The Influence of Dumping Bias on Timbral Clarity Ratings

Hermes, K., Brookes, T. and Hummersone, C. 2015. The Influence of Dumping Bias on Timbral Clarity Ratings. 139th Audio Engineering Society Convention. New York, USA 29 Oct - 01 Nov 2015 Audio Engineering Society.

TitleThe Influence of Dumping Bias on Timbral Clarity Ratings
AuthorsHermes, K., Brookes, T. and Hummersone, C.
TypeConference paper
Abstract

When listening test subjects are required to rate changes in a single attribute, but also hear changes in other attributes, their ratings can become skewed by “dumping bias.” To assess the influence of dumping bias on timbral “clarity” ratings, listeners were asked to rate stimuli: (i) in terms of clarity only; and (ii) in terms of clarity, warmth, fullness, and brightness. Clarity ratings of type (i) showed (up to 20%) larger interquartile ranges than those of type (ii). It is concluded that in single-attribute timbral rating experiments, statistical noise—potentially resulting from dumping bias—can be reduced by allowing listeners to rate additional attributes either simultaneously or beforehand.

KeywordsSpectral clarity
Automatic mixing
Listening test design
Psychoacoustics
Year2015
Conference139th Audio Engineering Society Convention
PublisherAudio Engineering Society

Related outputs

Factors influencing the spectral clarity of vocals in music mixes
Hermes, K. 2019. Factors influencing the spectral clarity of vocals in music mixes. Loughran, R. and Angus-Whiteoak, J. (ed.) Audio Engineering Society 146th Convention. Dublin 20 - 23 Mar 2019 Audio Engineering Society. https://doi.org/10.17743/aesconv.2019.978-1-942220-26-8

Enhancing creativity through automatic mixing research: testing spectral clarity predictors in the mix process
Hermes, K. 2019. Enhancing creativity through automatic mixing research: testing spectral clarity predictors in the mix process. in: Gullö, J.O. (ed.) Proceedings of the 12th Art of Record Production Conference Mono: Stereo: Multi – Stockholm 2017 Stockholm, Sweden Royal College of Music (KMH) & Art of Record Production. pp. 155-170

Optimizing vocal clarity in the mix
Hermes, K. 2019. Optimizing vocal clarity in the mix. in: Hepworth-Sawyer, R., Hodgson, J., Paterson, J. and Toulson, R. (ed.) Innovation in Music: Performance, Production, Technology, and Business UK Routledge.

Parameters of high quality mixes: EQ and spectral clarity
Hermes, K. 2017. Parameters of high quality mixes: EQ and spectral clarity.

Parameters of high quality mixes: EQ and spectral clarity
Hermes, K. 2017. Parameters of high quality mixes: EQ and spectral clarity.

Creativity, Collaboration and Workflow in Ableton
Hermes, K., Boon, H. and Gooderson, M. 2017. Creativity, Collaboration and Workflow in Ableton.

The harmonic centroid as predictor of single sound spectral clarity
Hermes, K. 2016. The harmonic centroid as predictor of single sound spectral clarity.

The harmonic centroid as a predictor of string instrument timbral clarity
Hermes, K., Brookes, T. and Hummersone, C. 2016. The harmonic centroid as a predictor of string instrument timbral clarity. Audio Engineering Society Convention. Paris, France 04 - 07 Jun 2016 Audio Engineering Society.

The harmonic centroid as predictor of single sound spectral clarity
Hermes, K., Brookes, T. and Hummersone, C. 2015. The harmonic centroid as predictor of single sound spectral clarity.

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/q1692/the-influence-of-dumping-bias-on-timbral-clarity-ratings


Share this
Tweet
Email

Usage statistics

32 total views
0 total downloads
2 views this month
0 downloads this month
These values are for the period from September 2nd 2018, when this repository was created

Export as