Transgender Freedom and the Law: A Liberal-Poststructural Discussion on McNally

Clayton Thompson, J. and Brooks, V. 2014. Transgender Freedom and the Law: A Liberal-Poststructural Discussion on McNally. Critical Legal Conference. University of Sussex 06 Sep 2014

TitleTransgender Freedom and the Law: A Liberal-Poststructural Discussion on McNally
AuthorsClayton Thompson, J.
Brooks, V.
TypeConference paper
Abstract

In R v McNally, gender deception is found capable of leading to the vitiation of consent to sexual intercourse and, in so doing, places restriction on the freedom of transgendered individuals in favour of cisgendered freedom. This paper seeks to challenge the standing of this decision by adopting a combined methodological approach between Deleuzian post-structuralism and Gewirthian legal idealism. In so doing, we attempt to show that the combination offers a novel and productive approach to contentious decisions, such as that in McNally. Our approach brings together post-structuralist corporeality which conceives of the body as material and productive, and Gewirth’s ‘agent’ to conceptualise the legal body as an entity which can, and should, shape judicial reasoning. It does this by employing the criterion of categorically necessary freedom on institutionalised practical reasoning. These ‘bodies of agents’ can be conceived as the underpinning and justificatory basis for the authority of the law subject to the morally rational Principle of Generic Consistency. This egalitarian condition precedent requires individualisation and the ability to accept self-differentiation in order to return to a status, which can be validly described as “law”. Ultimately, we argue that this theoretical combination responds to a call to problematise the connection made between gender discourse and judicial reasoning, whilst offering the opportunity to further our conceptions of law and broaden the theoretical armoury with which to challenge judicial reasoning in McNally. That is, a ‘good faith’ attempt to further and guarantee transgender freedoms.

KeywordsCriminal Law, Philosophy of Agency, Poststructuralism, LGBT Issues, Transgender, Sexual Offences and Rape, Legal Idealism, Principle of Generic Consistency, and R V McNally
Year2014
ConferenceCritical Legal Conference
Publication dates
Published06 Sep 2014

Related outputs

Rethinking Research Ethics in the Humanities: Principles and Recommendations
Kasstan, Jonathan R., Pearson, Geoff and Brooks, Victoria 2023. Rethinking Research Ethics in the Humanities: Principles and Recommendations. University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/w36yq

Mistress Ethics: On the Virtues of Sexual Kindness
Brooks, V. 2022. Mistress Ethics: On the Virtues of Sexual Kindness. Bloomsbury.

Sexual offences and to have done with the courtroom
Brooks, V. 2021. Sexual offences and to have done with the courtroom. in: Bartel, R. and Carter, J. (ed.) Handbook on Space, Place and Law Edward Elgar. pp. 61-70

A Recipe for Shocking the Urban Body
Brooks, V. 2020. A Recipe for Shocking the Urban Body . Lo Squaderno - Explorations in Space and Society . 56 (0), pp. 57-60.

Greer's 'bad sex' and the future of consent
Brooks, V. 2020. Greer's 'bad sex' and the future of consent. Sexuality and Culture. 24, pp. 903-921. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12119-019-09671-x

Fucking Law: the search for her sexual ethics
Brooks, V. Forthcoming. Fucking Law: the search for her sexual ethics. Zero Books.

Ethical awareness and socio-legal research in the UK
Brooks, V. 2019. Ethical awareness and socio-legal research in the UK. in: Mason, M., Creutzfeldt, N. and McConnachie, K (ed.) Routledge Handbook of Socio-Legal Theory and Methods Routledge.

