical Rationalism
Clayton Thompson, J. 2016. Law, Rights and Reproduction: Reproductive Autonomy in Ethical Rationalism. PhD thesis University of Westminster Law

Task Competency in the Rights Analytic: Mental Health and the Justification for Rights and Duties
Clayton Thompson, J. 2016. Task Competency in the Rights Analytic: Mental Health and the Justification for Rights and Duties.

Rights, Rationality and Reproduction: Balancing Interests in the Abortion Debate
Clayton Thompson, J. 2016. Rights, Rationality and Reproduction: Balancing Interests in the Abortion Debate.

Avoiding Reproduction: Law, Rights and Morality
Clayton Thompson, J. 2016. Avoiding Reproduction: Law, Rights and Morality.

Rationality, Autonomy, Reproduction
Clayton Thompson, J. 2015. Rationality, Autonomy, Reproduction.

You Can't Always Get What You Want: A Gewirthian Model of Rational Autonomy in Abortion
Clayton Thompson, J. 2015. You Can't Always Get What You Want: A Gewirthian Model of Rational Autonomy in Abortion.

You Can't Always Get What You Want: A Gewirthian Model of Rational Autonomy in Abortion
Clayton Thompson, J. 2015. You Can't Always Get What You Want: A Gewirthian Model of Rational Autonomy in Abortion.

Rationality, Autonomy, Reproduction
Clayton Thompson, J. 2015. Rationality, Autonomy, Reproduction.

Revolt, Revolution and Evolution: Reimagining the Principle of Generic Consistency as a Device for Institutional Reform
Clayton Thompson, J. 2015. Revolt, Revolution and Evolution: Reimagining the Principle of Generic Consistency as a Device for Institutional Reform.

Law, Moral Rationality and Ideals: Modifying the Principle of Generic Consistency to Define Legal ‘Ideals’ as Part of Transparent Autonomy
Clayton Thompson, J. 2014. Law, Moral Rationality and Ideals: Modifying the Principle of Generic Consistency to Define Legal ‘Ideals’ as Part of Transparent Autonomy.

Transgender Freedom and the Law: A Liberal-Poststructural Discussion on McNally
Clayton Thompson, J. and Brooks, V. 2014. Transgender Freedom and the Law: A Liberal-Poststructural Discussion on McNally.

You Should Never Look a Gift Horse in the Mouth
Clayton Thompson, J. 2012. You Should Never Look a Gift Horse in the Mouth.

Ethics and Loss of Chance in Medical Causation
Clayton Thompson, J. 2011. Ethics and Loss of Chance in Medical Causation. Globalising European Bioethics Education.

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/8z2xx/you-should-never-look-a-gift-horse-in-the-mouth-one-size-fits-all-compensation-in-wrongful-conception


Share this
Tweet
Email