Hopping, skipping or jumping to conclusions? Clarifying the role of the JTC bias in delusions

Fine, C., Gardner, M., Craigie, J. and Gold, I. 2007. Hopping, skipping or jumping to conclusions? Clarifying the role of the JTC bias in delusions. Cognitive Neuropsychiatry. 12 (1), pp. 46-77.

TitleHopping, skipping or jumping to conclusions? Clarifying the role of the JTC bias in delusions
AuthorsFine, C., Gardner, M., Craigie, J. and Gold, I.
Abstract

Introduction: There is substantial evidence that patients with delusions exhibit a reasoning bias - known as the "jumping to conclusions" (JTC) bias - which leads them to accept hypotheses as correct on the basis of less evidence than controls. We address three questions concerning the JTC bias that require clarification. Firstly, what is the best measure of the JTC bias? Second, is the JTC bias correlated specifically with delusions, or only with the symptomatology of schizophrenia? And third, is the bias enhanced by emotionally salient material? Methods To address these questions, we conducted a series of meta-analyses of studies that used the Beads task to compare the probabilistic reasoning styles of individuals with and without delusions. Results We found that only one of four measures of the JTC bias - "draws to decision" -reached significance. The JTC bias exhibited by delusional subjects - as measured by draws to decision - did not appear to be solely an epiphenomenal effect of schizophrenic symptomatology, and was not amplified by emotionally salient material. Conclusions A tendency to gather less evidence in the Beads task is reliably associated with the presence of delusional symptomatology. In contrast, certainty on the task, and responses to contradictory evidence, do not discriminate well between those with and without delusions. The implications for the underlying basis of the JTC bias, and its role in the formation and maintenance of delusions, are discussed.

JournalCognitive Neuropsychiatry
Journal citation12 (1), pp. 46-77
ISSN1354-6805
YearJan 2007
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)doi:10.1080/13546800600750597
Publication dates
PublishedJan 2007

Related outputs

How does drinking water affect attention and memory? The effect of mouth rinsing and mouth drying on children's performance
Edmonds, C.J., Harte, N. and Gardner, M. 2018. How does drinking water affect attention and memory? The effect of mouth rinsing and mouth drying on children's performance. Physiology & Behavior. 194, pp. 233-238.

Implicit mentalising during level-1 visual perspective-taking indicated by dissociation with attention orienting
Gardner, M., Bileviciute A.P. and Edmonds, C.J. 2018. Implicit mentalising during level-1 visual perspective-taking indicated by dissociation with attention orienting. Vision. 2 (1), p. 3.

'Spontaneous' Visual Perspective-Taking Mediated by Attention Orienting that is Voluntary and not Reflexive
Gardner, M., Taylor, D.A., Hull, Z. and Edmonds, C.J. 2018. 'Spontaneous' Visual Perspective-Taking Mediated by Attention Orienting that is Voluntary and not Reflexive. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology. 71 (4), pp. 1020-1029.

Developing cross-disciplinary education by facilitating collaboration within and between diverse teams
Gardner, M. 2017. Developing cross-disciplinary education by facilitating collaboration within and between diverse teams. Educational Developments. 18 (2), pp. 14-17.

Visual mismatch negativity to masked stimuli presented at very brief presentation rates
Flynn, M., Liasis, A, Gardner, M. and Towell, A. 2017. Visual mismatch negativity to masked stimuli presented at very brief presentation rates. Experimental Brain Research. 235 (2), pp. 555-563.

Dose-Response Effects of Water Supplementation on Cognitive Performance and Mood in Children and Adults
Edmonds, C.J., Crosbie, L., Fatima, F., Hussain, M., Jacob, N. and Gardner, M. 2017. Dose-Response Effects of Water Supplementation on Cognitive Performance and Mood in Children and Adults. Appetite. 108, pp. 464-470.

Embodied perspective-taking indicated by selective disruption from aberrant self motion
Gardner, M., Stent, C., Mohr, C. and Golding, J.F. 2017. Embodied perspective-taking indicated by selective disruption from aberrant self motion. Psychological Research. 81 (2), pp. 480-489.

Observed bodies generate object-based spatial codes
Taylor, A., Flynn, M., Edmonds, C.J. and Gardner, M. 2016. Observed bodies generate object-based spatial codes. Acta Psychologica. 169, pp. 71-78.