Dude Looks Like a Lady: Gender Deception, Consent and Ethics
Brooks, V. and Clayton Thompson, J. 2019. Dude Looks Like a Lady: Gender Deception, Consent and Ethics. Journal of Criminal Law. 83 (4), pp. 258-271. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022018319834373

Interrupting the courtroom organism: screaming bodies, material affects and the theatre of cruelty
Brooks, V. 2019. Interrupting the courtroom organism: screaming bodies, material affects and the theatre of cruelty. Law, Culture and the Humanities. 15 (2), pp. 332-351. https://doi.org/10.1177/1743872114543767

All-or-Nothing: Mental Capacity, Autonomy and Consent
Clayton Thompson, J. Forthcoming. All-or-Nothing: Mental Capacity, Autonomy and Consent. Second UK Mental Disability Law Conference. University of Nottingham 26 - 27 Jun 2018

Male Suicide, Masculinity and Vulnerability
Clayton Thompson, J. Forthcoming. Male Suicide, Masculinity and Vulnerability. Second UK Mental Disability Law Conference. University of Nottingham 26 - 27 Jun 2018

Samantha's Suffering: why sex machines should have rights too
Brooks, V. Forthcoming. Samantha's Suffering: why sex machines should have rights too. The Conversation.

The Rights Network: 100 Years of the Hohfeldian Rights Analytic
Clayton Thompson, J. 2018. The Rights Network: 100 Years of the Hohfeldian Rights Analytic. Laws. 7 (3) 28. https://doi.org/10.3390/laws7030028

Fucking (with) Academia: Ethics, Epistemology, Method
Brooks, V. 2018. Fucking (with) Academia: Ethics, Epistemology, Method . Ways of Knowing: Epistemology and Law. University of Westminster 31 May 2018

Under the fucking skin: a whore and her hotel room door
Brooks, V. 2018. Under the fucking skin: a whore and her hotel room door. Lo Squaderno - Explorations in Space and Society . 48, pp. 59-62.

Fucking Law (A New Methodological Movement)
Brooks, V. 2018. Fucking Law (A New Methodological Movement). Journal of Organizational Ethnography. 7 (1), pp. 31-43. https://doi.org/10.1108/JOE-09-2017-0043

All or Nothing: Capacity, Vulnerability and Autonomy
Clayton Thompson, J. 2018. All or Nothing: Capacity, Vulnerability and Autonomy. Socio-Legal Studies Association 2018. University of Bristol, UK 27 - 29 Mar 2018

Let’s talk about sex: deception, ethics and consent
Clayton Thompson, J. and Brooks, V. 2018. Let’s talk about sex: deception, ethics and consent. Socio-Legal Studies Association 2018. University of Bristol, UK 27 - 29 Mar 2018

Fucking Law: A Female Autoethnographer's Sex Research
Brooks, V. 2017. Fucking Law: A Female Autoethnographer's Sex Research . 4th European Geographies of Sexualities Conference. Barcelona 13 - 15 Sep 2017

Fucking Law (A New Methodological Movement)
Brooks, V. 2017. Fucking Law (A New Methodological Movement). 12th Annual Ethnography Symposium . University of Manchester 30 Aug - 01 Sep 2017

F#cking research ethics through radical method: autoethnography and the field of environmental law
Brooks, V. 2017. F#cking research ethics through radical method: autoethnography and the field of environmental law . in: Brooks, V. and Philippopoulos-Mihalopoulos, Andreas (ed.) Research Methods in Environmental Law: A Handbook Gloucester, UK; Northampton, USA Edward Elgar. pp. 534-555

All-or-Nothing: Capacity, Vulnerability and Autonomy
Clayton Thompson, J. 2017. All-or-Nothing: Capacity, Vulnerability and Autonomy. Westminster Law School Seminar Series. University of Westminster, London 30 - 30 Nov 2017

Ethics beyond immanence: rupturing law’s method through sex research
Brooks, V. 2016. Ethics beyond immanence: rupturing law’s method through sex research. PhD thesis University of Westminster Law https://doi.org/10.34737/9z8wv

Law, Rights and Reproduction: Reproductive Autonomy in Ethical Rationalism
Clayton Thompson, J. 2016. Law, Rights and Reproduction: Reproductive Autonomy in Ethical Rationalism. PhD thesis University of Westminster Law https://doi.org/10.34737/9y598

Task Competency in the Rights Analytic: Mental Health and the Justification for Rights and Duties
Clayton Thompson, J. 2016. Task Competency in the Rights Analytic: Mental Health and the Justification for Rights and Duties. Inaugural UK Mental Disability Law Conference. University of Nottingham, Nottingham 30 Jun - 01 Jul 2016

