The Bane of Chinese Civilisation: Pruning Gangtai Dramas and Meteor Garden

How Wee Ng 2026. The Bane of Chinese Civilisation: Pruning Gangtai Dramas and Meteor Garden. in: How Wee Ng (ed.) The Chinese Censorship Discourse on Television Dramas: Worrying about the Audience in Postsocialist China Routledge.

Chapter titleThe Bane of Chinese Civilisation: Pruning Gangtai Dramas and Meteor Garden
AuthorsHow Wee Ng
EditorsHow Wee Ng
Abstract

Focusing on the fraught reception of Gangtai television dramas, this chapter focuses on how their popularity from the 1990s to early 2000s provoked anxieties over vulgarisation, youth corruption, and cultural sovereignty. While commercially attractive and cost-effective for television stations, these dramas were framed as “spiritual pollutants” that degraded public taste and Chinese cultural values. Figures like Wang Shuo who was accused of vulgarisation for his tongsu works, ironically condemned Gangtai culture as vulgar, a stance shaped by his personal frustration with his daughter’s fandom. This chapter examines the discourse surrounding the highly popular Taiwanese idol drama Meteor Garden (2001), which was controversial for its depictions of school violence, celebrity worship, and effeminate masculinity. Its suspension prompted illegal circulation and discussions among students, parents, and teachers. Censorship proved productive, generating a domestic alternative, Meteor Showers (2009) that aligned with state-sanctioned youthhood and behaviour. The discourse surrounding the morally rehabilitated series revealed a gap between its high ratings and the conflicting moral views it provoked. Renowned playwright Wei Minglun, who championed women’s emancipation through theatre, condemned the fandom surrounding Meteor Garden. His defence of “individuality” in elite theatre while disqualifying its popular expressions on television reflects a deeper anxiety over the erosion of cultural authority.

Book titleThe Chinese Censorship Discourse on Television Dramas: Worrying about the Audience in Postsocialist China
Year2026
PublisherRoutledge
Publication dates
Published22 Jan 2026
ISBN9781003471684
9781032749549
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003471684-6
Web address (URL)https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003471684-6

Related outputs

Disarming the Knight-Errant: Remaking Wuxia in My Own Swordsman
How Wee Ng 2026. Disarming the Knight-Errant: Remaking Wuxia in My Own Swordsman. in: How Wee Ng (ed.) The Chinese Censorship Discourse on Television Dramas: Worrying about the Audience in Postsocialist China Routledge.

The Tremulous Hand Lifting Spirits: Contending Tongsu and Vulgarisation in Yearnings
How Wee Ng 2026. The Tremulous Hand Lifting Spirits: Contending Tongsu and Vulgarisation in Yearnings. in: How Wee Ng (ed.) The Chinese Censorship Discourse on Television Dramas: Worrying about the Audience in Postsocialist China Routledge.

When Is China: Playing with History in Tales of Qianlong and Towards the Republic
How Wee Ng 2026. When Is China: Playing with History in Tales of Qianlong and Towards the Republic. in: How Wee Ng (ed.) The Chinese Censorship Discourse on Television Dramas: Worrying about the Audience in Postsocialist China Routledge.

Who's Afraid of the Big Bad Youth: Disciplining Foreign Influences in Garrison's Gorillas
How Wee Ng 2026. Who's Afraid of the Big Bad Youth: Disciplining Foreign Influences in Garrison's Gorillas. in: How Wee Ng (ed.) The Chinese Censorship Discourse on Television Dramas: Worrying about the Audience in Postsocialist China Routledge.

Historical Context: Worrying about the Television Audience in Postsocialist China
How Wee Ng 2026. Historical Context: Worrying about the Television Audience in Postsocialist China. in: How Wee Ng (ed.) The Chinese Censorship Discourse on Television Dramas: Worrying about the Audience in Postsocialist China Routledge.

Introduction: Rethinking Censorship as Discourse, Articulatory Practices, Performance, and Dialogic
How Wee Ng 2026. Introduction: Rethinking Censorship as Discourse, Articulatory Practices, Performance, and Dialogic. in: How Wee Ng (ed.) The Chinese Censorship Discourse on Television Dramas: Worrying about the Audience in Postsocialist China Routledge.

Decolonising China on screen: curating cinemas of the Sinosphere for the university classroom
How Wee Ng 2025. Decolonising China on screen: curating cinemas of the Sinosphere for the university classroom. Media Practice and Education. Advanced online publication. https://doi.org/10.1080/25741136.2025.2600057

Working-class Masculinities in Postsocialist Chinese Television: Mediating (Im)potency and Reproducing Transnational and Localised Inequalities
Ng, H. 2024. Working-class Masculinities in Postsocialist Chinese Television: Mediating (Im)potency and Reproducing Transnational and Localised Inequalities. in: Border Masculinities in Literary and Visual Cultures London Palgrave Macmillan.