Strategy modulates spatial perspective-taking: evidence for dissociable disembodied and embodied routes
Gardner, M., Brazier, M., Edmonds, C.J. and Gronholm, P.C. 2013. Strategy modulates spatial perspective-taking: evidence for dissociable disembodied and embodied routes. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience.

Subjective thirst moderates changes in speed of responding associated with water consumption
Edmonds, C.J., Crombie, R. and Gardner, M. 2013. Subjective thirst moderates changes in speed of responding associated with water consumption. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience.

Drink availability is associated with enhanced examination performance in adults
Pawson, C., Gardner, M., Doherty, S., Martin, L., Soares, R. and Edmonds, C.J. 2013. Drink availability is associated with enhanced examination performance in adults. Psychology Teaching Review. 19 (1), pp. 57-66.

Water consumption, not expectancies about water consumption, affects cognitive performance in adults
Edmonds, C.J., Crombie, R., Ballieux, H., Gardner, M. and Dawkins, L. 2013. Water consumption, not expectancies about water consumption, affects cognitive performance in adults. Appetite. 60, pp. 148-153.

Sex differences in components of imagined perspective transformation
Gardner, M., Sorhus, I., Edmonds, C.J. and Potts, R. 2012. Sex differences in components of imagined perspective transformation. Acta Psychologica. 140 (1), pp. 1-6.

Empathic and non-empathic routes to visuospatial perspective-taking
Gronholm, P.C., Flynn, M., Edmonds, C.J. and Gardner, M. 2012. Empathic and non-empathic routes to visuospatial perspective-taking. Consciousness and Cognition. 21 (1), pp. 494-500.

Domain general mechanisms account for imagined transformations of whole body perspective
Gardner, M. and Potts, R. 2011. Domain general mechanisms account for imagined transformations of whole body perspective. Acta Psychologica. 137 (3), pp. 371-381.

Hand dominance influences the processing of observed bodies
Gardner, M. and Potts, R. 2010. Hand dominance influences the processing of observed bodies. Brain and Cognition. 73 (1), pp. 35-40.

Can illusory deviant stimuli be used as attentional distractors to record vMMN in a passive three stimulus oddball paradigm?
Flynn, M., Liasis, A., Gardner, M., Boyd, S. and Towell, A. 2009. Can illusory deviant stimuli be used as attentional distractors to record vMMN in a passive three stimulus oddball paradigm? Experimental Brain Research. 197 (2), pp. 153-161.

P36.42 Identification of a pre-attentive visual discrimination response
Flynn, M., Liasis, A., Gardner, M. and Towell, A. 2006. P36.42 Identification of a pre-attentive visual discrimination response. Clinical Neurophysiology. 117 (Supplement 1), p. 194.

Attentional demands of continuously monitoring orientation using vestibular information
Yardley, L., Papo, D., Bronstein, A.M., Gresty, M.A., Gardner, M., Lavie, N. and Luxon, L. 2002. Attentional demands of continuously monitoring orientation using vestibular information. Neuropsychologia. 40 (4), pp. 373-383.

Interference between postural control and mental task performance in patients with vestibular disorder and healthy controls
Yardley, L., Gardner, M., Bronstein, A.M., Davies, R., Buckwell, D. and Luxon, L. 2001. Interference between postural control and mental task performance in patients with vestibular disorder and healthy controls. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry. 71 (1), pp. 48-52.

Seeing how it's done: matching conditions for observer rats ( Rattus norvegicus ) in the bidirectional control
Ray, E.D., Gardner, M. and Heyes, C. 2000. Seeing how it's done: matching conditions for observer rats ( Rattus norvegicus ) in the bidirectional control. Animal Cognition. 3 (3), pp. 147-157.

Book review: Budiansky, S. (1998). If a lion could talk: How animals think. London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson. Pp. 234. ISBN 0297819321. £20.00 (Hbk). ISBN 0753807726. £7.99 (Pbk).
Gardner, M. 2000. Book review: Budiansky, S. (1998). If a lion could talk: How animals think. London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson. Pp. 234. ISBN 0297819321. £20.00 (Hbk). ISBN 0753807726. £7.99 (Pbk). Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology Section B. 53 (3), pp. 286-287.

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/91vy2/hopping-skipping-or-jumping-to-conclusions-clarifying-the-role-of-the-jtc-bias-in-delusions


Share this
Tweet
Email