Rights, Rationality and Reproduction: Balancing Interests in the Abortion Debate
Clayton Thompson, J. 2016. Rights, Rationality and Reproduction: Balancing Interests in the Abortion Debate. Gender and Sexuality: Identities, Institutions, and Intersectionality. University of Westminster 13 May 2016

Avoiding Reproduction: Law, Rights and Morality
Clayton Thompson, J. 2016. Avoiding Reproduction: Law, Rights and Morality. Graduate School Assembly. University of Westminster 16 Mar 2016

Rationality, Autonomy, Reproduction
Clayton Thompson, J. 2015. Rationality, Autonomy, Reproduction. Law Doctoral Seminar Series 2015. University of Westminster 28 Oct 2015

You Can't Always Get What You Want: A Gewirthian Model of Rational Autonomy in Abortion
Clayton Thompson, J. 2015. You Can't Always Get What You Want: A Gewirthian Model of Rational Autonomy in Abortion. HEAL Seminar Series. University of Southampton 25 Nov 2015

You Can't Always Get What You Want: A Gewirthian Model of Rational Autonomy in Abortion
Clayton Thompson, J. 2015. You Can't Always Get What You Want: A Gewirthian Model of Rational Autonomy in Abortion. HEAL Seminar Series. University of Southampton 25 Nov 2015

Rationality, Autonomy, Reproduction
Clayton Thompson, J. 2015. Rationality, Autonomy, Reproduction. LAW DOCTORAL SEMINAR SERIES 2015 . University of Westminster 28 Oct 2015

Revolt, Revolution and Evolution: Reimagining the Principle of Generic Consistency as a Device for Institutional Reform
Clayton Thompson, J. 2015. Revolt, Revolution and Evolution: Reimagining the Principle of Generic Consistency as a Device for Institutional Reform. University of Copenhagen Postgraduate Law Conference. Copenhagen, Denmark 29 Jan 2015

Law, Moral Rationality and Ideals: Modifying the Principle of Generic Consistency to Define Legal ‘Ideals’ as Part of Transparent Autonomy
Clayton Thompson, J. 2014. Law, Moral Rationality and Ideals: Modifying the Principle of Generic Consistency to Define Legal ‘Ideals’ as Part of Transparent Autonomy. Democracy, Rights & Reason(s). University of Westminster 13 Feb 2014

Sun, sea, sand and sex: the coastal sexuality of materially open legal subjects
Brooks, V. 2014. Sun, sea, sand and sex: the coastal sexuality of materially open legal subjects. 4th International Emotional Geographies Conference. University of Groningen, Netherlands 03 Jul 2013

Sex, law & posthuman encounters: an examination of sexual deviance at the coast
Brooks, V. 2014. Sex, law & posthuman encounters: an examination of sexual deviance at the coast. Democracy, rights and reason(s). University of Westminster 13 Feb 2014

No room for law in the folds of the soul: entangling and unraveling law and sexuality
Brooks, V. 2014. No room for law in the folds of the soul: entangling and unraveling law and sexuality. Creative Constraints. UCL 03 Nov 2014

Confronting law affectively: encounters of a Patpong sex tourist
Brooks, V. 2014. Confronting law affectively: encounters of a Patpong sex tourist. Law and Critique. 25 (3), pp. 289-309. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10978-014-9137-5

You Should Never Look a Gift Horse in the Mouth: One-Size-Fits-All Compensation in Wrongful Conception
Clayton Thompson, J. 2012. You Should Never Look a Gift Horse in the Mouth: One-Size-Fits-All Compensation in Wrongful Conception. Westminster Law Review. 2 (1), pp. 73-96.

You Should Never Look a Gift Horse in the Mouth
Clayton Thompson, J. 2012. You Should Never Look a Gift Horse in the Mouth. Westminster Law Review. University of Westminster

Ethics and Loss of Chance in Medical Causation
Clayton Thompson, J. 2011. Ethics and Loss of Chance in Medical Causation. Globalising European Bioethics Education.

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/8yq48/transgender-freedom-and-the-law-a-liberal-poststructural-discussion-on-mcnally


Share this

Usage statistics

515 total views
0 total downloads
These values cover views and downloads from WestminsterResearch and are for the period from September 2nd 2018, when this repository was created.