Queer Singapore Chinese Theatre: Staging Homosexuality, AIDS and Familial Acceptance
Ng, H. 2024. Queer Singapore Chinese Theatre: Staging Homosexuality, AIDS and Familial Acceptance. in: Queer Literature in the Sinosphere London Bloomsbury Academic. pp. 221-243

Performing Fear in Television Production: Practices of an Illiberal Democracy, by Siao Yuong Fong
Ng, H. 2023. Performing Fear in Television Production: Practices of an Illiberal Democracy, by Siao Yuong Fong. Television & New Media. 25 (4), pp. 405 - 408. https://doi.org/10.1177/15274764231215760

Articulating Silences around Death in Both Sides, Now: Medical Professionals Grappling with Grief
Ng, H. 2022. Articulating Silences around Death in Both Sides, Now: Medical Professionals Grappling with Grief. in: Rajendran, C. and Gough, R. (ed.) Changing Places: Drama Box and the Politics of Space Aberystwyth Performance Research. pp. 164-174

Mainstream Theatre
Ng, H. 2022. Mainstream Theatre. in: Drama Box: 30 Keywords Singapore Drama Box. pp. 48-55

Multilingual
Ng, H. 2022. Multilingual. in: Drama Box: 30 Keywords Singapore Drama Box. pp. 98-105

Dialectics as Creative Process and Decentring China: Zuni Icosahedron and Drama Box’s One Hundred Years of Solitude 10.0: Cultural Revolution
Ng, H. 2021. Dialectics as Creative Process and Decentring China: Zuni Icosahedron and Drama Box’s One Hundred Years of Solitude 10.0: Cultural Revolution. in: Asian City Crossings: Pathways of Performance through Hong Kong and Singapore London Routledge.

K. Rajagopal on making films for and on the ethnic minority in Singapore
Ng, H. 2020. K. Rajagopal on making films for and on the ethnic minority in Singapore. Asian Cinema. 31 (1), pp. 139-142. https://doi.org/10.1386/ac_00019_7

Boo Junfeng on funding, festivals and Chinese privilege
Ng, H. 2020. Boo Junfeng on funding, festivals and Chinese privilege. Asian Cinema. 31 (1), pp. 131-137. https://doi.org/10.1386/ac_00018_7

Unpacking the 'Singapore New Wave'
Fong, S.Y. and Ng, H. 2020. Unpacking the 'Singapore New Wave'. Asian Cinema. 31 (1), pp. 3-15. https://doi.org/10.1386/ac_00010_2

Taipei Golden Horse film awards and Singapore cinema: Prestige, privilege and disarticulation
Ng, H. 2020. Taipei Golden Horse film awards and Singapore cinema: Prestige, privilege and disarticulation. Asian Cinema. 31 (1), pp. 99-122. https://doi.org/10.1386/ac_00015_1

Drawing from Grotowski and Beyond: Kuo Pao Kun’s Discourse on Audiences in Singapore in the 1980s
Ng, H. 2020. Drawing from Grotowski and Beyond: Kuo Pao Kun’s Discourse on Audiences in Singapore in the 1980s. Inter-Asia Cultural Studies. 21 (2), pp. 238-250. https://doi.org/10.1080/14649373.2020.1759879

The Liminality of Decolonization, De-Cold War and Deimperialization: Boal’s Newspaper Theater and East Asian Popular Culture as Method in Drama Box’s Community Commedia Dell’Arte News Busters!
Ng, H.W. 2019. The Liminality of Decolonization, De-Cold War and Deimperialization: Boal’s Newspaper Theater and East Asian Popular Culture as Method in Drama Box’s Community Commedia Dell’Arte News Busters! Router: A Journal of Cultural Studies. (29), pp. 123-160. https://doi.org/10.6752/JCS.201906_(28).0002

Rethinking Censorship in China: The Case of "Snail House (Woju)"
Ng, H. 2015. Rethinking Censorship in China: The Case of "Snail House (Woju)". in: Bai, R. and Song, G. (ed.) Chinese Television in the Twenty–First Century: Entertaining the Nation Routledge. pp. 87-103

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/x4y88/the-bane-of-chinese-civilisation-pruning-gangtai-dramas-and-meteor-garden


Share this

Usage statistics

56 total views
0 total downloads
These values cover views and downloads from WestminsterResearch and are for the period from September 2nd 2018, when this repository was created.