Law, Rights and Reproduction: Reproductive Autonomy in Ethical Rationalism

Clayton Thompson, J. 2016. Law, Rights and Reproduction: Reproductive Autonomy in Ethical Rationalism. PhD thesis University of Westminster Law

TitleLaw, Rights and Reproduction: Reproductive Autonomy in Ethical Rationalism
TypePhD thesis
AuthorsClayton Thompson, J.
Abstract

As medical technology has advanced, so too have our attitudes towards the level of control we can expect to hold over our procreative capacities. This creates a multi-dimensional problem for the law in terms of access to services which prevent conception, access to services which terminate a pregnancy and recompensing those whose choices to avoid procreating are frustrated. These developments go to the heart of our perception of autonomy.
In order to evaluate these three issues in relation to reproductive autonomy, I set out to investigate how the Gewirthian theory of ethical rationalism can be used to understanding the intersection between law, rights, and autonomy. As such, I assert that it is because of agents’ ability to engage in practical reason that the concept of legal enterprise should be grounded in rationality. Therefore, any attempt to understand notions of autonomy must be based on the categorical imperative derived from the Principle of Generic Consistency (PGC).
As a result, I claim that (a) a theory of legal rights must be framed around the indirect application of the PGC and (b) a model of autonomy must account for the limitations drawn by the rational exercise of reason. This requires support for institutional policies which genuinely uphold the rights of agents. In so doing, a greater level of respect for and protection of reproductive autonomy is possible. This exhibits the full conceptual metamorphosis of the PGC from a rational moral principle, through an ethical collective principle, a constitutional principle of legal reason, a basis for rights discourse, and to a model of autonomy.
Consequently, the law must be reformed to reflect the rights of agents in these situations and develop an approach which demonstrates a meaningful respect of autonomy. I suggest that this requires rights of access to services, rights to reparation and duties on the State to empower productive agency.

Year2016
FileClayton Thompson_thesis_2016.pdf
Publication dates
PublishedApr 2016

Related outputs

Dude Looks Like a Lady: Gender Deception, Consent and Ethics
Brooks, V. and Clayton Thompson, J. 2019. Dude Looks Like a Lady: Gender Deception, Consent and Ethics. Journal of Criminal Law. 83 (4), pp. 258-271. doi:10.1177/0022018319834373

All-or-Nothing: Mental Capacity, Autonomy and Consent
Clayton Thompson, J. All-or-Nothing: Mental Capacity, Autonomy and Consent. Second UK Mental Disability Law Conference. University of Nottingham 26 - 27 Jun 2018

Male Suicide, Masculinity and Vulnerability
Clayton Thompson, J. Male Suicide, Masculinity and Vulnerability. Second UK Mental Disability Law Conference. University of Nottingham 26 - 27 Jun 2018

The Rights Network: 100 Years of the Hohfeldian Rights Analytic
Clayton Thompson, J. 2018. The Rights Network: 100 Years of the Hohfeldian Rights Analytic. Laws. 7 (3). doi:10.3390/laws7030028

The Rights Network: 100 Years of the Hohfeldian Rights Analytic
Clayton Thompson, J. 2018. The Rights Network: 100 Years of the Hohfeldian Rights Analytic. Preprints. doi:10.20944/preprints201807.0183.v1

All or Nothing: Capacity, Vulnerability and Autonomy
Clayton Thompson, J. 2018. All or Nothing: Capacity, Vulnerability and Autonomy. Socio-Legal Studies Association 2018. University of Bristol, UK 27 - 29 Mar 2018

Let’s talk about sex: deception, ethics and consent
Clayton Thompson, J. and Brooks, V. 2018. Let’s talk about sex: deception, ethics and consent. Socio-Legal Studies Association 2018. University of Bristol, UK 27 - 29 Mar 2018

