"Coming To Life" and Intermediality in the Tableaux Vivants of Magic Mirror and Confessions To The Mirror

Pucill, S. 2018. "Coming To Life" and Intermediality in the Tableaux Vivants of Magic Mirror and Confessions To The Mirror. in: Smith, V. and Hamlyn, N. (ed.) Experimental and Expanded Animation: New Perspectives and Practices Switzerland Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 231-255

Chapter title"Coming To Life" and Intermediality in the Tableaux Vivants of Magic Mirror and Confessions To The Mirror
AuthorsPucill, S.
EditorsSmith, V. and Hamlyn, N.
Abstract

Drawing upon the recent writing by Agnes Petho, the text examines the films Magic Mirror and Confessions To The Mirror in terms of their intermedial language. The main focus in the analysis is on the tableaux vivants that re-enact photographs by Claude Cahun, which according to Petho are the supreme examples of intermedial intensity.

A questioning of the duality of traditional categories of “animation–live action” is examined through the writing of Tomas Lamarre. This is applied to the way in which Cahuns’s photographs are enlivened or animated in the film. Borrowing Lamarre’s concept, what the tableaux vivants add to the original still image (Cahun’s photograph) is time, rather than movement. This idea is developed in the examples described where the re enacted image holds still, whilst voices and a soundscape create the movement within the film. Literal movement of the image, the agitational serves not to signify but to keep our attention to stay with the prolonged image.

Particular instances of intermediality are discussed both generally and through examples. This includes a theory of the auratic through the touch of the filmmaker. Finally, a discussion is had of the idea of inhabiting the place of Cahun as performer, which is heightened through the disorientation that is a consequence of the intermedial. Crossing time period and authorship is a central focus of the writing, which points to the significance of an artist animating the historical archive in film where uncovered historical narrative has the potential to be be brought into the present through direct means.

KeywordsIntermedial, Tableaux Vivants, Claude Cahun, Experimental Film, Expanded Animation
Book titleExperimental and Expanded Animation: New Perspectives and Practices
Page range231-255
Year2018
PublisherPalgrave Macmillan
Publication dates
Published19 Sep 2018
Place of publicationSwitzerland
ISBN9783319738727
9783319738734
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-73873-4_12
FunderUniversity for the Creative Arts
Web address (URL)https://research.uca.ac.uk/3893/
https://www.zippyframes.com/index.php/academic/experimental-and-expanded-animation-new-perspectives-gets-sas-norman-mclaren-award-best-scholarly-book-in-animation

Related outputs

Interview with Nina Danino and Sarah Pucill
Pucill, S. and Danino, N. 2025. Forthcoming. Interview with Nina Danino and Sarah Pucill. in: Experimental narrative film and women’s practices at the London Film-maker’s Co-operative Lux Productions.

Narcissus' 2013, b/w photograph
Pucill, S. 2024. Narcissus' 2013, b/w photograph. in: Michael Petre (ed.) Mirror Mirror: the use of reflection in Contemporary Art London Thames and Hudson Ltd.

Backcomb (16mm col, 1995, 6min)
Pucill, S. 2024. Backcomb (16mm col, 1995, 6min).

"Untitled II from 'Stages of Mourning' (2004) and 'Double Exposure' (2023)
Pucill, S. 2024. "Untitled II from 'Stages of Mourning' (2004) and 'Double Exposure' (2023). in: Flora Dunster and Theo Gordon (ed.) Photography, a Queer History Ilex Press.

'Double Exposure' 16mm+Digital, col+bw, 27min, UK premiere of the film was at Danielle Arnaud Gallery, London, December 2023, with a Q+A with the writer and curator Helena Reckitt
Pucill, S. 2023. 'Double Exposure' 16mm+Digital, col+bw, 27min, UK premiere of the film was at Danielle Arnaud Gallery, London, December 2023, with a Q+A with the writer and curator Helena Reckitt.

'Double Exposure' 16mm+Digital, col+bw, 27min, 2023 premiere at the Frankfurt Experimental Film Festival
Pucill, S. 2023. 'Double Exposure' 16mm+Digital, col+bw, 27min, 2023 premiere at the Frankfurt Experimental Film Festival.

'Between Women, British Experimental filmmakers in 1990s' curated by Sarah Pucill and Karola Gramman at Frankfurt Experimental Film Festival Sept 2023.
Pucill, S. 2023. 'Between Women, British Experimental filmmakers in 1990s' curated by Sarah Pucill and Karola Gramman at Frankfurt Experimental Film Festival Sept 2023.

'Double Exposure' 16mm+Digital, col+bw, 27min, 2023
Pucill, S. 2023. 'Double Exposure' 16mm+Digital, col+bw, 27min, 2023.

'Phantom Rhapsody' (16mm,bw,18min,2010. And The Impossible Realised in a Magic Mirror: Clips from Magic Mirror (16mm, b/w , 2013-2023) plus film stills
Pucill, S. 2023. 'Phantom Rhapsody' (16mm,bw,18min,2010. And The Impossible Realised in a Magic Mirror: Clips from Magic Mirror (16mm, b/w , 2013-2023) plus film stills. Vortic Curated online exhibition 17 Apr - 09 Jul 2023

Podcast: Interview and discussion between Juliet Jacques and Sarah Pucill on Pucill's film Magic Mirror
Pucill, S. 2023. Podcast: Interview and discussion between Juliet Jacques and Sarah Pucill on Pucill's film Magic Mirror.

Screening of 'Magic Mirror ' (16mm, 75min, 2013) at Lexi Cinema, curated by Juliet Jacques
Pucill, S. 2022. Screening of 'Magic Mirror ' (16mm, 75min, 2013) at Lexi Cinema, curated by Juliet Jacques.

Confessions to the Mirror
Pucill, S. 2022. Confessions to the Mirror. Cobra Museum, Amstelveen, Netherlands Spring 2021 and then Kunsthal Museum Gallery, Rotterdam 2022 21 May - 28 Aug 2022

“Eruption, rupture, suture and disruption” A text by Sarah Pucill on two films by Sandra Lahire, “Arrows “(1984) and “Night dances” (1995)
Pucill, S. 2022. “Eruption, rupture, suture and disruption” A text by Sarah Pucill on two films by Sandra Lahire, “Arrows “(1984) and “Night dances” (1995). in: Maria Palacios Cruz and Charlotte Proctor (ed.) ‘Cahier’ booklet to accompany a screening at Courtisane Film Festival, April/May 2021

Online Masterclass as part of 'Photo Film' research group I gave a masterclass presentation of my two films on the writer and photographer Claude Cahun
Pucill, S. 2021. Online Masterclass as part of 'Photo Film' research group I gave a masterclass presentation of my two films on the writer and photographer Claude Cahun.

'Confessions to the Mirror' (16mm, col 68min 2016)
Pucill, S. 2021. 'Confessions to the Mirror' (16mm, col 68min 2016) . Cobra Museum, Amstelveen, Netherlands 13 Sep 2020 - 10 Jan 2021

A Dialogue with Claude Cahun: Between Writing, Photography and Film in Magic Mirror and Confessions to the Mirror
Pucill, S. 2021. A Dialogue with Claude Cahun: Between Writing, Photography and Film in Magic Mirror and Confessions to the Mirror. in: Knowles, K. and Schmid, M. (ed.) Cinematic Intermediality: Theory and Practice Edinburgh Edinburgh University Press. pp. 194-201

Confessions to the Mirror Staged in an Exhibition
Pucill, S. 2020. Confessions to the Mirror Staged in an Exhibition. Cobra Museum, Amstelveen, Netherlands 13 Sep 2020 - 10 Jan 2021

Jersey Premiere Screening of Confessions to the Mirror
Pucill, S. 2020. Jersey Premiere Screening of Confessions to the Mirror. Jersey, Channel Islands May 2020

Frankfurt Screening: Confessions to the Mirror
Pucill, S. 2020. Frankfurt Screening: Confessions to the Mirror. Schirn Kunsthalle Frankfurt 13 Feb - 24 May 2020