All-or-Nothing: Capacity, Vulnerability and Autonomy
Clayton Thompson, J. 2017. All-or-Nothing: Capacity, Vulnerability and Autonomy. Westminster Law School Seminar Series. University of Westminster, London 30 - 30 Nov 2017

Task Competency in the Rights Analytic: Mental Health and the Justification for Rights and Duties
Clayton Thompson, J. 2016. Task Competency in the Rights Analytic: Mental Health and the Justification for Rights and Duties. Inaugural UK Mental Disability Law Conference. University of Nottingham, Nottingham 30 Jun - 01 Jul 2016

Rights, Rationality and Reproduction: Balancing Interests in the Abortion Debate
Clayton Thompson, J. 2016. Rights, Rationality and Reproduction: Balancing Interests in the Abortion Debate. Gender and Sexuality: Identities, Institutions, and Intersectionality. University of Westminster 13 May 2016

Avoiding Reproduction: Law, Rights and Morality
Clayton Thompson, J. 2016. Avoiding Reproduction: Law, Rights and Morality. Graduate School Assembly. University of Westminster 16 Mar 2016

Rationality, Autonomy, Reproduction
Clayton Thompson, J. 2015. Rationality, Autonomy, Reproduction. Law Doctoral Seminar Series 2015. University of Westminster 28 Oct 2015

You Can't Always Get What You Want: A Gewirthian Model of Rational Autonomy in Abortion
Clayton Thompson, J. 2015. You Can't Always Get What You Want: A Gewirthian Model of Rational Autonomy in Abortion. HEAL Seminar Series. University of Southampton 25 Nov 2015

You Can't Always Get What You Want: A Gewirthian Model of Rational Autonomy in Abortion
Clayton Thompson, J. 2015. You Can't Always Get What You Want: A Gewirthian Model of Rational Autonomy in Abortion. HEAL Seminar Series. University of Southampton 25 Nov 2015

Rationality, Autonomy, Reproduction
Clayton Thompson, J. 2015. Rationality, Autonomy, Reproduction. LAW DOCTORAL SEMINAR SERIES 2015 . University of Westminster 28 Oct 2015

Revolt, Revolution and Evolution: Reimagining the Principle of Generic Consistency as a Device for Institutional Reform
Clayton Thompson, J. 2015. Revolt, Revolution and Evolution: Reimagining the Principle of Generic Consistency as a Device for Institutional Reform. University of Copenhagen Postgraduate Law Conference. Copenhagen, Denmark 29 Jan 2015

Law, Moral Rationality and Ideals: Modifying the Principle of Generic Consistency to Define Legal ‘Ideals’ as Part of Transparent Autonomy
Clayton Thompson, J. 2014. Law, Moral Rationality and Ideals: Modifying the Principle of Generic Consistency to Define Legal ‘Ideals’ as Part of Transparent Autonomy. Democracy, Rights & Reason(s). University of Westminster 13 Feb 2014

Transgender Freedom and the Law: A Liberal-Poststructural Discussion on McNally
Clayton Thompson, J. and Brooks, V. 2014. Transgender Freedom and the Law: A Liberal-Poststructural Discussion on McNally. Critical Legal Conference. University of Sussex 06 Sep 2014

You Should Never Look a Gift Horse in the Mouth: One-Size-Fits-All Compensation in Wrongful Conception
Clayton Thompson, J. 2012. You Should Never Look a Gift Horse in the Mouth: One-Size-Fits-All Compensation in Wrongful Conception. Westminster Law Review. 2 (1), pp. 73-96.

You Should Never Look a Gift Horse in the Mouth
Clayton Thompson, J. 2012. You Should Never Look a Gift Horse in the Mouth. Westminster Law Review. University of Westminster

Ethics and Loss of Chance in Medical Causation
Clayton Thompson, J. 2011. Ethics and Loss of Chance in Medical Causation. Globalising European Bioethics Education.

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/9y598/law-rights-and-reproduction-reproductive-autonomy-in-ethical-rationalism


Share this
Tweet
Email