Ottawa Art Gallery Screening: Confessions to the Mirror
Pucill, S. 2019. Ottawa Art Gallery Screening: Confessions to the Mirror. Ottawa Municipal Art Gallery 14 Sep 2019 - 09 Feb 2020

Garden Self Portraits after Claude Cahun and Marcel Moore
Pucill, S. 2019. Garden Self Portraits after Claude Cahun and Marcel Moore. Ottawa Municipal Art Gallery 14 Sep 2019 - 09 Feb 2020

Dortmund / Cologne Women's International Film Festival Official Selection: Confessions to the Mirror
Pucill, S. 2019. Dortmund / Cologne Women's International Film Festival Official Selection: Confessions to the Mirror. Dortmund, Germany 08 - 14 Apr 2019

UCL Art Museum Screening: Confessions To The Mirror + Q+A with Maria Walsh
Pucill, S. 2018. UCL Art Museum Screening: Confessions To The Mirror + Q+A with Maria Walsh. Bloomsbury Studio, UCL, London 22 May 2018

Bagdam Lesbian Festival, Toulouse, France, screening of Confessions to the Mirror
Pucill, S. 2018. Bagdam Lesbian Festival, Toulouse, France, screening of Confessions to the Mirror . Toulouse, France 29 Mar - 14 Apr 2018

BEEF Bristol Screening: Confessions To The Mirror and Q+A with Vicky Smith
Pucill, S. 2018. BEEF Bristol Screening: Confessions To The Mirror and Q+A with Vicky Smith. Cube Microplex Cinema, Bristol 20 Feb 2018

Encounters of the Space Between: a Collaboration with Claude Cahun in Magic Mirror and Confessions to the Mirror
Pucill, S. 2018. Encounters of the Space Between: a Collaboration with Claude Cahun in Magic Mirror and Confessions to the Mirror. à la croisée des approches et des disciplines. Dialogue intercontinental. CNRS, Site Pouchet, 75017 Paris 25 - 26 Jun 2018

White Cube, Bermondsey, London: Screening: Magic Mirror, Confessions To The Mirror
Pucill, S. 2017. White Cube, Bermondsey, London: Screening: Magic Mirror, Confessions To The Mirror. 28 Jun - 17 Sep 2017

Cinematek, Oslo: Screening of Confessions To The Mirror + Q+A Greg Pope
Pucill, S. 2017. Cinematek, Oslo: Screening of Confessions To The Mirror + Q+A Greg Pope. Cinemateket, Oslo 2010 - 2019

National Portrait Gallery: Screening of Confessions To The Mirror
Pucill, S. 2017. National Portrait Gallery: Screening of Confessions To The Mirror. National Portrait Gallery, London 09 Mar - 29 May 2017

Creteil International Women's Film Festival Official Selection: Confessions To The Mirror
Pucill, S. 2017. Creteil International Women's Film Festival Official Selection: Confessions To The Mirror. Maison des Arts, Place Salvador Allende, Creteil, Paris 10 - 19 Mar 2017

Alchemy Film Festival, Scotland Official Selection: Confessions To The Mirror (16mm, col, 68min, 2016)
Pucill, S. 2017. Alchemy Film Festival, Scotland Official Selection: Confessions To The Mirror (16mm, col, 68min, 2016). Heart of Hawick, Scottish Borders 02 - 06 Mar 2017

The Provocation of Intermediality in the Tableaux Vivants in Magic Mirror and Confessions To The Mirror
Pucill, S. 2017. The Provocation of Intermediality in the Tableaux Vivants in Magic Mirror and Confessions To The Mirror. Pratschke, K. (ed.) Photofilm: Sampling the Archive. GUGA (Centre of Architecture), in co-operation with the Metropolitan University, Budapest, Hungary. 19 Sep - 19 Nov 2017

BFI London Film Festival Premiere of Confessions To The Mirror (16mm col, 68min)
Pucill, S. 2016. BFI London Film Festival Premiere of Confessions To The Mirror (16mm col, 68min). BFI Southbank, London 05 - 16 Oct 2016

Confessions to the Mirror (16mm, col, 68min, 2016)
Pucill, S. 2016. Confessions to the Mirror (16mm, col, 68min, 2016). University of Westminster. https://doi.org/10.34737/qvq82

Confessions To The Mirror
Pucill, S. 2016. Confessions To The Mirror.

Alchemy Moving Image Art Festival, Official Selection
Pucill, S. 2015. Alchemy Moving Image Art Festival, Official Selection. Haiwick, Scotland

Roundtable Discussion: The Women of the London Filmmaker’s Co-op
Danino, N., Matthee, J., Novaczek, R., Pucill, S. and Syed, A. 2015. Roundtable Discussion: The Women of the London Filmmaker’s Co-op. The Moving Image Review & Art Journal (MIRAJ). 4 (1&2), pp. 164-179. https://doi.org/10.1386/miraj.4.1-2.164_1

Magic Mirror (exhibition)
Pucill, S. 2015. Magic Mirror (exhibition). The Nunnery Gallery, London 14 Apr - 14 Jun 2015

Magic Mirror
Pucill, S. 2013. Magic Mirror.

Phantom Rhapsody
Pucill, S. 2010. Phantom Rhapsody.

Fall in Frame
Pucill, S. 2009. Fall in Frame.

Taking My Skin
Pucill, S. 2007. Taking My Skin. Toronto, Canada 12 Apr 2007

Blind Light (2007)
Pucill, S. 2007. Blind Light (2007). 66 East 4th Street, New York, NY 10003 01 Dec 2007

The 'Autoethnographic' in Chantal Akerman's News from Home, and an Analysis of Almost Out and Stages of Mourning
Pucill, S. 2006. The 'Autoethnographic' in Chantal Akerman's News from Home, and an Analysis of Almost Out and Stages of Mourning. in: Hatfield, J. (ed.) Experimental film and video: an anthology Eastleigh, UK John Libbey. pp. 83-92

Stages of Mourning
Pucill, S. 2006. Stages of Mourning. 66 East 4th Street, New York, NY 10003 18 Nov 2006

The Question of the Subject and the Autobiographic in Artists Moving Image Practice
Pucill, S., Hatfield, J. and Reynolds, L. 2004. The Question of the Subject and the Autobiographic in Artists Moving Image Practice. Filmwaves Magazine. 24 (2), pp. 5-9.

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/q2wqv/-coming-to-life-and-intermediality-in-the-tableaux-vivants-of-magic-mirror-and-confessions-to-the-mirror


Explore this book chapter

Confessions To The Mirror
Pucill, S. 2016. Confessions To The Mirror.

A Dialogue with Claude Cahun: Between Writing, Photography and Film in Magic Mirror and Confessions to the Mirror
Pucill, S. 2021. A Dialogue with Claude Cahun: Between Writing, Photography and Film in Magic Mirror and Confessions to the Mirror. in: Knowles, K. and Schmid, M. (ed.) Cinematic Intermediality: Theory and Practice Edinburgh Edinburgh University Press. pp. 194-201

Garden Self Portraits after Claude Cahun and Marcel Moore
Pucill, S. 2019. Garden Self Portraits after Claude Cahun and Marcel Moore. Ottawa Municipal Art Gallery 14 Sep 2019 - 09 Feb 2020

Encounters of the Space Between: a Collaboration with Claude Cahun in Magic Mirror and Confessions to the Mirror
Pucill, S. 2018. Encounters of the Space Between: a Collaboration with Claude Cahun in Magic Mirror and Confessions to the Mirror. à la croisée des approches et des disciplines. Dialogue intercontinental. CNRS, Site Pouchet, 75017 Paris 25 - 26 Jun 2018

The Provocation of Intermediality in the Tableaux Vivants in Magic Mirror and Confessions To The Mirror
Pucill, S. 2017. The Provocation of Intermediality in the Tableaux Vivants in Magic Mirror and Confessions To The Mirror. Pratschke, K. (ed.) Photofilm: Sampling the Archive. GUGA (Centre of Architecture), in co-operation with the Metropolitan University, Budapest, Hungary. 19 Sep - 19 Nov 2017

Jersey Premiere Screening of Confessions to the Mirror
Pucill, S. 2020. Jersey Premiere Screening of Confessions to the Mirror. Jersey, Channel Islands May 2020

Frankfurt Screening: Confessions to the Mirror
Pucill, S. 2020. Frankfurt Screening: Confessions to the Mirror. Schirn Kunsthalle Frankfurt 13 Feb - 24 May 2020

Ottawa Art Gallery Screening: Confessions to the Mirror
Pucill, S. 2019. Ottawa Art Gallery Screening: Confessions to the Mirror. Ottawa Municipal Art Gallery 14 Sep 2019 - 09 Feb 2020

Dortmund / Cologne Women's International Film Festival Official Selection: Confessions to the Mirror
Pucill, S. 2019. Dortmund / Cologne Women's International Film Festival Official Selection: Confessions to the Mirror. Dortmund, Germany 08 - 14 Apr 2019

UCL Art Museum Screening: Confessions To The Mirror + Q+A with Maria Walsh
Pucill, S. 2018. UCL Art Museum Screening: Confessions To The Mirror + Q+A with Maria Walsh. Bloomsbury Studio, UCL, London 22 May 2018

Bagdam Lesbian Festival, Toulouse, France, screening of Confessions to the Mirror
Pucill, S. 2018. Bagdam Lesbian Festival, Toulouse, France, screening of Confessions to the Mirror . Toulouse, France 29 Mar - 14 Apr 2018

BEEF Bristol Screening: Confessions To The Mirror and Q+A with Vicky Smith
Pucill, S. 2018. BEEF Bristol Screening: Confessions To The Mirror and Q+A with Vicky Smith. Cube Microplex Cinema, Bristol 20 Feb 2018

White Cube, Bermondsey, London: Screening: Magic Mirror, Confessions To The Mirror
Pucill, S. 2017. White Cube, Bermondsey, London: Screening: Magic Mirror, Confessions To The Mirror. 28 Jun - 17 Sep 2017

Cinematek, Oslo: Screening of Confessions To The Mirror + Q+A Greg Pope
Pucill, S. 2017. Cinematek, Oslo: Screening of Confessions To The Mirror + Q+A Greg Pope. Cinemateket, Oslo 2010 - 2019

National Portrait Gallery: Screening of Confessions To The Mirror
Pucill, S. 2017. National Portrait Gallery: Screening of Confessions To The Mirror. National Portrait Gallery, London 09 Mar - 29 May 2017

Creteil International Women's Film Festival Official Selection: Confessions To The Mirror
Pucill, S. 2017. Creteil International Women's Film Festival Official Selection: Confessions To The Mirror. Maison des Arts, Place Salvador Allende, Creteil, Paris 10 - 19 Mar 2017

Alchemy Film Festival, Scotland Official Selection: Confessions To The Mirror (16mm, col, 68min, 2016)
Pucill, S. 2017. Alchemy Film Festival, Scotland Official Selection: Confessions To The Mirror (16mm, col, 68min, 2016). Heart of Hawick, Scottish Borders 02 - 06 Mar 2017

BFI London Film Festival Premiere of Confessions To The Mirror (16mm col, 68min)
Pucill, S. 2016. BFI London Film Festival Premiere of Confessions To The Mirror (16mm col, 68min). BFI Southbank, London 05 - 16 Oct 2016

Televised documentary: Interview with extracts from Magic Mirror and Confessions to the Mirror in the documentary 'Masquerades and Games: the Female Artists of Surrealism'
2020. Televised documentary: Interview with extracts from Magic Mirror and Confessions to the Mirror in the documentary 'Masquerades and Games: the Female Artists of Surrealism'.

Share this

Usage statistics

191 total views
0 total downloads
These values cover views and downloads from WestminsterResearch and are for the period from September 2nd 2018, when this repository was created.